Just finished the 3rd season. As someone else said above, the ending was very vanilla. Such a damn shame because it came out of the gates very strong. But it finished very meh. Either way, Mahershala Ali was brilliant as was the other actors. The acting was great. The writing? Not so much. The writing ruined the season, could have been Season 1 special but nope. Looking at you Nic Pizzolato
This is why I prefer British detective shows, the writing is almost always very strong. Not many great American detective shows. Season 1 of True Detective was pure briliance which Pizzolato played big role (created the show, wrote it, directed some, etc) but he could never find his footing for season 2 or 3. Maybe 1st season was just that damn good and everything after it was going to suck regardless? But other than season 1 True Detective, not many great American detective shows. The Killing was solid but was very repetitive and dragged out season 1 and 2 when it could been shorter. The other seasons after it was solid when it switched cases. The Sinner was pretty solid. The Alienist was pretty good, had a very British feel to it. Of course, main actors weren't even American. That's about all I can think of. American detective/cop shows just flat out suck *** for most part.