Who is your choice for DC?

Lionville

All-Conference
Nov 23, 2005
1,686
2,594
113
He’s probably tired of this routine with outsiders. I say he promotes from within. Dex and Smiff co-DC’s. Connor to coach LB’s.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jpe6Fair

Georgia Peach

Senior
Oct 28, 2021
376
682
93
He’s probably tired of this routine with outsiders. I say he promotes from within. Dex and Smiff co-DC’s. Connor to coach LB’s.
The recent "outsider" hires have been pretty good, yes? I think he goes outside again because he will have something shiny to sell and will be able to attract quality applicants. There will be no shortage of interest across the country.
 
May 11, 2012
508
703
93
Do we need one? Cost-savings opportunity. Companies often do not fill open positions
CJF has made some great staff hires....and also a few clunkers. Just seems PSU has become a reclamation destination for coaches to go and look good then leave. Do Asst Coaches have buyout clauses in their contract? IIRC wasn't there a snafu when Shoop left for Tennessee? This 1 - 2 year turnover isn't good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ManxomeLion

Grant Green

All-American
Jan 21, 2004
4,201
5,675
113
CJF has made some great staff hires....and also a few clunkers. Just seems PSU has become a reclamation destination for coaches to go and look good then leave. Do Asst Coaches have buyout clauses in their contract? IIRC wasn't there a snafu when Shoop left for Tennessee? This 1 - 2 year turnover isn't good.
I seem to recall him saying that he likes to look at coordinators that are former HCs, so that is going to come with the territory. If you are consistently a really good team, you have to expect that you are going to lose coordinators to HC jobs anyway (see Alabama).
 

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,471
5,291
113
I seem to recall him saying that he likes to look at coordinators that are former HCs, so that is going to come with the territory. If you are consistently a really good team, you have to expect that you are going to lose coordinators to HC jobs anyway (see Alabama).
Tough to fit anyone into the vin diagram of both crossing paths with Franklin, being a former Head Coach, defensive experience (or even a geographical fit), etc. Mel Tucker? I'd say Pat Fitzgerald (and would love it), but don't think we'd go that route. Jim Leonhard? If we're really just looking for the Head Coaching experience and defensive minded, Gary Patterson or Ed Orgeron?
 

Grant Green

All-American
Jan 21, 2004
4,201
5,675
113
Tough to fit anyone into the vin diagram of both crossing paths with Franklin, being a former Head Coach, defensive experience (or even a geographical fit), etc. Mel Tucker? I'd say Pat Fitzgerald (and would love it), but don't think we'd go that route. Jim Leonhard? If we're really just looking for the Head Coaching experience and defensive minded, Gary Patterson or Ed Orgeron?
Fitz or Patterson would interest me. Not sure about Ed O.
Promoting from within not the worst idea.
 

Georgia Peach

Senior
Oct 28, 2021
376
682
93
Tough to fit anyone into the vin diagram of both crossing paths with Franklin, being a former Head Coach, defensive experience (or even a geographical fit), etc. Mel Tucker? I'd say Pat Fitzgerald (and would love it), but don't think we'd go that route. Jim Leonhard? If we're really just looking for the Head Coaching experience and defensive minded, Gary Patterson or Ed Orgeron?
Orgeron? Baggage. Fitzgerald? Baggage. Mel Tucker? Huge baggage. With many of the top players with eligibility returning he needs to make a safe and quality hire. Given next year's prospects it should be an attractive job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUJam

Erial_Lion

All-American
Nov 1, 2021
4,471
5,291
113
Orgeron? Baggage. Fitzgerald? Baggage. Mel Tucker? Huge baggage. With many of the top players with eligibility returning he needs to make a safe and quality hire. Given next year's prospects it should be an attractive job.
I had forgotten that Tucker has those issues...he's probably even more unlikely than Fitz. Whoever eventually takes a chance on Fitz again will be rewarded I'd think. But I don't expect it to be us.

I don't think that Orgeron's past would hurt his future prospects at this point.
 

PSUJam

Heisman
Oct 7, 2021
14,077
26,972
113
Have to pick a DC who's defense scheme fits our personel. Especially with how thin we now are at LB.
 

MrTailgate

All-Conference
Oct 19, 2021
992
1,834
93
I had forgotten that Tucker has those issues...he's probably even more unlikely than Fitz. Whoever eventually takes a chance on Fitz again will be rewarded I'd think. But I don't expect it to be us.

I don't think that Orgeron's past would hurt his future prospects at this point.
There are numerous reasons why Fitzgerald has not been visible. Those reasons are still ongoing so he isn’t most likely coaching anywhere next year, maybe longer. There is one BIG destination that makes sense for him and it’s not Penn St.
 
May 11, 2012
508
703
93
I seem to recall him saying that he likes to look at coordinators that are former HCs, so that is going to come with the territory. If you are consistently a really good team, you have to expect that you are going to lose coordinators to HC jobs anyway (see Alabama).
That being said....the obvious choice to me is Pat Fitzgerald.

Well I am unaware of issues with Fitzgerald thus maybe he isn't the obvious choice.....although I'd love it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Grant Green

Thorndike2021

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2012
901
2,035
93
Dick LeBeau might be a great choice. At 87 he would still be tougher than most of his players. But he seems to be enjoying his retirement.

Given this, Tim Banks would be my first choice. He's done very well at Tenn. Excellent recruiter, has worked well with CJF, and has become a proven DC in the SEC.

I could see CJF taking a run at someone like Ephraim Banda though. Banda was a Manny Diaz acolyte for quite a while and would run a similar scheme. He has some recruiting and NFL experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13 and flash86
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State running back Carson Hansen is now doubtful for Saturday's matchup with Rutgers
  2. 02 BWI Recruiting Inside Lasch: New 2027 RPM logged to kick off massive recruiting weekend for Penn State
  3. 03 BWI Football Penn State 3-2-1: Improving offense, leadership decisions and a test of consistency
  4. 04 BWI Recruiting Over 70 prospects now confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  5. 05 BWI Wrestling Which Penn State wrestlers are going to the CJ Morgan Invitational at Army? Here's the list, plus other thoughts