Songs that you consider "perfect"

Still in State Colllege

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
641
1,087
93
It’s funny, I found all three of those bands in reverse order. Happened to hear “Drown” on the radio one day and thought it was Neil Young. Didn’t catch the name so I searched and searched until I found out it was Son Volt. Bought the album and loved it instantly (still do). Next, I ran into “Outasite outamind” by Wilco and Beinf There and lived that as well. It wasn’t until years later that I found out they were once combined as Uncle Tupelo and naturally all of their stuff as well.
Great talents Farrar/Tweedy and like most they had a shelf life together. Some many good singer songwriters / bands from the period of my life.

Some many great bands could be traced to Eric Ambel and his touch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Connorpozlee

manatree

All-American
Oct 6, 2021
3,641
6,677
113
As good as ‘Hallelujah’ is Cohen agonized over perfecting it - I think there are versions with several additional verses. Additionally, both Buckley and Wainwright do the better versions of this song than Cohen, which is a testament to its greatness.

I don't think that Cohen ever considered that song finished, let alone perfected. He claimed to have written 150 different versions of the song and was known for singing many different versions of it throughout his career. It is a great song, and it is truly ironic that so many people consider it to be the perfect song.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

DavidM

All-American
Aug 27, 2002
2,573
7,421
113
Legitimately one of my least favorite songs, ever. Everything about it is grating.
Ah, wouldn't it be terrible if everybody liked the same things? Me, I think arrogance and absolute self-absorption deserve their own anthem.
 
May 11, 2016
479
283
63
The song's simple melody and rhythmic counterpoint quickly made it a favorite among fans; acoustic guitar virtuoso Leo Kottke, who often covered the song in performance, once called it "the most perfect guitar song ever written."

The story goes that Allman had a dream where Jimi Hendrix showed him the melody of the tune in a Holiday Inn motel bathroom, using the sink faucet as a guitar fretboard.



This one isn't bad either:

 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,071
21,663
113
I don't think that Cohen ever considered that song finished, let alone perfected. He claimed to have written 150 different versions of the song and was known for singing many different versions of it throughout his career. It is a great song, and it is truly ironic that so many people consider it to be the perfect song.

Top Five all time songwriters? Cohen, Lennon/McCartney, Paul Simon…..?
 

marshall23

All-Conference
May 23, 2013
4,883
4,167
113


The first time I heard this song, my wife played it for me. She wanted to let me know that she was in love with me.
10/10 will be 13 years since I lost her to cancer. I play it often and fantasize that we are dancing together.
My world is black and white.

Sinatra wanted them to write another verse so he could record it. They said no thank you.
 
Jan 8, 2016
254
324
63
For example, I think this a great song, but I don't consider it perfect. I think it would be better if they removed about 80% of the backup vocals (doowop?!?).



These songs, on the other hand, I consider great and can think of no changes that would make them better.

I love the almost psychedelic vibe of this:


Crank this one up:


I love the visual story this one tells:


This is obviously very subjective so have at it.

 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State running back Carson Hansen is now doubtful for Saturday's matchup with Rutgers
  2. 02 BWI Recruiting Inside Lasch: New 2027 RPM logged to kick off massive recruiting weekend for Penn State
  3. 03 BWI Football Penn State 3-2-1: Improving offense, leadership decisions and a test of consistency
  4. 04 BWI Recruiting Over 70 prospects now confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  5. 05 BWI Wrestling Which Penn State wrestlers are going to the CJ Morgan Invitational at Army? Here's the list, plus other thoughts