UL players suing NCAA

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
how much did U6 spend to reverse the NCAA punishment? No doubt in my mind U6 paid a ton with the best attorneys only to be shut down..Morgan,Morgan ,Morgan, and a bunch more Morgans must think they are supermen..
 

1Blouman

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2010
3,607
1,165
113
Ol Luke Hancock, Mr Do Gooder...

You knew this stuff was happening, yet refused to say anything. That speaks more about your morals than anything
Luke acting like the snowflake he is. "I have to put up with this everyday!" or some such thing he is saying. Maybe he didn't know. Why not? Montrezl, Chane and Russ certainly knew. Why didn't they tell him to come and join in the fun? Because they knew it was wrong but continued for 3 or 4 seasons worth. If Luke wants to sue somebody he should sue his teammates and McGee. They're the cause.
 

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
I tried googling the pic of Deng posing with Katina in Minardi...it gone....anybody got it to post?
 

55wildcat

Heisman
Jan 4, 2006
33,976
99,413
113
Luke acting like the snowflake he is. "I have to put up with this everyday!" or some such thing he is saying. Maybe he didn't know. Why not? Montrezl, Chane and Russ certainly knew. Why didn't they tell him to come and join in the fun? Because they knew it was wrong but continued for 3 or 4 seasons worth. If Luke wants to sue somebody he should sue his teammates and McGee. They're the cause.

I bet Luke was the one that leaked the info about "Three Will"....1000 % Luke knew about everything that went on
 

Glenn's Take

Heisman
May 20, 2012
13,078
15,419
113
I'll say this about Luke Hancock. If I was doing the hiring I wouldn't have cared at all about getting the championship taken away. I absolutely wouldn't hire him to do anything after this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1679859502

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
When they lose, John Morgan can claim he went to bat "for the people" against "the giants of industry" and he only lost because of technicalities that also allow the NCAA to use players like indentured servants. He may want to pay me now for the commercial I just wrote. Thats all this is about for John Morgan. He can't possibly be dumb enough to think he has any chance to win. This is all about marketing to a certain segment of the population.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 55wildcat and Ugoff

1Blouman

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2010
3,607
1,165
113
Luke organized the "Celebration" at 4th St. Live and now this lawsuit. I think he must be on the verge of a nervous breakdown. Snowflake probably cries himself to sleep just like Rick did.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,212
113
The first claim in the complaint is a false light claim for plaintiff Hancock. That claim might go through discovery. This is not going to be pretty for UL.

Wasn't it reported early on that Hancock was not involved in fiasco in Minardi Hall?
 

UKnCincy_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2008
3,504
4,024
0
The first claim in the complaint is a false light claim for plaintiff Hancock. That claim might go through discovery. This is not going to be pretty for UL.

Wasn't it reported early on that Hancock was not involved in fiasco in Minardi Hall?

This won’t go through discovery. The NCAA was very clear in their decisions and press realeases by explicitly stating that some, but not all, athletes competed while ineligible after receiving extra benefits.

In no way did the NCAA ever imply that all players on the team were involved. If people are busting Hancock’s chops about this at work then it’s because those people were either too lazy to understand the facts or simply wanted to give him a hard time. It’s not because the NCAA portrayed Hancock specifically in a misleading fashion.

In either case, that’s not the NCAA’s fault. It sucks for Hancock if he didn’t particpate and gets labeled by this, but sometimes that kind of stuff just happens and there’s nothing you can do about it. It would be similar to if you were a great, honest accountant but people are hesitant to trust and use you because you worked at Arthur Anderson at the time of the Enron scandal. That fact may cause legitimate harm, but that doesn’t mean it was the result of someone portraying you in a false light. People simply make unfair associations sometimes.

This lawsuit is a joke and nothing but a publicity stunt by Morgan and Morgan.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,212
113
This won’t go through discovery. The NCAA was very clear in their decisions and press realeases by explicitly stating that some, but not all, athletes competed while ineligible after receiving extra benefits.

In no way did the NCAA ever imply that all players on the team were involved. If people are busting Hancock’s chops about this at work then it’s because those people were either too lazy to understand the facts or simply wanted to give him a hard time. It’s not because the NCAA portrayed Hancock specifically in a misleading fashion.

In either case, that’s not the NCAA’s fault. It sucks for Hancock if he didn’t particpate and gets labeled by this, but sometimes that kind of stuff just happens and there’s nothing you can do about it. It would be similar to if you were a great, honest accountant but people are hesitant to trust and use you because you worked at Arthur Anderson at the time of the Enron scandal. That fact may cause legitimate harm, but that doesn’t mean it was the result of someone portraying you in a false light. People simply make unfair associations sometimes.

This lawsuit is a joke and nothing but a publicity stunt by Morgan and Morgan.

Maybe. It’s not necessarily easy to win summary judgment at an early stage in litigation. But, you may be right.
 
Nov 15, 2008
38,645
57,515
0
 

UKnCincy_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2008
3,504
4,024
0
Maybe. It’s not necessarily easy to win summary judgment at an early stage in litigation. But, you may be right.

That’s fair and you’re right, I’m probably being aggressive on my prediction.

Longer term though, I can’t see any possible way that this goes anywhere.
 
Nov 27, 2009
21,246
21,450
0
When they lose, John Morgan can claim he went to bat "for the people" against "the giants of industry" and he only lost because of technicalities that also allow the NCAA to use players like indentured servants. He may want to pay me now for the commercial I just wrote. Thats all this is about for John Morgan. He can't possibly be dumb enough to think he has any chance to win. This is all about marketing to a certain segment of the population.
This has nothing at all to do with marketing or advertisement. That is why they chose a small/non descript backdrop for the press conference. Handjob and U6 are a losers.
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
This has nothing at all to do with marketing or advertisement. That is why they chose a small/non descript backdrop for the press conference. Handjob and U6 are a losers.
Yes it does. He has zero chance and he knows it. The players may not know it but Morgan does. The man doesn't even understand the NCAA rules.
 

Pickle_Rick

All-American
Oct 8, 2017
4,358
6,636
0
I think ya'll missin' the "big picture". Morgan &etc, is getting a foot in the door. Next comes the lawsuit about NCAA makin' money off the backs of the poor, and innocent playa's. Expect thousands of letters to hit the postal service asking players to join in a class action suit. And they will get 'em. Every dummy that went to schools and just partied, dropped out, or failed in the NBA will be looking for dat cash money. This could bankrupt the NCAA with the right jury, and judge.
 

Orionorl

Senior
Apr 2, 2006
908
570
0
Too funny. John Morgan grew up in Lexington. He moved to Florida and got his law degree from UF. He's not the brightest legal bulb in his family. That would be his wife.

But he is a fine marketer, and hires smart lawyers away from good firms. He started doing class action stuff with money he made from fender bender settlements, which he got from pounding the Orlando TV stations with ads after ads. He now has hundreds of lawyers. He will never open his mouth in this case away from a TV camera.

There is a big settlement somewhere in this case. He has more lawyers than the NCAA. He will play them to death.
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
Too funny. John Morgan grew up in Lexington. He moved to Florida and got his law degree from UF. He's not the brightest legal bulb in his family. That would be his wife.

But he is a fine marketer, and hires smart lawyers away from good firms. He started doing class action stuff with money he made from fender bender settlements, which he got from pounding the Orlando TV stations with ads after ads. He now has hundreds of lawyers. He will never open his mouth in this case away from a TV camera.

There is a big settlement somewhere in this case. He has more lawyers than the NCAA. He will play them to death.
This will get dismissed before it even makes it to trial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKWildcatT

UKnCincy_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2008
3,504
4,024
0
Had a chance to read the complaint they filed and my first reaction was: John Morgan is further evidence that there are too many law schools in the US churning out too many lawyers.

A key piece of their complaint is that the vacated wins were the property of Hancock, et al. When the NCAA vacated the wins, they essentially stole the players property. The players are suing to get that property back.

Ponder that for a second. Property is not only something you own, but something where you can also transfer that ownership to another party.

That means that if a win is property, then it would follow that any player should be able to transfer those wins to whomever they wish. If I want to buy the wins awarded to John Wall, does that mean the NCAA must update the records to add my name?

This is like something out of Alice in Wonderland. I can’t fathom a judge taking that seriously. The only property here is the record book, and the NCAA is and always has been the sole owner and keeper of the record book. The wins are merely whatever notations the NCAA chooses to make in the record book.

Sorry, but this kind of garbage from attorneys infuriates me. I’m done with my rant.
 

UKnCincy_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2008
3,504
4,024
0
One last thought on John Morgan’s “brilliance”. Vacating a win simply means that the NCAA no longer acknowledges it happened. So for the wins to be property, that essentially means that what you own is control over whether the NCAA acknowledges that an event occurred.

That would also mean you own the right to demand that the NCAA cease recognizing any wins you own. In the one in 10 trillion chance that some judge runs with this, then anyone could go out and buy the wins from players and then demand the NCAA stop recognizing them.

Would be pretty funny if UL got this back only to have an army of UK fans start buying wins from UL players who may need cash and start vacating every season UL ever played.
 

Orionorl

Senior
Apr 2, 2006
908
570
0
One last thought on John Morgan’s “brilliance”. Vacating a win simply means that the NCAA no longer acknowledges it happened. So for the wins to be property, that essentially means that what you own is control over whether the NCAA acknowledges that an event occurred.

That would also mean you own the right to demand that the NCAA cease recognizing any wins you own. In the one in 10 trillion chance that some judge runs with this, then anyone could go out and buy the wins from players and then demand the NCAA stop recognizing them.

Would be pretty funny if UL got this back only to have an army of UK fans start buying wins from UL players who may need cash and start vacating every season UL ever played.
You all are making the mistake that you think Morgan will be handling this case. He will not. I can't recall him being in a courtroom except to take pictures in at least 20 years. He has class action lawyers that will pound the hell of the NCAA lawyers, and they don't mind appealing and keeping the pressure up. The guy's firm has made a BILLION (with a 'b'), on 5 billion recovery. They are not going to file suit on any case where it's assured they get bounced on a quick Motion to Dismiss. There are YEARS of discovery...they know something that makes it worthwhile to take the monetary risk. (Though he DID screw up supporting Hillary (he gave her a million plus). Her loss pissed him off so much he quit the Democratic Party.)

He's too short and fat to be an ambulance chaser. He couldn't run across the street. He made his money advertising. 1st or 2nd in the US on advertising.
 

UKnCincy_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2008
3,504
4,024
0
You all are making the mistake that you think Morgan will be handling this case. He will not. I can't recall him being in a courtroom except to take pictures in at least 20 years. He has class action lawyers that will pound the hell of the NCAA lawyers, and they don't mind appealing and keeping the pressure up. The guy's firm has made a BILLION (with a 'b'), on 5 billion recovery. They are not going to file suit on any case where it's assured they get bounced on a quick Motion to Dismiss. There are YEARS of discovery...they know something that makes it worthwhile to take the monetary risk. (Though he DID screw up supporting Hillary (he gave her a million plus). Her loss pissed him off so much he quit the Democratic Party.)

He's too short and fat to be an ambulance chaser. He couldn't run across the street. He made his money advertising. 1st or 2nd in the US on advertising.

I don’t think Morgan will be handling the case.

I’m simply talking about what’s in the actual complaint that was filed with the court, which I’m sure he reviewed before it was submitted.
 

Orionorl

Senior
Apr 2, 2006
908
570
0
I don’t think Morgan will be handling the case.

I’m simply talking about what’s in the actual complaint that was filed with the court, which I’m sure he reviewed before it was submitted.
Then you don't know John Morgan. Again, hundreds of lawyers in that firm. I am not sure he would know what he was reading. 'Eh' as a lawyer. 'Wow!' as a marketer.
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
Maybe. It’s not necessarily easy to win summary judgment at an early stage in litigation. But, you may be right.
Maybe but I doubt the case even survives a request for dismissal. It has got me thinking though. I wonder if this is really a ploy to get UL to pay them to shut it down. They have to know they can't beat the NCAA and they have to know UL doesn't want this publicity going on.....I wonder.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sambowieshin_rivals

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
You all are making the mistake that you think Morgan will be handling this case. He will not. I can't recall him being in a courtroom except to take pictures in at least 20 years. He has class action lawyers that will pound the hell of the NCAA lawyers, and they don't mind appealing and keeping the pressure up. The guy's firm has made a BILLION (with a 'b'), on 5 billion recovery. They are not going to file suit on any case where it's assured they get bounced on a quick Motion to Dismiss. There are YEARS of discovery...they know something that makes it worthwhile to take the monetary risk. (Though he DID screw up supporting Hillary (he gave her a million plus). Her loss pissed him off so much he quit the Democratic Party.)

He's too short and fat to be an ambulance chaser. He couldn't run across the street. He made his money advertising. 1st or 2nd in the US on advertising.
I think you give them far too much credit.
 

bigbluehomer

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2012
1,181
1,351
0
Would be pretty funny if UL got this back only to have an army of UK fans start buying wins from UL players who may need cash and start vacating every season UL ever played.

If they win, I predict Chane will be the first to have his on ebay.
 

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,316
67,212
113
Maybe but I doubt the case even survives a request for dismissal. It has got me thinking though. I wonder if this is really a ploy to get UL to pay them to shut it down. They have to know they can't beat the NCAA and they have to know UL doesn't want this publicity going on.....I wonder.

As to the false light claim, if the elements are pleaded and the limitations period has not run, I think it would take a motion for summary judgment, rather than a motion to dismiss, assuming the court truly has diversity jurisdiction. If the case does not get summarily dismissed, discovery could be ugly for UL. I sure hope former UL players are not holding their school ransom. That would suck.
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
As to the false light claim, if the elements are pleaded and the limitations period has not run, I think it would take a motion for summary judgment, rather than a motion to dismiss, assuming the court truly has diversity jurisdiction. If the case does not get summarily dismissed, discovery could be ugly for UL. I sure hope former UL players are not holding their school ransom. That would suck.
Here's an interesting article on the claims and possible outcomes.

https://www.si.com/college-basketball/2018/07/12/louisville-ex-players-lawsuit-ncaa-luke-hancock
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
Living in Louisville, early and often in the investigation and the case, Luke was identified as not being involved. I have never heard anyone suggest he was involved. I don’t know any UL fan who thinks he was involved.
Their case is completely frivolous and should be thrown out. What did they want the NCAA to do, punish the school and the complicit players and leave all the rest of the players alone? They can't do that, it would violate federal privacy laws by singling out only the complicit players. Once thats out of the way, there isn't really anything left in their case.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Indiana takes down John Calipari, Arkansas ahead of showdown with Kentucky in Indy
  2. 02 KSR KSR Show, 11/18: Ask Anything Wednesday, live from 10-noon
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington
  4. 04 KSR KSR Today: Mark Pope previews Indiana, Will Stein previews Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky Drops Out of 12-Team Field in Latest CFP Top 25 Rankings