UK vs Duke vs Mich St- 2016

Jul 4, 2007
6,534
12,113
113
Assuming Bolden chooses UK and Josh Jackson picks MSU, it will be pretty obvious who the top 3 teams will be entering next season. How do each teams stack up against each other?

Per the latest NBA draft update, Duke looks like they only expect to lose Ingram early to the NBA, along with senior Amile Jefferon and the 12th year Plumlee.. I don't know much about much about Mich St other than Valentine & Forbes will graduate. This is what I'm guessing the line-ups will look like. Please feel free to correct as necessary

* freshman

Kentucky

PG- Fox*
SG- Monk*
SF- Gabriel*
PF- Bam*
C- Bolden*

Bench

SKJ*
Matthews
Hawkins
Willis

Humphries
Wynard
Mulder

Duke

PG- Thorton
SG- Allen
SF- Jones
PF- Tatum*
C- Giles*

Bench

Jeter
Kennard
Jackson*
DeLaurier*


Mich St

PG- Harris
SG- Bridges*
SF- Jackson*
PF- Schilling
C- Davis

Bench

Langford*
Winston*
Ward*
Bess
Naim Jr

Based on these line-ups we would have the advantage with size and athleticism while Duke and Mich St lack a ton of size, but have more quality depth at the guard position. How does everyone else see it?
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
Based on those, we might be third - but in reality, I think we'll be 1a and 1b with Duke with MSU 3rd because I think we'll have more returning than you state here (with a couple transfers out).
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,941
63,128
113
I thought UK and Duke would be neck and neck a few months back. but a lot has changed since then.
  • Big injury to Giles. If by chance he's not the player he was, that really puts a huge gap between UK and Duke's class.
  • Duke appears to be done with Recruiting. Kentucky looks good with Bolden and maybe Kobi. If UK grabs just one, it makes Kentucky's class far and away #1, and everyone else a distant 2nd. (it might already be that way now).
  • Duke loses a lot of important upperclassmen. Kentucky loses Poythress (Sorry, I almost don't even see that being a loss at this point).
  • The current, projected returnee's favor Kentucky (Skal, Briscoe, Matthews, Hump, Lee) over Duke (Jeter, Thornton, Allen). At one time, no one thought Skal could come back, but it's looking more and more likely. He would give Kentucky the edge.
So, for now anyways, I think Kentucky holds the edge in Current roster and additions through recruiting. But, only so much of that talent can see the floor before players start getting minutes cut, so the above points might really equate to much of nothing.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,941
63,128
113
OP: There's no reason to think we lose Lee, Briscoe, Skal, and Ulis. 1 or 2 of them are coming back. Yes, in your scenario, Duke might edge us, but you're also painting the worst-case scenario for UK talent leaving, and the best case-scenario for Duke talent staying.

If Briscoe and Ulis are expected to leave, you should throw Allen in there, too.
 
Jul 11, 2007
27,222
34,299
0
It's UK and it's not close.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Michigan St. starters, IMHO:

PG Nairn or Winston
SG Harris
SF Jackson
PF Bridges
C Davis

Harris will not run the point for them. He is a wing scorer, not a point. Nairn and Winston will compete for the PG spot. If they get Jackson, I look for them to go small with Bridges playing a stretch 4.
 

Hofmannia

Redshirt
Apr 12, 2008
5
6
3
I tend to agree with the OP, this years draft is very weak, and if Lee wants to get drafted it's this year, not next... And Briscoe will probably use that logic too, and Skal will get drafted on potential alone. That just leaves Ullis, and I don't see him coming back, what's he got left to prove, he is what he is, 5'9... Better to go in a weak draft than a loaded one as '17 appears it will be...
 

JohnnyGentle

Senior
Nov 6, 2007
1,559
675
0
giles looked fairly raw to me (though extremely talented) and the year away from basketball won't help. and they're not exactly stacked up front

skal will make you gun-shy, but fox & monk look like they're better than average cal guard recruits which is saying quite a bit more than it sounds like

if willis or hawkins has a jorts-type come to jesus senior year i'll be even more confident
 
  • Like
Reactions: LineSkiCat14
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri is Officially the "Who Wants It More?" Bowl
  2. 02 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  3. 03 KSR Basketball It's not all bad: Five things Kentucky has done well this season
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Recruiting 5-star C Cherif Millogo signs with Kentucky
  5. 05 KSR Basketball KSR Show, 11/19: Matt is back in Lexington, live from 10 (a.m.) to noon (p.m.)