SCOTUS Term 2026-27

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Once again, we find ourselves in the dog days of August. The World Cup is behind us, there is no football, Ovi hasn't yet come back from Russia, the WNBA is still trying to run a business on the strength of hyperdramatics usually reserved for football site political forums, and honestly, who would watch baseball these days (and particularly given that the outcome is now foreordained for the Dodger Death Star)? So thoughts turn to fall, and when thoughts turn to fall, ol' Aardvark checks out the current docket for the upcoming SCOTUS term in October. As always, I do genuinely appreciate the collective efforts to keep this thread at least sorta-kinda on substance, and with a minimum of twitter feeds. Last year I thought we had a few interesting discussions.

So without further ado...

This year's term is shaping up to be pretty interesting. While last year's biggest cases tended (IMO) to revolve around government structural matters and the limits of executive power, this year's docket - at least so far - looks like it is going to tackle a host of more substantive legal-policy issues that are likely to be "sexier" in the eyes of the general public.

The October session kicks off with a bang, with a case involving whether federal law preempts state law claims by local governments against energy companies, for alleged injuries ultimately resulting from climate change (and particularly "interstate" pollution from fossil fuel combustion). (To my surprise, there seems to be a fair bit of analogous case law here). In October, we also have some interesting and important cases - well, they're all important -- involving jurisdiction for VA benefit disputes, ERISA fiduciary duties, when alien detention lasts long enough to trigger due process rights, and a privacy oriented case arising out of the "Bork" law involving video rental data. And it would not surprise me as well if we get some emergency docket activity in the runup to the fall elections.

After that, there are a host of potentially big cases not yet scheduled for argument, including...
-whether Title IX allows private actions for employment discrimination (or whether that's instead restricted to title VII);
-the 2A AR 15 case;
-the Excessive Fines case (Jouppi, which I think someone raised in last year's thread);
-a 1A case involving exclusions of Catholic schools from preschool subsidies;
-parental standing to challenge laws limiting their role in gender transitions of their children;
-another 1A case involving a pro se (!) litigant's challenge to local restrictions on his Orthodox Jewish prayer group in his home;
-an RNC challenge to voter registration and citizenship verification processes
-whether you actually have a right to a 12 person jury in criminal matters, rather than less than that.
 
Last edited:

Finance85

All-Conference
Dec 16, 2022
1,621
2,755
113
Once again, we find ourselves in the dog days of August. The World Cup is behind us, there is no football, Ovi hasn't yet come back from Russia, the WNBA is still trying to run a business on the strength of hyperdramatics usually reserved for football site political forums, and honestly, who would watch baseball these days (and particularly given that the outcome is now foreordained for the Dodger Death Star)? So thoughts turn to fall, and when thoughts turn to fall, ol' Aardvark checks out the current docket for the upcoming SCOTUS term in October. As always, I do genuinely appreciate the collective efforts to keep this thread at least sorta-kinda on substance, and with a minimum of twitter feeds. Last year I thought we had a few interesting discussions.

So without further ado...

This year's term is shaping up to be pretty interesting. While last year's biggest cases tended (IMO) to revolve around government structural matters and the limits of executive power, this year's docket - at least so far - looks like it is going to tackle a host of more substantive legal-policy issues that are likely to be "sexier" in the eyes of the general public.

The October session kicks off with a bang, with a case involving whether federal law preempts state law claims by local governments against energy companies, for alleged injuries ultimately resulting from climate change (and particularly "interstate" pollution). (To my surprise, there seems to be a fair bit of analogous case law here). In October, we also have some interesting and important cases - well, they're all important -- involving jurisdiction for VA benefit disputes, ERISA fiduciary duties, when alien detention lasts long enough to trigger due process rights, and a privacy oriented case arising out of the "Bork" law involving video rental data. And it would not surprise me as well if we get some emergency docket activity in the runup to the fall elections.

After that, there are a host of potentially big cases not yet scheduled for argument, including...
-whether Title IX allows private actions for employment discrimination (or whether that's instead restricted to title VII);
-the 2A AR 15 case;
-the Excessive Fines case (Jouppi, which I think someone raised in last year's thread);
-a 1A case involving exclusions of Catholic schools from preschool subsidies;
-parental standing to challenge laws limiting their role in gender transitions of their children;
-another 1A case involving a pro se (!) litigant's challenge to local restrictions on his Orthodox Jewish prayer group in his home;
-an RNC challenge to voter registration and citizenship verification processes
-whether you actually have a right to a 12 person jury in criminal matters, rather than less than that.
Thanks for the post!

I'm anticipating some applications for cert related to cases affected by rulings from the last term. I think the SCOTUS is getting tired of lower courts straying too far.

I'm particularly interesting in the 2A case and Jouppi case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aardvark86

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Thanks for the post!

I'm anticipating some applications for cert related to cases affected by rulings from the last term. I think the SCOTUS is getting tired of lower courts straying too far.

I'm particularly interesting in the 2A case and Jouppi case.
Honestly, I'm pretty indifferent on all 2A cases. But Jouppi is really interesting, and in the modern legislative world of civil penalties and multipliers which I am going to guess you are somewhat familiar with, holds the possibility for some absolutely wonderful mischief in the future.

For example, just jumping immediately to mind, I am recalling a matter I handled during covid which involved late reporting of certain pricing information by an ex-US drug manufacturer, to California. Now, under this particular regulatory scheme, California literally did absolutely nothing with the information reported to it. They didn't even question the substance of "what" you reported (and if memory serves, may have even limited the number of characters you could use in reporting). It was, essentially, just an in terrorem nuisance law designed to try to dissuade price increases (16%/2-3 years if I recall) by triggering reporting. (And again, they didn't regulate prices or prohibit you from taking them.) But if you were late on your report and had a lot of product/line items...well, that was a different story. $10k/day/line item. So they sought 8 figures from my client because no one was in the US office during covid to pick up the snail-mail notice they sent while the clock was running. In fairness, the AG guys were pretty reasonable in negotiating a settlement, but...seriously?
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
So a baby update today as we had an order list. Pretty dull stuff with no grants, though I'm sure there will be those who are excited, puzzled, or both, as to the fact that the court denied reconsideration in the E Jean Carroll case, which I could care less about.

While I was at it, I took a peek at the emergency docket. We have the ballroom application for stay, and we have two applications for stay on the mail in ballot EO litigation. And then we have a curious private application, in CEMEX, which sought to stay a 9th circuit order compelling collective bargaining, on the basis that the original election (which the employer won but was found to have committed unfair labor practices) was held 8 years ago and something north of 50% of the employees had turned over. A curious application because Justice Kagan (ordinarily CJ for 9th circuit matters) already denied it, and then CEMEX refiled it with Justice Alito for reasons not apparent in the record. Interestingly, the rules provide for that in some situations, but I have no idea what they are here.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Interesting post on the 4th amendment. Probably all things we already know, but they did Mayor Pete wrong. Should never have happened to him.

Pete Buttigieg, the Supreme Court, and the Fourth Amendment | SCOTUSblog
Yeah, i suppose if i ever had a knock at the door asking to enter, I'd probably strike a middle ground if they didn't have a warrant. Question 1: am I a witness, subject, or target of whatever it is you're looking into? Anything other than witness starts with a no. Question 2: Recognizing that you don't have a warrant (at least yet), please explain to me what you believe your basis for probable cause would be to enter? (do you mind if i record this?)
 

lucas80

Heisman
Jan 30, 2008
17,458
40,938
113
Yeah, i suppose if i ever had a knock at the door asking to enter, I'd probably strike a middle ground if they didn't have a warrant. Question 1: am I a witness, subject, or target of whatever it is you're looking into? Anything other than witness starts with a no. Question 2: Recognizing that you don't have a warrant (at least yet), please explain to me what you believe your basis for probable cause would be to enter? (do you mind if i record this?)
LOL if you think the guys would bother to knock, care about question #1, or give you enough time to utter your question #2 before giving you a tune up. Recording officers is now considered threatening agents if you are not up to speed on that.
The justices declined to hear Trump cry about the first Carroll lawsuit, but I suspect they will want to find a way to give Trump a win on the second suit under the gigantic umbrella of immunity they created for Republican presidents. It will be interesting to see if they decide that the best way to protect an underground bunker is by building a ball room that seats 1000 people over it.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
LOL if you think the guys would bother to knock, care about question #1, or give you enough time to utter your question #2 before giving you a tune up. Recording officers is now considered threatening agents if you are not up to speed on that.
The justices declined to hear Trump cry about the first Carroll lawsuit, but I suspect they will want to find a way to give Trump a win on the second suit under the gigantic umbrella of immunity they created for Republican presidents. It will be interesting to see if they decide that the best way to protect an underground bunker is by building a ball room that seats 1000 people over it.
Well sure, I mean I guess you could just go through life presuming everybody just acts in bad faith, but that makes for an awfully long slog.

Ftr, as it happens, I coasted through two stop lights this morning at 0630 on my bike in downtown Lexington. Got pulled over. Officer was courteous and professional (as was I) and kindly left me off with a warning rather than causing my car insurance premiums to ironically skyrocket for bicycle based misconduct. Go figure.
 
Last edited:

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
27,997
26,994
113
This ruling surprised me a little bit. Seemingly very consequential? Will it stand? I know it’s not a final ruling but still seems consequential

 
Last edited:

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113


listened to this on my drive home this evening re the Colorado case that opens the term. Not too bad but could have used someone to present the state perspective. And the fourth guy was a little wacky.
 
Last edited:

Finance85

All-Conference
Dec 16, 2022
1,621
2,755
113
Interesting there are no posts here about SCOTUS, at least temporarily, slamming the door on Trump's USPS election control scheme.

I'm particularly interested in the logic regarding the assumption the federal government can set rules for state run elections to federal office that go beyond Constitutional requirements or qualifications. I think Roberts knows he will have to address that concept if Trump keeps pushing the envelope, and doesn't want to go there.

Roberts already has to deal with the Gorsuch effect of pushing back against Chevron, as well as Gorsuch pushing back on federal control of the People (Indian tribes). Alito and Thomas will always side with a far right agenda, and Roberts must already be tired of Jackson not respecting protocol during oral arguments and writing increasingly tortured concurring / dissenting opinions based on social outcomes instead of law.

It may just be me, but it seems like there's been a major trend of all the justices writing their own concurring in part opinions on both opinions and dissents. That undoubtedly extends the timelines for opinions of be published, and complicates future cases on similar legal issues.

And of course, Roberts is undoubtedly weary of Trump's burden on the Court by pushing the envelope on so many legal fronts,
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy

THE_DEVIL

Heisman
Dec 16, 2022
5,648
11,335
113
Interesting there are no posts here about SCOTUS, at least temporarily, slamming the door on Trump's USPS election control scheme.

I'm particularly interested in the logic regarding the assumption the federal government can set rules for state run elections to federal office that go beyond Constitutional requirements or qualifications. I think Roberts knows he will have to address that concept if Trump keeps pushing the envelope, and doesn't want to go there.

Roberts already has to deal with the Gorsuch effect of pushing back against Chevron, as well as Gorsuch pushing back on federal control of the People (Indian tribes). Alito and Thomas will always side with a far right agenda, and Roberts must already be tired of Jackson not respecting protocol during oral arguments and writing increasingly tortured concurring / dissenting opinions based on social outcomes instead of law.

It may just be me, but it seems like there's been a major trend of all the justices writing their own concurring in part opinions on both opinions and dissents. That undoubtedly extends the timelines for opinions of be published, and complicates future cases on similar legal issues.

And of course, Roberts is undoubtedly weary of Trump's burden on the Court by pushing the envelope on so many legal fronts,
Roberts has no one but himself for issues at the Court.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Interesting there are no posts here about SCOTUS, at least temporarily, slamming the door on Trump's USPS election control scheme.

I'm particularly interested in the logic regarding the assumption the federal government can set rules for state run elections to federal office that go beyond Constitutional requirements or qualifications. I think Roberts knows he will have to address that concept if Trump keeps pushing the envelope, and doesn't want to go there.

Roberts already has to deal with the Gorsuch effect of pushing back against Chevron, as well as Gorsuch pushing back on federal control of the People (Indian tribes). Alito and Thomas will always side with a far right agenda, and Roberts must already be tired of Jackson not respecting protocol during oral arguments and writing increasingly tortured concurring / dissenting opinions based on social outcomes instead of law.

It may just be me, but it seems like there's been a major trend of all the justices writing their own concurring in part opinions on both opinions and dissents. That undoubtedly extends the timelines for opinions of be published, and complicates future cases on similar legal issues.

And of course, Roberts is undoubtedly weary of Trump's burden on the Court by pushing the envelope on so many legal fronts,
I've actually had a couple of crazy weeks, and while I certainly saw these, I just have not had time to dive in to them at all (eg, to look at the actual application for stay). With that huge caveat...

I agree with where I think you're going (ie, congress can enact national election limits that can essentially preempt state standards, but I'm not sure what authority the president has to do that independent of congressional actions). While I've not looked at the briefs, I'm inferring from Kav's brief concurrence that they may have been arguing that this isn't so much an "election" rule as it is a general "postal service" rule (akin to rules that might apply to mailing of an LLBean catalog). Seems like a stretch to me. I don't know that I'd interpret Kav's opinion as being a clear 'yes' on that front - timing seems to be his ultimate rationale. I've not read the dissent at all, so maybe i'm missing some other argument they're making.

As far as concurrences and dissents, I don't know if its actually as dramatic as it seems in a statistical sense. But where I do think you're right is that we're seeing it on emergency docket petitions, which is a little weird.

I don't envy the Chief one bit. I admire the fact that he really does try to keep his eye on the institutional interests of "the Court" in a pretty complicated time with quite the herd of cats. For my money, the only place where people might quibble with his leadership role on a substantive issue is on race-based preferences and remedies, where he's clearly a tip of the spear guy. (That said, even there, i think it's very fair of him to ask 'just when does this all end?")
 
  • Like
Reactions: Finance85

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Not a scotus case, but if the creek don't rise (ie, if my schedule doesn't blow up in the next month), I'm going to try to head to Richmond to see the Fourth Circuit's en banc argument in what could prove to be two really interesting cases involving drug pricing that I think have a pretty fair chance of showing up at scotus in the foreseeable future due to the really interesting theoretical argument that was adopted by the district court and fourth circuit panel that essentially asserts a new form of preemption analysis. (Abbvie v Brown, PhRMA v McCuskey). Basically, the federal 340b drug program requires drug manufacturers to sell their products at a discount to safety net health care providers. During covid, a number of manufacturers implemented policies saying they wouldn't distribute 340b drugs to contract pharmacies independent of the providers, and successfully defended that from federal enforcement in a number of federal lawsuits. Enter the states. A bunch of states in turn enacted state laws saying manufacturers couldn't implement their policies as a matter of state law, even if the federal program law didn't prohibit it. So, manufacturers challenged those laws on federal field preemption grounds (ie, federal law occupies the field and states can interfere with that), and in most cases have lost. But the fourth circuit went the other way and ruled for the manufacturers. The basis of the ruling was that, where the federal program was based on the spending clause such that federal program law set the terms of the bargain with respect to a private entity's (here, a manufacturer's) decision to participate in that program, there is a lower bar to clear for preemption, where the state law may interfere with or change the terms of that bargain.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
…aaand just like that I see they’ve stayed the injunction on third country deportation and set a December argument. Looks like both process and substantive questions. I’ve not looked at the details either way.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Good morning boys and girls. The wait is over on the first Monday in October.

Today we get the Boulder, Colorado lawsuit on whether states can sue energy companies for climate change damages under state law or whether that's preempted. A huge case actually given the political nature of most state AGs. Might be interesting with Justice Alito's recusal. I'll be listening to the argument on my early drive tomorrow and will probably hold off on the recap til then.

Separately, the court issued its long conference order this morning. No new grants, lots of cert denials (too many to see if any of interest), and nothing really interesting in terms of individual justice opinions or statements on the denials.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Been a crazy week or two so I've not had much of a chance to look at the recent emergency docket stuff relating to immigration and elections. Big 1A case today (CO may actually win this one). Going to try to listen to the argument on my drive home thursday with the dogs in the car.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,054
5,718
113
Been a crazy week or two so I've not had much of a chance to look at the recent emergency docket stuff relating to immigration and elections. Big 1A case today (CO may actually win this one). Going to try to listen to the argument on my drive home thursday with the dogs in the car.

Where do you stand on the CO case (I'm assuming we're talking about Catholic schools wanting to ban kids with gay parents while still getting public funds)? It'll be nuts to me if SCOTUS supports the church; that would be the dumbest freedom of religion transgression in an increasingly stupid reality on this topic.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
Where do you stand on the CO case (I'm assuming we're talking about Catholic schools wanting to ban kids with gay parents while still getting public funds)? It'll be nuts to me if SCOTUS supports the church; that would be the dumbest freedom of religion transgression in an increasingly stupid reality on this topic.
First of all, on the religious front (and I'm saying this as a practicing Catholic), I can't help but wonder what this particular parish is thinking. To be sure, the Church supports heterosexual marriage, and only heterosexual marriage, as a sacramental institution, which I happen to agree with. But it doesn't close the doors to Mass to lgbtetc. persons, it holds them wide open. I'm scratching my head why the school doors should be closed to a child of such persons if the Mass doors aren't, and particularly as a matter of necessity for free exercise. But of course, the courts (rightfully) don't get into second guessing those sorts of questions.

On the legal front, my instinct is that CO should win, as the parish has tried to weave two things together that don't really go together. With that said...the one thing I'm not sure I understand factually is whether this preschool program is entirely state-funded, or whether there's also federal funding in play. If there is federal money involved, it could be a little more complicated. Last week I attended a Fourth Circuit en banc argument in an incredibly interesting case involving drug pricing (PhRMA v McCuskey). What makes it interesting is that PhRMA was pushing (and the district court and 4Cir panel adopted) a truly novel theory of preemption that my instinct says has (or should have) something to it. In essence, the theory (which I'm calling "Spending Clause Preemption") is that if a federal law is enacted under the authority of the Constitution's spending clause, it is easier to preempt a state law (or a construction of a state law) that seeks to graft new conditions on to participation in the federal spending program, because states should not be able to modify the terms of a quintessentially federal bargain. In PhRMA, the theory was extended to preempt a state law even where the federal law was silent as to the conduct the state law intended to mandate. So here, suppose this was a federally funded program, and suppose further that the feds (or at least the current feds) took the position that various federal religious protections wouldn't preclude the church's position here. Would the state's position change the terms of the federal participation bargain?

One of the reasons I'm intrigued by the Spending Clause Preemption theory is that it would provide a nice counterbalance to current Takings Clause jurisprudence. In the takings context, the courts have usually held (unless you're a state) that no matter how big a gun you have held to your head (say, the 1600% taxes levied if you don't participate in drug price negotiations), if you agree to participate rather than having your head blown off, it's voluntary and there can be no takings claim. Contrast that with a federal spending clause program which everyone acknowledges is voluntary, but which a third party that is not a party to the deal can change the terms of the deal after you've agreed to it. Somewhere, "voluntary" should mean voluntary on teh program's own terms. BTW, the 4th circuit was split during the argument, so it's almost certain IMO that one of the parties is going to try to take the theory to Scotus in the future.

BTW, for a good chuckle, check out about the 56:00 mark of the WV argument: ca4.uscourts.gov/OAarchive/mp3/25-1054-20261027.mp3
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: FLaw47

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
So I did listen to the st Mary’s argument on the drive home last night (with Mrs a in the car, which made for a few chuckles). Obviously the post argument press suggested that the parish looks on track to win, and I’d certainly agree with that.
Ultimately, I still think the state argument that participation opportunity was neutral is the better one. But the parish argument was a little trickier than I’d thought, in that I’m not sure there much of a distinction between overt exclusionary criteria and failure to grant an exception where neutral ones might affect free exercise. A lot of detail on which parts of two lines of precedent were still surviving, which I didn’t follow as well.
Bigger picture, I continue to question - theologically - the parish’s “need” for this exclusion. Catholicism is about so much more than lgbtetc issues.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,054
5,718
113
So I did listen to the st Mary’s argument on the drive home last night (with Mrs a in the car, which made for a few chuckles). Obviously the post argument press suggested that the parish looks on track to win, and I’d certainly agree with that.
Ultimately, I still think the state argument that participation opportunity was neutral is the better one. But the parish argument was a little trickier than I’d thought, in that I’m not sure there much of a distinction between overt exclusionary criteria and failure to grant an exception where neutral ones might affect free exercise. A lot of detail on which parts of two lines of precedent were still surviving, which I didn’t follow as well.
Bigger picture, I continue to question - theologically - the parish’s “need” for this exclusion. Catholicism is about so much more than lgbtetc issues.

I appreciate your perspective on this. You're clearly much more informed than I am on the specifics of the law; I have the luxury of some ignorance and can just weigh in on what it looks like from 15,000 feet.

What it looks like from 15,000 feet is that the Roberts Court has completely lost the thread on free exercise of religion and I hope a future (hopeful) liberal minority can unceremoniously reverse all of this, since stare decisis is effectively dead whenever the court feels like it.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,607
3,650
113
I appreciate your perspective on this. You're clearly much more informed than I am on the specifics of the law; I have the luxury of some ignorance and can just weigh in on what it looks like from 15,000 feet.

What it looks like from 15,000 feet is that the Roberts Court has completely lost the thread on free exercise of religion and I hope a future (hopeful) liberal minority can unceremoniously reverse all of this, since stare decisis is effectively dead whenever the court feels like it.
oh, i don't know that I'd say they lost the thread. There's always been a very weird tension between the principles of "free exercise" and "establishment", and at least directionally, I think they're right to be focusing more on effects and not simply intent on the former. And given that direction, the pervasiveness of spending programs, where schools have become the locus of delivery of pretty much every social service beyond education that you can imagine, has been such that these types of cases have probably become unavoidable.

Where the "next" tension may ultimately arise is that, in the religion context, we're focusing more on effects these days, yet in other discrimination contexts, the arrows are pointing more toward intent.

I'd also note that as uncomfortable as it is to recognize it, the way some states (including Colorado itself) have responded to these cases when they lose makes one wonder whether there actually is a little religious animus going on in the background. Indeed, the weirdest part about this case (aside from my personal views of the theology of it) is that there doesn't actually seem to be any preschooler that's actually been aggrieved, which makes you wonder why both parties have kept fighting it to this point. Probably symptomatic of my personal pet peeve about modern cases with fake plaintiffs where the "real" party is some sort of legal think tank interest group rather than an actual, injured human being or institution. (And again, as a practicing catholic, i don't say those last words lightly.)
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,054
5,718
113
oh, i don't know that I'd say they lost the thread. There's always been a very weird tension between the principles of "free exercise" and "establishment", and at least directionally, I think they're right to be focusing more on effects and not simply intent on the former. And given that direction, the pervasiveness of spending programs, where schools have become the locus of delivery of pretty much every social service beyond education that you can imagine, has been such that these types of cases have probably become unavoidable.

Where the "next" tension may ultimately arise is that, in the religion context, we're focusing more on effects these days, yet in other discrimination contexts, the arrows are pointing more toward intent.

I'd also note that as uncomfortable as it is to recognize it, the way some states (including Colorado itself) have responded to these cases when they lose makes one wonder whether there actually is a little religious animus going on in the background. Indeed, the weirdest part about this case (aside from my personal views of the theology of it) is that there doesn't actually seem to be any preschooler that's actually been aggrieved, which makes you wonder why both parties have kept fighting it to this point. Probably symptomatic of my personal pet peeve about modern cases with fake plaintiffs where the "real" party is some sort of legal think tank interest group rather than an actual, injured human being or institution. (And again, as a practicing catholic, i don't say those last words lightly.)

Fully agree on your last paragraph. Where was the standing on this? I feel like standing has been one of the most effective tools SCOTUS has weaponized to ignore cases that they don't want to deal with or usher forward cases with bogus justifications. I don't think I could begin to tell you if a case had standing without also knowing what the prosecution was trying to get as an outcome; that seems to be a more effective measure of if a case will be heard or not.

I do think Colorado screwed up by offering any funding to any religious schools but I'm sure they'd have been sued over that as well (and lost).
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Wednesday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Additional intel on why evaluation and valuation are major points of scrutiny under Dabo Swinney
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football The uncomfortable truth for Dabo Swinney and Clemson
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Recruiting Tuesday Clemson Football Recruiting Nuggets
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football The days of Clemson rubber-stamping Dabo Swinney's contractual decisions are probably over