To the negativists

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,304
3,876
113
There used to be a poster who hated Hazell's game. In the game thread he would have 7 posts about Jeremys bad play. Then JH would go 5 for six from 3 with 2 alleyopp dunks. Silence.

People see thru them.

Fair criticism always appreciated. But some posters come off as guys who are disappointed by good play.

I was not a gonzo fan from day 1. I was still a SHU fan, and I hoped he would prove me wrong.
 

shu67

Senior
Jun 12, 2021
1,003
740
93
You'll probably see a lot of the negatives in 4 days after playing a team that's averaging over 100 points per game. Let's enjoy being 3-0, while also recognizing the team doesn't look great.

We're going to learn a lot more about this team in the next 3 games of Alabama, Wisconsin, and NC State/Murray State.
Agree with your comments and really happy to be 3-0 at this point. The competition does get much better. Let's see if we can continue to grow as a team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turiddu

hallmatt

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2018
161
135
43
It was a nice win over a decent team.
Hopefully, Petrovic is the PG moving forward.
Unfortunately, still not high on this team, however that can change if we go 2-1 in the next 3 games.
Sha can really coach, but he can’t recruit at all. He missed on a lot of players this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SeanieWard

shu67

Senior
Jun 12, 2021
1,003
740
93
He missed on the 2 or 3 starters for Charlotte who could probably start for SHU if they came here! That being said we did beat them and there is talent on our roster and Sha deserves credit for the 3-0 start. I was impressed with a number of players on Charlotte and wonder how big their NIL budget and payout was given the talent on that team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turiddu

SPK145

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
1,611
3,685
113
Defense is way ahead of the offense, even with new found, under control, coach on the floor Petrovic at PG. His steady play plus the overall play of Williams, Anderson's 2 dagger threes, and the aforementioned defense won the game.

Efficiency's
Offense = 102.6
Defense = 92.7
 

Hall84

Senior
May 23, 2023
459
652
93
You'll probably see a lot of the negatives in 4 days after playing a team that's averaging over 100 points per game. Let's enjoy being 3-0, while also recognizing the team doesn't look great.

We're going to learn a lot more about this team in the next 3 games of Alabama, Wisconsin, and NC State/Murray State.
Let's hope that we learn the same thing that we learned last year after Maui; that we have a pretty decent team.
 

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
1,084
849
113
Too early to say. But to answer your question. No, I don’t think there’s a reason to feel better. We are probably playing exactly to expectations, which isnt exactly a positive.
 

hallmatt

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2018
161
135
43
I’m feeling worse about Copeland. Doesn’t rebound, fouls more than Hines/payne, small

Wilcher great defense but his offense has been horrendous. We didn’t bring him here to be a defender. He was expected to be our best/2nd best player.

How Sha struck out on the most important position with Del Jones is crazy.

Roddie Anderson has been a bright spot.

Thank God a judge ruled in our favor with Fisher.

The wings have been worse than expected.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,304
3,876
113
I’m feeling worse about Copeland. Doesn’t rebound, fouls more than Hines/payne, small

Wilcher great defense but his offense has been horrendous. We didn’t bring him here to be a defender. He was expected to be our best/2nd best player.

How Sha struck out on the most important position with Del Jones is crazy.

Roddie Anderson has been a bright spot.

Thank God a judge ruled in our favor with Fisher.

The wings have been worse than expected.
Yes, we have to be concerned with the fouls. After liu, I thought they were just dumb fouls, maybe a bad call. But 2 in a row, def dampens the win. Guys do get into consistent foul trouble cause of dumb fouls. Hope this changes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turiddu

ivyhillpark63

Senior
Feb 4, 2012
486
498
62
There were a couple spurts where we looked really good in first and 2nd half.
Not sure why sha made wholesale subs when we went up 11. Let the guys finish the job..
 

NYShoreGuy

All-Conference
Jan 7, 2006
2,746
1,287
113
You'll probably see a lot of the negatives in 4 days after playing a team that's averaging over 100 points per game. Let's enjoy being 3-0, while also recognizing the team doesn't look great.

We're going to learn a lot more about this team in the next 3 games of Alabama, Wisconsin, and NC State/Murray State.
If bama is a 20 point verdict it is a positive
 

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,651
12,171
113
Really won’t have a good feel until about game 6 or 7, as the experimenting is in process. My biggest concerns have been PG and depth at 4/5.

- Feeling better at PG after last night.
- Feeling worse about 4/5 depth (Copeland foul prone and Kabba play).

Still sticking with my 9-11 BE record prediction, with a downside lean.
 

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
1,084
849
113
Even with a win, one of the broken records admits to not feeling any better. Probably will take a loss of decent margin on Friday, then he and 3-4 others with no weekend plans will be in their glory until the rest of us go to work on Monday.
You’re so obsessed with me.. please tell me what in my post was wrong…
 

Piratz

All-Conference
Mar 24, 2004
1,844
3,626
113
Much better last night. Charlotte hit some bombs and tough shots too to keep it close.

**Looks like Sha got to Petrovic. He was very uneven and – to me – looked rather slow and unathletic in the opener despite showing more “PG skills” than the others, then mysteriously didn’t play basically at all in game 2. I heard Sha on with Cohen and Popkin afterwards and he was saying Petrovic excels in a game style like last night, but not in structure as against a zone in the LIU game. IDK, seems odd, but last night, damn, very impressive.

**Petrovic brought it and glad to see it! That looked like a capable PG. I still have questions about him against BE-caliber teams, and I hope he proves he can handle it, but last night was by far the type of play we need and it’s not even question anymore. Jones hasn’t shown a fraction of that.

**Williams also is an interesting player. The guy is a tall wing. He doesn’t rebound or really get physical but if you can move the ball and take advantage of him as a matchup factor, there’s an answer. Teams that can back us down will dominate us though.

**I think the 1st half rotations are bonkers right now. I hope it evens out so it doesn’t impede gelling.

**These things take time with 13 new faces. I expect the tempo and style of Alabama to blow our doors off, but it’ll be a good experience to get out there against elite players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turiddu

NIL BAD

Senior
Aug 15, 2025
460
423
63
Free-throw defense was elite. The subbing 4 guys at a time has to stop. We don't have enough scoring options for that.
Williams took the biggest leap & seems like a better option than Coleman at this point. Petro over Dell is a no brainer. Parker/Wilcher should split minutes moving forward. Parker was better last night. Both are very good defenders.
Anderson continues to impress.
 

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
1,084
849
113
You're a never-ending font of material. If you can't take a positive from Petrovic's play, then you have no objectivity.
I'm sure you'll counter with Charlotte is terrible, although you had them winning by 5 last night.
Okay, Petrovic has played well. What about Del Jones? Kinda cancels each other out no? Hence the answer is nothing to to feel more positive about
 
Feb 9, 2005
284
479
63
I’m feeling worse about Copeland. Doesn’t rebound, fouls more than Hines/payne, small

Wilcher great defense but his offense has been horrendous. We didn’t bring him here to be a defender. He was expected to be our best/2nd best player.

How Sha struck out on the most important position with Del Jones is crazy.

Roddie Anderson has been a bright spot.

Thank God a judge ruled in our favor with Fisher.

The wings have been worse than expected.
If Holloway wasn't our coach, we'd really be in the abyss. And he signed up for more of it.
 
Feb 9, 2005
284
479
63
Okay, Petrovic has played well. What about Del Jones? Kinda cancels each other out no? Hence the answer is nothing to to feel more positive about
No, it doesn't. Both looked bad prior to last night. Then one looked good, and hopefully will be the prime guy at the position going forward. If he looks like Del Jones again over the next couple of weeks, then I'll be in agreement.
 

dehere23

All-Conference
Feb 28, 2015
2,113
2,426
113
If Holloway wasn't our coach, we'd really be in the abyss. And he signed up for more of it.
I’m a Sha guy, but he isn’t doing this for free. He makes a fortune to coach at a place he loves, with more influence and job security than probably most HCs in the country (and some of that not deserved based on the resume to date). I get your sentiment, but this is an extremely attractive place for Sha to be as well.
 

PirateBlue08

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2025
1,432
1,318
113
The Petrovic revelation is a huge reason to be encouraged, although Copeland dramatically regressed, Del Jones who was expected to be one of our top players is a complete zero with shoes, and Wilcher who was expected to breakout and carry our scoring load is a non-factor offensively.

Roddie continues to be somewhat of a surprise although I expected him to be pretty good.

Kabba is a huge disappointment after the pre-season hype, and hoping it’s just injury rust.

Williams finally showed something which was very encouraging. He looks like the best shot blocker interior defensive presence since Gill (if it continues). And his pick and roll action with Petrovic is definitely something positive.

The wing players who were intended to be our top shooters have disappointed.

Fisher is what we know he is, limited but solid. Parker stepped up and if he limits bonehead decisions will be a big asset.

So lots to be encouraged about and lots to be discouraged about. But the bar was so low, especially just hoping to find a somewhat capable pg, that it’s hard to be very confident going into the tougher part of our schedule.

Time will tell. I’m still in “show me” mode.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,304
3,876
113
Now, I def want petro to start and play the most minutes, was, still am, thrilled with his play last night, but I am not buying that we have seen the best of what Jones has to offer. Sha has his preferences and stubbornness, but he is not a dope re PG ability.
 

PirateBlue08

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2025
1,432
1,318
113
Now, I def want petro to start and play the most minutes, was, still am, thrilled with his play last night, but I am not buying that we have seen the best of what Jones has to offer. Sha has his preferences and stubbornness, but he is not a dope re PG ability.
I tend to agree, but how many wins can we sacrifice until we find out? Maybe sliding him to the backup 2 is a better role for him to at least hit a few shots and get some confidence. I'd rather Parker back up Petrovic anyway.
 

Anon1776442946

Freshman
Apr 17, 2026
90
90
18
Del jones is a big ??. How did u avg 17 last year and look completely lost against this competition. We havent even gotten into the BE and tough part of non conf schedule
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,304
3,876
113
Cant blame fish. Hes a 3 playing the 4 at like 6'4.5- 6'5. He battled his *** of last year. Its frustrating getting guys who cant play their natural position. We do it every year
I would love to see DWill, Cope and Fish on the floor together. Pair them with Roddie and Petro. Assuming Cope deals with fouls better in the future, or Kabba or Dolinsky show they can hold their own.
 

hallmatt

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2018
161
135
43
I would love to see DWill, Cope and Fish on the floor together. Pair them with Roddie and Petro. Assuming Cope deals with fouls better in the future, or Kabba or Dolinsky show they can hold their own.
Why? Dwill, Cope, and Fish live in the paint.
 
Seton Hall Pirates

Latest

  1. 01 Rivals 4-star PG Javion Tyndale commits to Seton Hall
  2. 02 Rivals Basketball Recruiting 4-star PG Javion Tyndale down to 6 schools
  3. 03 Women's Sports Highly-recruited 2027 prospect Ava Womack breaks down recruitment
  4. 04 Women's Sports Highly-recruited 2027 prospect Eni Oyedeji breaks down recruitment
  5. 05 On3 Basketball LMU transfer guard Rodney Brown Jr. commits to Seton Hall