I was shocked as well.
1. Given Goodell's history: his overreaction to other cases, given that he has not hesitated to punish others before in the absence of conclusive evidence.
2. Given the facts surrounding the case, Hill's history, the nature of the allegations, given the tape that came out after, given the public scrutiny surrounding it all.
It's very odd to me. Seems completely arbitrary. I'm not sure how Ezekiel Elliot gets suspended in the absence of clear evidence, and to a lesser and more controversial degree, Tom Brady, while Hill does not. It's also unclear to me why Incognitio got only two games.