Who would you prefer.......

[jdbulldog]

Polk in his prime or Cohen in his prime?

 

[57stratdawg]

With these bats? Cohen. Just holding out hope we'll see Cohen tweak things in the future offensively.

 

[patdog]

Polk had his faults, but 5 CWS trips from 1979-1990 plus 3 regional finals (equivalent to a super regional today) trumps anything Cohen has done so far. Granted, Polk never made the CWS finals, but he did finish tied for 3rd once.

 

[esplanade91]

Based on previous stints in the majors, this is probably the season that Buck Showalter gets fired. Time to bring him home!