Anthony Ashnault
4 time All American and undefeated national champion (no question)
Followed by Carli Lloyd and Ray Rice
Good point.. but (if not post-2000) Wicks and Lalas earned the equivalent of a Heisman... which considers every position and every player from 100s of programs. There are only 79 wrestling schools. And Ashnault was not the most dominant... wasn't top 3 in that regard.
Post-2000.. it is Ashnault. I like the argument about what Lloyd did after Rutgers.. but, really, she was a dominant soccer player here and should have gotten more and higher honors should Rutgers have done better. And post-Rutgers.. there were times when I thought she should have won awards given to others.