Toggle sidebar

Twerpstreit

Reply
C

countryroads89_rivals

Sophomore
Sep 6, 2013
27,594
120
0
is talking about moving Georgia up to 3 and putting them in the playoffs. I certainly hope none of the actual committee members think like him. How in the world could you put a two-loss team in ahead of a one-loss, conference champion?

He has to be on some kind of drugs. He picked Tennessee to beat us and he picked Marshall to beat Va Tech today.
 
T

The Bell Tolls for Thee

Freshman
Feb 15, 2005
7,083
60
0
countryroads89 said:
is talking about moving Georgia up to 3 and putting them in the playoffs. I certainly hope none of the actual committee members think like him. How in the world could you put a two-loss team in ahead of a one-loss, conference champion?

He has to be on some kind of drugs. He picked Tennessee to beat us and he picked Marshall to beat Va Tech today.
Click to expand...

That is why these debates and using committees is bogus. Even the NFL which has 16 games across 32 teams and 4 wild card spots still gets at least one team in the playoffs from a bad division that doesn't deserve it as much as another team. Hell, half the time the Super Bowl is not the best 2 teams as those 2 teams are in the same conference or division even. Sure Georgia may be a better team than OU and is definitely a better team than ND, but they lost a regular season game and didn't win their conference. Consider today a wild card game that Georgia lost since they were playing a playoff team. Its pretty easy in this case. The tougher cases are like the Big 10 last year in which the clearly 2 best teams are in the same division and thus one doesn't even have to play in the championship game and is still in the mix. That's why these big conferences are a problem, because at least in the Big XII you can say that even if you are a top 4 team, you had a chance to beat the team that did win the conference by playing head to head (likely twice) and against the exact same competition. Sure a worse team may make it, but you had your shot and were just unlucky that a better team was in your conference that year. Look at the NCAA tournament this year. Put WVU in Loyola-Chicago's bracket and the Mountaineers are likely in the Final Four last year. Unfortunately they drew the best team in the tournament in the round of 16. Loyola-Chicago gets a Final Four banner despite not being as good of a team as WVU. All that rambling to say that when the resume's are remotely close, the team that actually won their conference should get the nod. Sure if Northwestern knocks off tOSU or had ISU managed to keep to just 2 losses and won the Big XII, then there is debate.
 
T

TownesVanZandt_rivals

Freshman
Aug 19, 2018
9,810
78
0
People are saying this....
Georgia is one of the best four teams.

Doesn't mean they will get a spot because of one game.
If that is the case Ohio St's win over Michigan trumps that.

You can't just dismiss their game against LSU either as a bad day.

Truthfully it should be
Alabama
Clemson
Oklahoma/Ohio St/Georgia/ND/UCF

Compare the last Two

Oklahoma because of having the Heisman winner will get the nod
 
8

88rocco

Redshirt
Feb 13, 2012
583
4
0
Twerp is an idiot. If UGA gets in the playoffs and OU get's left out, I think I'm done with CFB. Too much corruption.
 
Last edited:
S

skygusty_rivals

Freshman
May 14, 2003
4,990
65
0
Just to be Devils Advocate, a Final Four of ND, Clemson, Alabama and Georgia could piss off enough people for there to be more of a clamor for an 8 team playoff. Basically 2 ACC and 2 SEC teams would be in the final 4.
 
3

3xWVUenginEER

Freshman
Dec 7, 2005
6,818
65
0
countryroads89 said:
is talking about moving Georgia up to 3 and putting them in the playoffs. ..........

............... and he picked Marshall to beat Va Tech today.
Click to expand...
Watch it. I was so dumb I picked Marshall too. I forgot Doc Holiday can't beat P5s with any record other than horrible and even in some cases when he knows their signals for almost 4 qtrs (last 2 drives one school finally used towels to hide signals)
 
T

TexasforevEER

Freshman
Nov 10, 2006
2,364
64
0
What folks post about Georgia being better than Oklahoma and Notre Dame is simply what they 'think'. It is not what they know. I think lots of things that get proven wrong. Georgia has lost 2 games. They are not part of the Top Four. Get over it. Warez
 
Top Bottom
Reply