SUPERBACK MARSHALL LANG COMMITS TO NU

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,659
4,434
78
Yeah, Dickerson, Vitale, and Cam Green were trash. I have no clue where you come up with your evaluations.

Where did I say any of those guys were trash? Green came in as a WR anyway.

I’m more concerned about the fact that we haven’t come up with an impact Superback since the class of 2014 (Dickerson) and most of the room is filled by local guys with mediocre tape and sparse offer lists. I’m all for trusting coaches’ evaluations, but at some point it becomes a pattern.
 

CrippleCat

Redshirt
Mar 8, 2019
3,144
0
0
Where did I say any of those guys were trash? Green came in as a WR anyway.

I’m more concerned about the fact that we haven’t come up with an impact Superback since the class of 2014 (Dickerson) and most of the room is filled by local guys with mediocre tape and sparse offer lists. I’m all for trusting coaches’ evaluations, but at some point it becomes a pattern.
Fair enough...I see your point, but we always seem to come up with a good one.. Until the staff fails to produce a good one we need to trust them.
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,659
4,434
78
Fair enough...I see your point, but we always seem to come up with a good one.. Until the staff fails to produce a good one we need to trust them.

Pugh seems to have all the physical skills, but has struggled to stay healthy and is somewhat inconsistent catching the ball. Mangieri strikes me more as an in-line guy. Gordon has yet to spend a moment on campus and Eshoo has been persona non grata. Would love an impact guy to emerge, but LOTS of work to do for any of those guys to get to that level.
 

freewillie07

Junior
Aug 22, 2017
5,370
224
48
Fair enough...I see your point, but we always seem to come up with a good one.. Until the staff fails to produce a good one we need to trust them.

A good “one,” yes. But then the problem becomes what happens when something unexpected happens to that starter — say, he chooses to medically retire instead of play his final year?

Then the Cats end up in the situation they’re in, all-in on Pugh even though he couldn’t practice in the spring. Moving Goens to superback. Etc. I like Gordon, but he probably needs a year before getting major minutes.

The glaring recruiting weaknesses in OL and WR appear to be receding (particularly if we can add Sullivan or Martinez to the class). It does raise the question: Is superback recruiting our new weak link? And if so, why?

Disclaimer: no one would be happier than me to see these two 2020 guys ball out and be stars.
 

TheC

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
19,526
1,580
62
If you play for Coach Speck at St X, you are going to be a team player. He comes from a good family and will fit in well at NU.
Cripple knows his Cincinnati football. Its just too bad this kid's from St X and not Big Moe!
 

CrippleCat

Redshirt
Mar 8, 2019
3,144
0
0
Pugh seems to have all the physical skills, but has struggled to stay healthy and is somewhat inconsistent catching the ball. Mangieri strikes me more as an in-line guy. Gordon has yet to spend a moment on campus and Eshoo has been persona non grata. Would love an impact guy to emerge, but LOTS of work to do for any of those guys to get to that level.
Another post I have to agree with. Hoping Pugh can step up.
 

CrippleCat

Redshirt
Mar 8, 2019
3,144
0
0
That is just so wrong. Nobody with a choice passes on X to attend Moeller.

GOUNUII
They both have there pluses. Half of Jango's friends went to X, the other half went to Moe. I would say Coach Speck is about as good a High School coach as you can find. And definitely if you were a defensive player you would have to choose X. Moeller is very good at baseball, basketball, and football. You can't go wrong going to either school. I was going to send Jango to Elder, but the drive was too far. There are many great players in this area. Fitz and his staff have been recruiting Ohio hard. It has paid off. The GCL is one of the best leagues in the nation. Still glad my son went to the greatest place on the planet for a high school student athlete (IMG) and the greatest place on the planet for a collegiate athlete (NU). I wish my son could have reached his potential and contributed more, but regardless of the outcome I know he was at the best place he could be. Nothing but purple love my friends and excited to see some games this year. Go Cats..
 

CrippleCat

Redshirt
Mar 8, 2019
3,144
0
0
What do you mean by this? He’s not liked? Or did you mean persona incognito, as in missing?
Eshoo is one of the nicest kids on the team. As a matter of fact he is taking his day off tomorrow to move my sons belongings to storage. He has great parents.. He had some injuries last season.. Hopefully he gets healthy this year and things click for him. These are all my sons 2016 classmates, the ones I said would be special. They haven't disappointed. Even with losing some very good players to injuries, like Larkin.
 

TheC

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
19,526
1,580
62
Nothing wrong with school pride. The more the better ... even at Moeller. :)
Exactly. Though I had a little bit of an adjustment moving on to NU from Moeller. My new school's colors were now Purple and White and I was living in Elder Hall. You can see why that was upsetting for a little while.
 

GOUNUII

Junior
Jan 4, 2004
6,418
238
63
Well, you should be happy that we have another Cincinnati guy on the roster

We have done well with our Cincy area guys over the years. LaSalle, Moeller, Milford and now St. X have all contributed. Don't recall any Elder boys finding their way out of the West Side of town to Evanston. Here's wishing great things for Porter, Foster and especially Lang ... who will arrive in Evanston much less heralded than Porter and Foster ... but with a Bomber pedigree that will serve him well.

Mrs. GOUNUII and I love all the Cats, but especially those who come to us from Ohio. A state that has been very good to NU going back to the Ara era.

GOUNUII
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,635
4,930
113
They both have there pluses. Half of Jango's friends went to X, the other half went to Moe. I would say Coach Speck is about as good a High School coach as you can find. And definitely if you were a defensive player you would have to choose X. Moeller is very good at baseball, basketball, and football. You can't go wrong going to either school. I was going to send Jango to Elder, but the drive was too far. There are many great players in this area. Fitz and his staff have been recruiting Ohio hard. It has paid off. The GCL is one of the best leagues in the nation. Still glad my son went to the greatest place on the planet for a high school student athlete (IMG) and the greatest place on the planet for a collegiate athlete (NU). I wish my son could have reached his potential and contributed more, but regardless of the outcome I know he was at the best place he could be. Nothing but purple love my friends and excited to see some games this year. Go Cats..
I think GCG inadvertently fumbled his terminology.
 

CSCatFan1

Senior
Dec 4, 2002
39,976
464
83
We have done well with our Cincy area guys over the years. LaSalle, Moeller, Milford and now St. X have all contributed. Don't recall any Elder boys finding their way out of the West Side of town to Evanston. Here's wishing great things for Porter, Foster and especially Lang ... who will arrive in Evanston much less heralded than Porter and Foster ... but with a Bomber pedigree that will serve him well.

Mrs. GOUNUII and I love all the Cats, but especially those who come to us from Ohio. A state that has been very good to NU going back to the Ara era.

GOUNUII

LaSalle has a couple of 2021 DB prospects to keep an eye on...Jaylen Johnson and Devonta Smith. Johnson seems the higher regarded of the two, recently offered by OSU. Smith was just offered by Minny. I’d hope we are in the process of evaluating both.
 

Max_Power

Senior
May 29, 2001
3,145
608
101
Yeah, Dickerson, Vitale, and Cam Green were trash. I have no clue where you come up with your evaluations.

Pugh and Eshoo were both solid sought after recruits. Mangieri comes from a family that just plays football and played on special teams in every game as a true freshman. Watch any big game last year and you see just how insanely valuable Cam Green was - as well as the crazy amount of hits he took as he often received the ball as the outlet and got immediately hit by a defender running full speed into his back.
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,659
4,434
78
Pugh and Eshoo were both solid sought after recruits. Mangieri comes from a family that just plays football and played on special teams in every game as a true freshman. Watch any big game last year and you see just how insanely valuable Cam Green was - as well as the crazy amount of hits he took as he often received the ball as the outlet and got immediately hit by a defender running full speed into his back.

Don't want to pile on the kid, but Eshoo wasn't particularly "sought after." His other offers were Illinois, Ball State, Bowling Green, Nevada, Wyoming, and FBS schools. He's Exhibit A for "lightly recruited local kid who got offered in camp with mediocre tape and offer list." Injuries have complicated the picture, but that's how he came in. Just facts.

Pugh reported Arkansas, Duke, Illinois, Kentucky, Michigan, Nebraska, Penn State, Pitt, Purdue, Syracuse, and Wake Forest among others.

The discrepancies between the offer lists are... stark.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,635
4,930
113
Don't want to pile on the kid, but Eshoo wasn't particularly "sought after." His other offers were Illinois, Ball State, Bowling Green, Nevada, Wyoming, and FBS schools. He's Exhibit A for "lightly recruited local kid who got offered in camp with mediocre tape and offer list." Injuries have complicated the picture, but that's how he came in. Just facts.

Pugh reported Arkansas, Duke, Illinois, Kentucky, Michigan, Nebraska, Penn State, Pitt, Purdue, Syracuse, and Wake Forest among others.

The discrepancies between the offer lists are... stark.
So let me get this straight, Stars don’t matter, but offers do matter? Want to make sure will are both gaining on that windmill at the same pace.
 
Aug 19, 2015
324
54
0
But are they much better?
Dan Vitale: 6' 2" and lightly recruited, most programs wouldn't recruit a TE at this size. Ever. Yet he was a top receiver for us and now plays on Sundays (at full back now)
Drake Dunsmore: 6' 3" mid 3 star with only a few P5 offers. Also a top receiver and NFL draftee
Garret Dickerson: 6' 3" was a 4 star but primarily because big programs wanted him as a DE. We landed him in no small part because we wanted him on offense. Made the Giants roster mid-season

I'd say we have a pretty good history with undersized tight ends.
 

CrippleCat

Redshirt
Mar 8, 2019
3,144
0
0
Eshoo has injuries that have negatively impacted his career. It is not a lack of talent. I feel if Eshoo's body had held up he would have been a contributer.
 

phatcat_rivals223240

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2001
19,305
1,410
113
They both have there pluses. Half of Jango's friends went to X, the other half went to Moe. I would say Coach Speck is about as good a High School coach as you can find. And definitely if you were a defensive player you would have to choose X. Moeller is very good at baseball, basketball, and football. You can't go wrong going to either school. I was going to send Jango to Elder, but the drive was too far. There are many great players in this area. Fitz and his staff have been recruiting Ohio hard. It has paid off. The GCL is one of the best leagues in the nation. Still glad my son went to the greatest place on the planet for a high school student athlete (IMG) and the greatest place on the planet for a collegiate athlete (NU). I wish my son could have reached his potential and contributed more, but regardless of the outcome I know he was at the best place he could be. Nothing but purple love my friends and excited to see some games this year. Go Cats..
so this is Cat'sDad? I missed that announcement if so.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Northwestern at Minnesota PFF Snaps Analysis
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Takeaways: Northwestern hamstrings itself in 20-17 loss at Minnesota
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Northwestern losing streak hits four after gut-wrenching 20-17 loss to Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Northwestern outmatched by Virginia Tech in 87-70 loss
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Fearless Forecast: Northwestern vs. Minnesota