Spill over from another convo: Is Toby Johnson pure DT?

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,786
24,678
113
If so, our staff must be pretty damn impressed with the kid, because it's probably the deepest position on the team.

Quay Evans
Nick James
PJ Jones
Kaleb Eulls (?)
Curtis Vigers
Nelson Adams
Toby Johnson

Even if Toby RS, they would all return in 2014. Seems like some guys are going to get buried at DT (Eulls, Adams, and James(?)).
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
When it was thought that he would EE prior to injury, he was the consensus #1 overall JUCO player in the country. He was something like a 99 rating on 24/7 at that time. Look at the kid's offer sheet... An injury and grade problems later, he's still a mid-level consensus 4*.

He's as pure a 4-3 DT as you will ever find. Is he expected to play DE at 300 lbs? He does have Fletcher Cox-type versatility though in that he's got speed and ability to play an effective DE in 3-4 sets...

I don't get how you can imply that we have any depth or stability at the position? Especially after the shitburger we saw on the field this year that ended in Boyd being double-teamed ALL season and Cherrington getting the majority of the snaps. DT may be the single largest questionmark for our entire team at this point. We need to hit on an elite JUCO badly. You listed a bunch of players that have already had the opportunity to produce and have not done so on a consistent or successful basis. I only consider 3 of them being even in the realm of NFL-type talent we've had at the position pretty consistently over the years -- PJ, James, and Quay. At this point, NONE of those 3 have shown that we can count on them -- Quite the opposite in all 3 cases thusfar in their young careers.

And really? Of those listed, you expect Nick James to get lost in the shuffle? Everything I heard or read from bowl practices said that he's the most elite of the bunch...
 
Last edited:

MrCoolDog

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
3
0
0
I don't know if he's pure DT. He's 6-3, 300 pounds, but I can't find any 40 times (I've heard he has speed). His profile lists him as both DT and DE - not sure which he played most in juco. I think you get a kid with his talent on campus and see where he best helps the team. We do have some depth at DT, but its young, and you can't have too many quality DL IMO.
 

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,786
24,678
113
It's not that I don't think James is good, I just think the game is moving away from DTs like him. It's tough for guys like him to play against the Auburns, OM, and Texas AM's of the world today. Wilson echoed that before we played A&M this year.

You can't judge our DTs on last year. C34 has talked extensively about our DL being taught to 'read and react' last year instead of getting upfield and disrupting. You can PM him if you want more information.

DT is the deepest position on the team with the possible exception of center. We probably wont know what we have in this guy until 2014.
 

SPMT

Redshirt
Aug 25, 2012
187
0
0
Good point. Note how Saban recruited a ton of longer, lighter more athletic dlinemen. He specifically stated that he did so in order to handle the A&M type offenses.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
If so, our staff must be pretty damn impressed with the kid, because it's probably the deepest position on the team.

Quay Evans
Nick James
PJ Jones
Kaleb Eulls (?)
Curtis Vigers
Nelson Adams
Toby Johnson

Even if Toby RS, they would all return in 2014. Seems like some guys are going to get buried at DT (Eulls, Adams, and James(?)).

All you can say right now is we have quantity at the position, we don't really have any guys proven at the position at this point.
 

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,200
2,666
113
Don't confuse depth with talent.

In todays game you need minimum 4 guys to rotate - especially considering the faster offenses you've mentioned. I say you need a 5th legitimate DT in case one of your first four get injured. If Eulls is in fact moving inside, I think we have 5 that can play (Jones, Evans, James, Virges, Eulls). I don't expect to see Adams or Washington play much as redshirt freshmen.

So do we need Johnson? I know very little about the guy, but if the coaches believe he's a better option than any of our top 5 - I say sign him up. We know four guys will get a lot of playing time, two more will play sparingly, and whoever is left can just get their feeling hurt while watching from the sidelines.
 

SidneyBurger

Redshirt
Oct 18, 2012
197
0
0
Just judging from the video I watched, he has the speed for DE. He would be very versatile for us, no doubt. He's legit. I say take him and figure out the rest later. I don't expect to see much of guys like Adams and Washington for a couple more years anyways, so I wouldn't worry with hurting any feelings.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
Johnson is a guy that would give us the flexibility to rotate between 3 and 4 man fronts. We could have him, Autry, at the DE's with James playing the Nose in a 3-man front. We're just not sure he will be ready to go this Fall.

He is very talented- and we always need talent. Just need to get him eligible and healthy
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
His profile lists him as both DT and DE - not sure which he played most in juco.

This is because he was thought to be a UGA lock for a very, very long time... Georgia runs a 3-man front, in which case, like I said -- he was being recruited as a DE...

In a 4-man front, he's a DT...
 

Coach 57

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
374
0
0
It's not that I don't think James is good, I just think the game is moving away from DTs like him. It's tough for guys like him to play against the Auburns, OM, and Texas AM's of the world today.


Not a true statement. Our 43 front in the past there was in fact only one REAL DT, the other was actually used as a NT. When Fletcher was here he was the DT and Boyd played the N. Once they got a rhythm together on the field Fletcher and him were a force to reckon with as you could only doubleteam one. The NT ins 43 scheme lines up between the shoulder pads of the G & C and is immediate threat to A & or B gap penetration. Boyd in a way was happy to see Fletcher go as he was promised the DT spot the following year after Cox's departure. Assuming the role of the NT would be either PJ, Virges (PJ was more talented and both stayed in off the field issues especially PJ). So the task fell to either Quay, Nick (again off the field trouble as C34 and I have stated) and eventually we were almost forced to play Cherry. Who couldn't fulfill his duties of commanding a doubleteam. Boyd was forced to watch a double on most plays unless DL with off the field problems took the field who were VERY young (quay & nick) and didn't understand gap control or he watched PJ do his job and by that time seemed to not grasp consistency. Virges seems to really disappoint me. As he really should've been the guy to help Josh last year. But just didn't and doesn't. Quay's impact this year will be felt quite a bit barring injury. As will Nick as he has a full term to be in shape. But engie and 57stratdawg both are right and wrong. Engie is correct in the assessment of the performance of this group last season. At some point hopefully a "light" will come on for Virges and company.

As far as the game moving away from the DT. That is absurd. They are space eaters and create lanes for blitzing LBs, or an occasional $ to run inside and prevent a C or a G getting their 300lb hands on a them. As long as their are OG and C there will always be room for a DT who has great hands, explosive punch and good feet. Because he will more times than not create his OWN gap. Instead of having someone make it for him.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
I feel like we will be pretty damn good at DT. Quay and James are some talented mf'ers. They are also very ummmm "spirited". Which is very good when channeled in the appropriate manner. While it sucked that they didnt get near the reps they should have in 2012- it also helped hammer home the fact that they cant pop off whenever they feel like it or leave any doubt as to who is in control. Guys like this tend to stay in line a whole lot more when they are the ones starting and being counted on heavily.

Another thing is that you should see some hellacious battles this Spring between them and Day, Jackson, and Malone- making all 5 of them better.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
Another thing is that you should see some hellacious battles this Spring between them and Day, Jackson, and Malone- making all 5 of them better.

Excellent point.

To me, the D-Line is the X-Factor this coming season. If they can get even a little pressure on the QB, and stop the run without having to have safety help, then we will be tough to move the ball on.

While we have youth at CB, it is talented youth. And everybody needs to just get ready, because these young corners aren't going to be playing press coverage on the WR's early on...We can't risk getting beat with homerun passes while these guys are learning and getting there first reps. They will end up being a solid group. And don't forget, Deshea Townsend is trying to move up the ladder so he will be on a mission to coach these guys up.

That being said, I look for big improvement out of the defense this year. I don't think Turner is getting talked about enough either. He has always put together good defensive lines with much less talent than he will have this year....he is excited about it and we should be too.
 
Last edited:

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
yep...and I wish I could watch practice- you can count on a few fights and shouting matches between Day and James/Evans. I expect a very spirited Spring Practice
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
Well, that's exactly what this bunch needs. We have GOT to get some swagger back on this team, especially on defense. We show zero emotion and it bugs the hell out of me. I feel like Autry wants to be that emotional guy, but he didn't really have enough around him, and they didn't make enough big plays, to show it. Maybe Evans and James will be those guys to help us get the swag back. Chris Jones is quite the talker as well, so hopefully we have got the talent and personality to get back to the cocky defenses we have gotten used to over the years.
 

severstaldawg

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1
0
1
First time poster but has anyone heard of Tevin Lawson longtime LSU commit that was asked to greyshirt so he started looking back around and may end up visiting us? To me if he has 4 playing years left he maybe a better option.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Engie is correct in the assessment of the performance of this group last season. At some point hopefully a "light" will come on for Virges and company.

Correct. I am certainly not saying that DT/DL CAN'T be the strength of our team. It absolutely can -- and it has the greatest accumulation of talent of any position group we've got. But, the light hasn't "officially" come on for any of these guys yet, which has to give us pause until it actually does. Heard a LOT of great things about Quay/James in bowl practices(hopefully, having to sit and watch the Egg Bowl defeat when they should have been playing served as an attitude adjustment). But we're still at "wait and see" stage right now.

The Spring Game will tell us all we need to know about this position group IMO. I'll never forget Boyd/Fletcher dominating the game in 2011 and leaving us KNOWING they were going to be a team strength going into the season. I'm hopeful that I see the same type of thing this year...
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
First time poster but has anyone heard of Tevin Lawson longtime LSU commit that was asked to greyshirt so he started looking back around and may end up visiting us? To me if he has 4 playing years left he maybe a better option.

Good info! Thanks for adding that.

Personally, I wouldn't have a problem with adding them both. We need them both honestly. Like I say, we've got no sure things right now(Toby helps immediately, Lawson helps in year 2 or 3). And since Quay/James didn't redshirt(and the next guys likely will), there is essentially the possibility of a 3-yr gap to the next DTs since we didn't take any highschoolers in this class. We've certainly got room right now, and we simply don't need to turn away 4* type talent if we can help it...
 

SidneyBurger

Redshirt
Oct 18, 2012
197
0
0
There's also Lauren Jackson from EMCC. He isn't listed as committed to anyone that I can see, I know he was being scouted heavily at one point. Big available body if needed..
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
I look for us to try to get Lauren Jackson and David Washington to walk on... which seems like a pretty good possibility at this point...
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Rapid Recap: Mississippi State 34-16 Tennessee Tech
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Keys to Victory for Mississippi State vs. Tennessee Tech
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Recruiting Top 10 2027 QB Gavin Hampton and Bulldog commit highlights mental and physical improvements to his game