I very much like Sharpe. He is great with baseball as well whether it's with Handley or McLaughlin.
I'm partial to Pavelka for my own nostalgia's sake, but he was very partisan, excitable, and frequently you would have no idea what was going on. "Cheap shot, big time!" from the 1995 Orange Bowl.
Warren Swain is toward the bottom of the list for me, if not at the bottom.