So Cal can't win unless he has superior talent...

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
It does. Probably gives more credence to the fact that the all 5 star OAD model doesn’t work.
That makes tons of sense until you realize that it's 2 teams using the system against 350, and those 2 make up 20% of the championships in the past decade.

I feel like we're having the 4 pointer conversation all over again.

I might do a free math lecture series for the good of RR over the summer.
 

NC Weasel

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
18,602
2,027
0
Well today, the superior guard play belonged to Auburn. Harper and Brown were just better than Hagans and Herro, period. On both ends.

So Pearl can only win with superior talent?

Auburn was ranked preseason in the top 10 for a reason .... today they showed why. Their DEFENSE was great and those 2 guards were hot on hot. Instead of looking at why KY lost we should be looking at why Auburn won.
 

KatforLife56

Junior
Feb 4, 2019
350
389
0
Well today, the superior guard play belonged to Auburn. Harper and Brown were just better than Hagans and Herro, period. On both ends.

So Pearl can only win with superior talent?

Auburn was ranked preseason in the top 10 for a reason .... today they showed why. Their DEFENSE was great and those 2 guards were hot on hot. Instead of looking at why KY lost we should be looking at why Auburn won.
Sounds like you are thrilled as hell that we lost. We lost because Cal does not run an offense, Herro could not get open all game, did you notice any plays being called for him? No, you did not because there weren't any. Our little turnover machine just dribbled and weaved until the shot clock was running down and then someone threw up a prayer. Cal cannot adjust to anything, we only play man defense no matter how many times we get smoked....that is also why we lost.
 

Allcats08

All-Conference
Feb 13, 2019
1,635
3,000
113
Sounds like you are thrilled as hell that we lost. We lost because Cal does not run an offense, Herro could not get open all game, did you notice any plays being called for him? No, you did not because there weren't any. Our little turnover machine just dribbled and weaved until the shot clock was running down and then someone threw up a prayer. Cal cannot adjust to anything, we only play man defense no matter how many times we get smoked....that is also why we lost.
Herro had a ton of plays designed to get him open. One I remember well, he catches it on the right block and decides to turn a 2 ft shot off the block into a fading 10 footer in to traffic.
 

KatforLife56

Junior
Feb 4, 2019
350
389
0
Herro had a ton of plays designed to get him open. One I remember well, he catches it on the right block and decides to turn a 2 ft shot off the block into a fading 10 footer in to traffic.
No, what you saw was hime coming off a down screen, which is where our guards run while they are weaving over and over. That is not a play bud, that is called an action. We don't run plays. Period.
 

LadyCaytIL

Heisman
Oct 28, 2012
33,080
34,752
113
If it wasnt for the NBA lock out... we'd not have a title and if Duke went full on one and done in 2015.. they'd not have Cook and not won the title...

Conclusion is that you have to have good players coming back for continuity.
 

Allcats08

All-Conference
Feb 13, 2019
1,635
3,000
113
No, what you saw was hime coming off a down screen, which is where our guards run while they are weaving over and over. That is not a play bud, that is called an action. We don't run plays. Period.
Nope. He cut off a back screen from pj I think from the corner to get to the strong side block. That’s a designed play.
 

School boy

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2007
5,506
3,865
0
Cal can't win because he has his role players leave early. The ones that get drafted around 30-45 second rounds.

Plus he can't run offense, it's not all about getting top talent
 

Looksbetterinblue

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2018
1,085
1,412
98
It does. Probably gives more credence to the fact that the all 5 star OAD model doesn’t work.
Hahahahaha. Doesn’t work? 99% of the teams in D1 aren’t using OAD and it justt so happens the two who use it most are the most successful teams in the last decade. Who’s kidding whom? Yes, you need more than just OaD. You need some glue guys to hold it together when times are tough but talent wins more times than not. Superior talent at the guard position is always imortabt and we just fell a little short this year in that dept. but we were a free throw from a final four.
Said differently, pick a team over the last 10 years that doesn’t use OAD which you would swap results with. Exactly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VA/UK and blubo

NoDef

All-American
Sep 1, 2001
5,187
7,168
113
It's the hardest title to win . There is a reason that the top team (OAD or veteran) only wins it 25% of the time.. heck one of the top four teams only win it like 60% of the time. This isn't football where you can just win with talent 9 out of 10 times. There is not much difference in guard play in the top 50 teams and guards are usually the ones that determine the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VA/UK

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
It does. Probably gives more credence to the fact that the all 5 star OAD model doesn’t work.

Though it made up 25% of the elite 8. Took bad games on the part of both teams to get them out. Had they played typically, they would have been half the final four.
 

TroutBum

All-Conference
Nov 4, 2014
1,927
2,960
67
How many senior laden teams didn’t win it all this year or any year for that matter?
Does that mean that model doesn’t work? Absolutely not!
You have to have good players, good coaching and some luck to win it all and in some cases, help from the refs!
 

1991greywildcat

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2014
2,337
1,580
0
No coach can win only depending on freshman and sophomore talent every season. The fact that Cal wins 30 games a year without the Anthony Davis and Zion Williamson's of the basketball world is what makes him so unique, just imagine K trying to get close, to 30 wins with last season's Kentucky team.. For as just having talent, Anthony Davis, MKG and that sqaud would not have won the title without bringing players back off that Final Four team the season before, most notably Darius Miller. I do not think Kentucky has ever won a title without a Kentucky boy playing major minutes somehow..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat
Oct 8, 2017
671
568
0
Well today, the superior guard play belonged to Auburn. Harper and Brown were just better than Hagans and Herro, period. On both ends.

So Pearl can only win with superior talent?

Auburn was ranked preseason in the top 10 for a reason .... today they showed why. Their DEFENSE was great and those 2 guards were hot on hot. Instead of looking at why KY lost we should be looking at why Auburn won.

Good post as we can’t hide from what was evident! Herro and Hagans need to use this game as experience and motivation to come back and lead a great recruiting class and a few other sophomores to a Final Four—like Harper and Brown did!! Talent with experience is paramount, as we saw with Cal’s UK Championship team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VA/UK

JAC71

All-American
Jun 28, 2015
5,065
9,544
113
Tournaments always seem dominated by great gaurd play. Now with alot of teams going with the small ball approach I will be curious what Cal does with next years roster.
 
Oct 8, 2017
671
568
0
Doesn’t Shasheski have 5 National Championships?

But only one in the OAD era—and how many years has he been at the Dukies to get the other 4!!?

K is a good coach but Cal may be better! If Cal’s teams could shoot FT’s better in critical games, going back to his Memphis championship final against Kansass, he’d probably have at least a couple more titles!
 

K_TIME

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
18,517
26,074
113
If it wasnt for the NBA lock out... we'd not have a title and if Duke went full on one and done in 2015.. they'd not have Cook and not won the title...

Conclusion is that you have to have good players coming back for continuity.
Good point...on Terrance Jones coming back influenced by NBA lockout
 

K_TIME

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
18,517
26,074
113
Who the hell do you wanna replace Cal with? All of the “smart” guys wanna whine, but what the is the alternative? Please inform us.
1. Cal is a top notch coach...but he's stubborn and his trajectory the last 4 years isn't the same as his first 6 years. So let's not act like he might be un-replaceable if he is stubborn and not willing to react.
2. I'd argue Greg Marshall has shown a ton and could be successful at UK, I'd hate the thought of Tony Bennett's style at UK but he is another, I don't know if Billy Donovan has had enough of NBA yet but he's a proven commodity, Jay Wright may be a Nova lifer but he'd be a plus candidate, Mark Few at Zags has had them top 10 program for a long time now, etc...

I think it's so short sighted to argue nobody else would come to UK that could win titles. THe UK program sort of recruits for itself with any coach to be honest.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
I guess it depends on what your definition of OAD is.

In 2012 we were able to recruit the kids we needed to win a national championship and we were lucky to retain Jones, develop Darius Miller, and had a supporting cast of Lamb, Vargas, Beckham, Hood and I can't remember who else.

This was during an era where we could get who we wanted.

That era doesn't exist anymore. Between avoiding landmines of kids with an NCAA investigation bank account and having the dilution of other programs buying into the OAD mentality, the odds of us combining a mix of veteran leadership and POY candidate freshmen is going to be very, very slim.

Our definition of OAD has also become pretty loose because we think we have 4 OADs coming in but the reality is that maybe 1 or 2 of them really are and the rest of them by virtue of being freshmen and recruited at Kentucky are lumped into the OAD label. See 5 star "project" Nick Richards as an example.

And to say there are only 2 programs invested in the OAD is wrong. First, Kansas has been doing this as well, and secondly, when you consider now we really only end up with 1 or 2 true OADs (because for example you can't count PJ, Richards, Montgomery, etc.) then virtually any school that has a highly rated recruit as a freshmen is now in the OAD game.

The biggest issue is we aren't recruiting kids we need , we're recruiting kids we want that are available.

In 2012 we *might* have lost Zion to Duke but not Zion, Barrett and Jones, now UK loses Wiseman to Memphis, Edwards to Georgia and we find ourselves having to put all our recruiting efforts into landing our 4th big man choice
 

Trinity45

All-American
Oct 26, 2005
3,428
5,354
113
It does. Probably gives more credence to the fact that the all 5 star OAD model doesn’t work.

I agree over all. Trying to rely on a bunch of freshmen just has too many flaws, hell Duke has the top two out of three picks and they struggled the entire tournament. You need a balance, I don't think we get this far or have this good a season with out Travis and we only had him for one season. Think what it would be like if you had a Travis like player for 4 season, having had Cal for 4 years learning the ropes and helping younger players. Cal had unused scholarships but he chose not to fill them, hell he gave one to his son who should not be wasting a scholarship on since Cal makes over 9 mil a year.
 

Mike-D

Heisman
Jul 14, 2001
50,624
76,125
113
1. Cal is a top notch coach...but he's stubborn and his trajectory the last 4 years isn't the same as his first 6 years. So let's not act like he might be un-replaceable if he is stubborn and not willing to react.
2. I'd argue Greg Marshall has shown a ton and could be successful at UK, I'd hate the thought of Tony Bennett's style at UK but he is another, I don't know if Billy Donovan has had enough of NBA yet but he's a proven commodity, Jay Wright may be a Nova lifer but he'd be a plus candidate, Mark Few at Zags has had them top 10 program for a long time now, etc...

I think it's so short sighted to argue nobody else would come to UK that could win titles. THe UK program sort of recruits for itself with any coach to be honest.

The Tony Bennett nut huggers act like the dude never lost to a 16 seed last year. Mark Few lost in the Elite-8 like we did. Jay Wright got destroyed in the 2nd round by 30. Greg Marshal was in the NIT this year.

I think you’re just rambling at this point.
 

KyCatFan1

Heisman
May 6, 2002
30,867
31,594
113
Well today, the superior guard play belonged to Auburn. Harper and Brown were just better than Hagans and Herro, period. On both ends.

So Pearl can only win with superior talent?

Auburn was ranked preseason in the top 10 for a reason .... today they showed why. Their DEFENSE was great and those 2 guards were hot on hot. Instead of looking at why KY lost we should be looking at why Auburn won.

Because Auburn's 3 and 4 star experienced guards smoked our 5 star one and done players that won't stay around a second year to get more experienced. In 2 games, those 2 Auburn guards put up 90 points against us.
 

K_TIME

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
18,517
26,074
113
The Tony Bennett nut huggers act like the dude never lost to a 16 seed last year. Mark Few lost in the Elite-8 like we did. Jay Wright got destroyed in the 2nd round by 30. Greg Marshal was in the NIT this year.

I think you’re just rambling at this point.
Ok you’re right. Nobody else could win at UK but the all knowing Cal

But almost all UK coaches that have won title is goofy stat in your way
 
May 27, 2007
32,279
25,677
113
lol the best thing about Duke losing is now we don't have to hear Duke Blu come on here and proclaim them as the greatest basketball team in the history of college basketball anymore lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

blubo

Heisman
Oct 14, 2014
22,273
85,181
78
Hahahahaha. Doesn’t work? 99% of the teams in D1 aren’t using OAD and it justt so happens the two who use it most are the most successful teams in the last decade. Who’s kidding whom? Yes, you need more than just OaD. You need some glue guys to hold it together when times are tough but talent wins more times than not. Superior talent at the guard position is always imortabt and we just fell a little short this year in that dept. but we were a free throw from a final four.
Said differently, pick a team over the last 10 years that doesn’t use OAD which you would swap results with. Exactly.

Your first sentence should end the debate.
 

Elliott Tim

All-American
Dec 10, 2005
10,122
6,290
0
If it wasnt for the NBA lock out... we'd not have a title and if Duke went full on one and done in 2015.. they'd not have Cook and not won the title...

Conclusion is that you have to have good players coming back for continuity.
Foundation is the key. Sandy ground gives way to the pressure . You are spot on.
 

MegaBlue05

Heisman
Mar 8, 2014
11,279
23,111
66
No, what you saw was hime coming off a down screen, which is where our guards run while they are weaving over and over. That is not a play bud, that is called an action. We don't run plays. Period.

Send your application to Mitch, coach. I expect you to go undefeated each season with a 49 ppg margin of victory.
 

VA/UK

All-Conference
Dec 2, 2011
932
1,662
0
1. Cal is a top notch coach...but he's stubborn and his trajectory the last 4 years isn't the same as his first 6 years. So let's not act like he might be un-replaceable if he is stubborn and not willing to react.
2. I'd argue Greg Marshall has shown a ton and could be successful at UK, I'd hate the thought of Tony Bennett's style at UK but he is another, I don't know if Billy Donovan has had enough of NBA yet but he's a proven commodity, Jay Wright may be a Nova lifer but he'd be a plus candidate, Mark Few at Zags has had them top 10 program for a long time now, etc...

I think it's so short sighted to argue nobody else would come to UK that could win titles. THe UK program sort of recruits for itself with any coach to be honest.
Billy Gillespie on line two. These attacks on Cal are pathetic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Looksbetterinblue
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football What happened on every Kentucky red zone possession against Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Stein Proud of Kentucky's Fight, but will not have a Loser's Mentality
  3. 03 KSR Football Instant Takeaways: Red zone miscues, porous pass defense help continue Kentucky's November losing streak
  4. 04 KSR Football Stein: Kentucky Must Finish Strong in the "Most Important Game of the Year"
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein says he "friggin' hates losing" in his postgame press conference