What is reviewable in baseball?

[TrueMaroonGrind]

How did they not review the play at 2nd and then go back and review the home plate play?

Is it up to the discretion of the home plate ump or is it just written in the rules somewhere?

That was a very frustrating series of plays.

 

[engie]

View attachment 6533

 

[Hankp22]

By those rules

It is correct to review that at the plate and they got it right.

The review rules should be revisited going forward though. If you're going to allow for the review, then I feel a coach should get one challenge per game for safe/out calls on the bases (similar to challenge flag in NFL).

For the purpose of tonight though, the review was conducted within guidelines.

 

[thekimmer]

The rules are dumb but they are what they are. SHould not have needed a review. The guy ball beat the runner by 10 feet. SS had to wait on him to get there to tag him. That was either crooked or just gross incompetence. I might have gotten throw out of the game over that one

 

[bruiser.sixpack]

I think our issue for the last 5 innings has been the inability to make their pitcher actually throw strikes across the plate. Like swinging at pitches that are 2 feet off the plate or 6 inches below the dirt in front of home.

But errors by the left side of the infield didn't help in the 7th.****

 

[TrueMaroonGrind]

I see. Other than making two terrible calls, they followed the rules. That said the rules made no sense and created an unfair advantage, partly due to the incompetencies of the second base coach. That needs to be fixed.