In order to be a Blue Blood you need ALL of the following, in no order:
1. Strong institutional support
2. Strong fan support (sell out every or almost every game) LOTS of school spirit and lots of fans that never went to that school.
3. Strong donor support = AD raises millions and millions every year. Along with Super donors that give millions on a regular basis. Just for football.
4. Ability for the school to sell itself to 4 star recruits no matter who the HC is.
5. Football program is considered a dream job for elite HCs
6. Winning a lot. Winning record every year. Favored to win their division or conference every or most years (even if they fall short). Winning lots of conference championships and major bowl games. At least a handful of National championships and Heisman winners.
7. When there is a down period, they ALWAYS bounce back to being elite again. When there is a major scandal, they ALWAYS bounce back to being elite again.
8. They will always be elite unless they drop football (University of chicago) or decided they no longer want to be a blue blood on their own (Harvard, Princeton and Yale) basically once a Football problem becomes a blue blood they will always be a blue blood unless they decide to to be one anymore.
Blue bloods take a LONG time to build. USC, OSU, OU, Bama etc.
Clemson is simply not a blue blood but a current national power.
Tiers:
1) BLue blood-- Bama, USC, OSU, OU etc.
2) National Power-- this tier is where the third tier can jump into. I include the likes of Clemson, Miami,Georgia. Teams with NCs but not long term blue bloods yet.
3) Rising programs -- teams like Oregon. MSU right now and in the 90s Vtech under Beamer is an example. These programs are solid in teams like Oreg. -- some closer in the upper #2 tier.
4) Average programs -- you know the ones
5) Bottom of barrel -- easy to know.