Was Pope's first year really that great?

howitis_rivals115807

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2001
4,951
1,537
113
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882
 

UkBluePrint

Sophomore
Mar 13, 2026
115
130
33
NO it wasn't. when i saw him get selected i KNEW....KNEW that this was the worst damn thing that could happen and sure enough, it was. He's absolutely pathetic. Could not believe that he was actually going to be the coach. Blew my mind but here we are...terrible again.
 

Catapult44

Sophomore
Jul 19, 2025
97
177
33
You really don't think we would have beat Texas and Vandy if we had Butler (or even Kriesa)? Probably beat Bama at home if Carr had been able to go (don't think Nelson goes for career high). Good chance we would have beat Arky if totally healthy. That would have made us a 2 seed with legit chance to make FF. As you pointed out, we did beat 2 FF teams when we were healthy.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,654
36,373
113
I think the big thing was that it was a better season than we expected. We were ranked all year long, made the sweet 16, a few players were pleasant surprises etc. I think the newness and excitement was strong enough and a few things fell into place that it gave us some hope.

Unfortunately, I think that kind of season is the ceiling for him rather than the norm.
 

howitis_rivals115807

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2001
4,951
1,537
113
I think the big thing was that it was a better season than we expected. We were ranked all year long, made the sweet 16, a few players were pleasant surprises etc. I think the newness and excitement was strong enough and a few things fell into place that it gave us some hope.

Unfortunately, I think that kind of season is the ceiling for him rather than the norm.
well we lost 12 games, got blown out a bunch, and had to comeback in alot of the games we did win. we just had a couple big wins that year that fooled us. Looking back we just as bad back then too.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
5,211
7,103
82
They weren't. They were like all of his teams. Wildly inconsistent. When your teams are soft defensively and rely on shooting the 3 well to be successful, this is the result. It's not sustainable. That team had dudes that knew how to play. Full of 4 and 5 year players. Even when healthy, they still laid eggs. It's just what his teams do, and it's too bad.
 

Wildcat_in_DC

All-Conference
Nov 25, 2025
1,593
2,845
113
beating Duke started it off on a positive note and then every loss you could just pivot back to that moment and make any excuse you want.

folks would say pope was unlucky with injuries, but i always felt he got lucky in his biggest wins. the 5 biggest wins that year: duke, gonzaga, ut x2 and uf
  • duke: 1-12 from three in the 2nd half, 4-24 for the game
  • gonzaga: 0-9 from three in the 2nd half
  • tenn game 1: took 45 three point shots, made 11 but that is a ton of 3s
  • tenn game 2: 3-18 from three
uf was a great win and was one of the best games i've seen in a while. you can always play the "what-if" game, but considering how bad defense/rebounding has been under pope i view these 3 point shooting numbers more of a team getting cold vs us playing great defense and causing missed shots.

if those teams just shoot bad from three instead of missing everything, pope probably loses half those games. in which uk is now a 5, 6 or 7 seed in the NCAAT. and his first year isnt viewed the same at all.

but at the end of the day.....he won those games.
 

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,654
36,373
113
well we lost 12 games, got blown out a bunch, and had to comeback in alot of the games we did win. we just had a couple big wins that year that fooled us.
All true. But when you put that together with the fact that he basically duct taped a team together in a month after he got hired, I still found it pretty impressive.
 

Padsfs07

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2013
4,073
4,002
108
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882


It was a good year for the most part. We were in the top 10 for half the season and ranked the entire time. We were a 3 seed in the tourney.

Also, while unranked is true, Clemson, Arkansas, Texas, Vanderbilt, and Georgia were all NCAA tournament teams. Ohio St was the only one not to be.
 

UkBluePrint

Sophomore
Mar 13, 2026
115
130
33
Pope's pregame to the players is probably something like, "Guys, tune out the nonsense on social media and understand that I love you. You've given your heart and soul and I understand the media and the UK fanbase. We can be cruel and unconditional. Just know we are growing you as young men to better in life that is far greater than basketball. Give me the best that you have and that's all anyone can ask from you."
 

Bleedin Blue in Ohio

All-Conference
Feb 3, 2013
557
1,173
93
Looking back had they not had the 2 come from behind wins vs Duke and Gonzaga the answer would be different but his first year was great. At least until the injuries mounted up. Healthy that team could have been final 4 good. Beat Duke, beat Gonzaga, beat Louisville, beat Florida (The National Champs), beat Tennessee twice, and went to sweet 16. Last year and so far, this year not close to great.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cats192

Padsfs07

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2013
4,073
4,002
108
beating Duke started it off on a positive note and then every loss you could just pivot back to that moment and make any excuse you want.

folks would say pope was unlucky with injuries, but i always felt he got lucky in his biggest wins. the 5 biggest wins that year: duke, gonzaga, ut x2 and uf
  • duke: 1-12 from three in the 2nd half, 4-24 for the game
  • gonzaga: 0-9 from three in the 2nd half
  • tenn game 1: took 45 three point shots, made 11 but that is a ton of 3s
  • tenn game 2: 3-18 from three
uf was a great win and was one of the best games i've seen in a while. you can always play the "what-if" game, but considering how bad defense/rebounding has been under pope i view these 3 point shooting numbers more of a team getting cold vs us playing great defense and causing missed shots.

if those teams just shoot bad from three instead of missing everything, pope probably loses half those games. in which uk is now a 5, 6 or 7 seed in the NCAAT. and his first year isnt viewed the same at all.

but at the end of the day.....he won those games.


But then you look at team totals for the season, and we were one of the absolute worst in giving up a lot of attempts, and one of the best in terms of lowest 3pt percentage allowed for the season. And that correlates with being terrible at rebounding. Then, last year, he brought those number back to the mean a little bit, without good results.

This year is like the first season so far, but the other teams are connecting.

His BYU teams, defensively, were somewhat similar btw, so it seems to be his defensive trait as a coach.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,211
113
It was a really good fun year with a few disappointments, especially considering the injuries. It was great to get to the Sweet 16 after dealing with Tourney disappointment for a few years.
 

Omega_X

Senior
Sep 7, 2026
370
671
93
lol no. It had moments but overall it was an average year for UK. That first year was the typical Pope year. Win a bunch of games nobody expected and turn around and lose games nobody expected. The next two years have been even worse than typical Pope years.

It’s also funny our fans all year said “this will be our worst team. These will be our worst players.” Even at the time I was very skeptical of that. That same sentiment has been said about Stein and this football team as well and again I’m not so sure about that. A lot of things went right in their first years and there’s players that played better than expected. Amari was a unicorn at center. He was critical to the offense. Our Oline is very good sans Wood and is critical to the offense. You aren’t going to go out and find better linemen for next year than Heard and Price.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,211
113
lol no. It had moments but overall it was an average year for UK. That first year was the typical Pope year. Win a bunch of games nobody expected and turn around and lose games nobody expected. The next two years have been even worse than typical Pope years.

It’s also funny our fans all year said “this will be our worst team. These will be our worst players.” Even at the time I was very skeptical of that. That same sentiment has been said about Stein and this football team as well and again I’m not so sure about that. A lot of things went right in their first years and there’s players that played better than expected. Amari was a unicorn at center. He was critical to the offense. Our Oline is very good sans Wood and is critical to the offense. You aren’t going to go out and find better linemen for next year than Heard and Price.
Hopefully Pope can land some good OL in the portal.
 

Johnnie Africa

All-Conference
Feb 27, 2003
1,198
3,689
113
It was a good year. Objectively in every way. Especially for a first year coach who put a 100% roster together in under one month. Go watch the Florida game at Rupp, one of the last games where the entire team was healthy for the most part and tell me that wasn’t a good team.
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,174
21,125
103
It probably felt better at the time than it actually was but I do feel that was his best constructed roster. Injuries to Butler, Krisa, Robinson and Carr really did that team in. Fully Healthy they were Capable of making a FF. I think you could give Pope 10 full seasons, and that would probably be his best roster.
 

BlueSince92

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
11,174
4,191
230
Nobody thought Pope’s first year as a whole was all that great. But when the offense was looking amazing and we had humiliated a stable of top 10 and top 15 teams and multiple independent respected national analysts were starting to make the case Lamont Butler was the best guard in the entire country, all before the wheels fell off the bus due to injuries, that part was pretty great. But have fun tearing down your straw man.
 

Reggie Noble

Senior
Jul 5, 2025
287
460
63
It was a good year. Objectively in every way. Especially for a first year coach who put a 100% roster together in under one month. Go watch the Florida game at Rupp, one of the last games where the entire team was healthy for the most part and tell me that wasn’t a good team.
Yeah, when he got the job the only uncommitted top50 player was Liam Mcneely who had decommitted from IU and was basically already going to UCONN and the UK recruits Knox, Richmond, Somto, Fland and JQ . The transfer portal also had already been raided bare by then. So, all things considered I thought he did well. I now know that it wouldn't have mattered if he got the job 6 months earlier, he wasn't going to get those recruits, new info.
 

Hitman206

All-Conference
Jul 11, 2009
930
1,169
93
Yeah, when he got the job the only uncommitted top50 player was Liam Mcneely who had decommitted from IU and was basically already going to UCONN and the UK recruits Knox, Richmond, Somto, Fland and JQ . The transfer portal also had already been raided bare by then. So, all things considered I thought he did well. I now know that it wouldn't have mattered if he got the job 6 months earlier, he wasn't going to get those recruits, new info.
If UK had got Chaz Lanier who went to Tennessee instead of Jaxson Robinson, that would have completed the team. They needed a guy who could create a shot with the shot clock winding down. I also wished Pope could have kept Thiero from transferring to Arkansas.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,211
113
It was a good year. Objectively in every way. Especially for a first year coach who put a 100% roster together in under one month. Go watch the Florida game at Rupp, one of the last games where the entire team was healthy for the most part and tell me that wasn’t a good team.
Pope needs to be fired and his first year was really good can both be true.
 

UKBB4Ever

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
2,482
4,398
113
It was just OK. Fun because it was different. But all the signs that we would be where we are now were evident then.

If you pointed them out you were a coiboy!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

TrueBluePhil

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2010
1,029
1,965
113
does compitition count for someones record. I agree mark pope is not a good fit but we have to include the whole picture. Pope has had a much tougher schedule in two years then Cal had in 15.

Here’s the season-by-season comparison of SEC teams in the NCAA men’s tournament while each coached Kentucky. Pope’s Kentucky tenure began after the 2024 tournament, so 2024 belongs to Calipari.

SeasonCalipari at KentuckyPope at Kentucky
2009–104—
2010–115—
2011–124—
2012–133—
2013–143—
2014–155—
2015–163—
2016–175—
2017–188—
2018–197—
2019–20Tournament canceled—
2020–216—
2021–226—
2022–238—
2023–248—
2024–25—14
2025–26—10
 

Cats4321

All-Conference
Nov 18, 2025
1,339
3,804
113
We exceeded my expectations with the relatively low amount of talent. Those guys wanted to be here, so it was a fun season. But people try to act like that was some national championship caliber team when looking back, but the reality was that they weren't really that good. I remember even saying a few times, "we aren't very good but I enjoy watching them compete ".

Ansley Almonor was one of my favorites ever. Not because he was a good player, but you could tell he was living a dream just playing at UK. He probably never expected to play at this level, so seemed to enjoy every minute of it. And he filled a very specific role pretty well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RedwoodHigh
May 4, 2015
10,748
13,920
86
I can’t speak for others but I had low expectations for that season seeing as Pope had a rebuild of sorts. He may have passed my expectations but that doesn’t mean it was a great season.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,211
113
does compitition count for someones record. I agree mark pope is not a good fit but we have to include the whole picture. Pope has had a much tougher schedule in two years then Cal had in 15.

Here’s the season-by-season comparison of SEC teams in the NCAA men’s tournament while each coached Kentucky. Pope’s Kentucky tenure began after the 2024 tournament, so 2024 belongs to Calipari.

SeasonCalipari at KentuckyPope at Kentucky
2009–104—
2010–115—
2011–124—
2012–133—
2013–143—
2014–155—
2015–163—
2016–175—
2017–188—
2018–197—
2019–20Tournament canceled—
2020–216—
2021–226—
2022–238—
2023–248—
2024–25—14
2025–26—10
Cal wanted the SEC to improve and it did. Not sure it helped him, but I give him credit for pushing the SEC to be a basketball league.
 

Major_Tom

Junior
Apr 16, 2010
974
319
56
I can’t speak for others but I had low expectations for that season seeing as Pope had a rebuild of sorts. He may have passed my expectations but that doesn’t mean it was a great season.
Same here. With any new coach, there’s a grace period. A coach’s first season is one to build upon. But we have regressed. That’s what makes it unacceptable. The trend is down, not up.
 

PastorofMuppets82

All-Conference
Mar 4, 2025
846
1,841
93
That season was "great" in context to what it should have been. All the top recruits already signed elsewhere (1 in the top 50 unsigned at the time of his hire), The portal already picked clean, Empty roster sans Travis Perry, no coaching staff. Year one was build the plane while flying it. I think almost every level headed fan expected it to be a building year, some short comings, nothing spectacular, but foundational for the future.

It was not a "great" year compared against other UK historical years. Some super elite wins, some baffling losses, and inconsistent play.

I mean there was a point where Amari Williams was our best option at point guard and we were still winning games (Butler out, Krissa out, Robinson out, and Travis Perry nearly unplayable). That would be like us asking Zyon Hawthorne to start at point for us without Zoom, Wilkins, or Williams out there. But with or without injuries, the fanbase needed that Sweet 16 to get over the heartbreak from the end of the Cal years and poor tournament outcomes. It was... hope... The hype going into year two was gaining momentum, people were starting to see the vision.

Then it turned out to be fools gold. I think Pope expected the brand to be more helpful in recruiting elite players and it was only good enough, with him at the helm, to be a bargaining chip and hat on the table. It gets us 90 percent of the way there, and he can't finish the last 10.

I don't think Penny Hardaway is a good coach. I don't think he's a stellar recruiter. But listening to his interview after they beat down Louisville was pretty revealing. They said Memphis only gave him $7 million for NIL. He had to put in $2.5 million himself out of his pocket to field the team HE WANTED. He stopped recruiting or talking to guys concerned about money or playing time. He went after what he called winners. Guys that were undersized, overlooked, had a chip on their shoulder, super physical, dawgs. They've beaten Iowa St, VCU, and UofL so far (lost to Vandy) with a 5'10" point guard averaging 24 pts a game who is as tough as they come on both sides of the ball. Small budget teams have to do this. I think Pope can't see the forest for the trees. They spend so much effort going after the top 20 players (high school) and don't even look for the dawgs. We got Mason Williams because we wanted his Dad on staff. An overlooked 3-4 star depending on which service you looked at, outside the top 100. He's raw, but he's got the most energy and hustle on the entire team. We certainly need the elite studs (2 probably each year), but give me those all heart with just enough athleticism to be dangerous guys who will almost kill themselves to win a game. We loved Pitino for findings guys like that, especially his early teams. Even Cal's better teams had glue guys that were more heart than talent. I honestly think our NIL budget makes us turn our nose up to the guys who are bargains for what they bring to the table. Then they blow up and we have to overpay to try and get them out of the portal later.

I think there is a reason the Athletic Department keeps making hires in the "player development and player evaluation" areas, with random different names for the men's basketball team. The previous staff (some of which are gone now and rightfully replaced with Mo and Aboyo) can't evaluate talent on it's own and just throw offers at the ON3 rankings top 25. Then throw money at them. Recruiting here is comical.
 

Im The Village Idiot

All-American
Sep 7, 2025
2,888
7,338
113
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882
Was Pope's first year "great"? No -- and I don't think the argument was ever that it was great. I think the argument was that it was good --- and I believe it absolutely was a "good" year, given the circumstances. After last season and now the opening to this one, I'm baffled as to how Pope managed to have the year he did in the 2025 season. A three seeded team that made the Sweet 16 and spent half the year in the AP top 10 was a good team, despite the bad losses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johnnie Africa

SlowWalkerSTL

Sophomore
Jun 12, 2023
122
144
43
The big wins overshadowed the bad losses. Honestly, if Cal would have had the same season, people wouldn’t be happy with the results.

Pope’s newness and the hope that we were going to turn around and become a top 5 team again every year allowed them to look past what we are seeing today. People also saw that he came in and had to put a team together within weeks, adding to what they were willing to overlook.

He put that team together pretty quickly and for what he had, he did okay. Since then, he’s had plenty of time to assemble his rosters and game plan/coach, which is even more concerning. You’d expect his first year to be his worst. Instead, what most would say is his best “team” yet is looking like we are going to struggle enormously.

I love Pope for what he did here as a player, but he was the wrong hire and I was concerned from the start. I hoped to be wrong. Unfortunately, it’s worse than I imagined it being.

The good news is that we’ve been here before. We’ve made bad hires to turn around and make the best hire imaginable. We can overcome a few bad years under a bad coach. We cannot make the wrong decision with the next one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Indiana takes down John Calipari, Arkansas ahead of showdown with Kentucky in Indy
  2. 02 KSR KSR Show, 11/18: Ask Anything Wednesday, live from 10-noon
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington
  4. 04 KSR KSR Today: Mark Pope previews Indiana, Will Stein previews Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky Drops Out of 12-Team Field in Latest CFP Top 25 Rankings