Schiano to Pats as DC

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,668
151,496
113
I didn’t realized Belichick son is the Patriots safety coach. Never played the position but must have learned something from Schiano. Belichick trusted Schiano to teach his son the ropes.

Schiano probably should follow the lead of the defensive backs and not make any drastic changes.
Not sure I’d go that far. He played lacrosse at Rutgers and walked on to the football team for one season.
 

BIGTENITCH

Sophomore
Aug 31, 2017
551
143
0
Best of luck to Schiano. Another reason to root for them when the Giants an Jets R done with the season. I'm sure Bellichick would be happy to see Schiano leave for Rutgers should a mutual interest exist.
 

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
I always get a chuckle by posters who think he is coming back to Rutgers. He is 52 and failed at his first stint as an NFL head coach. He now apparently has worked his way back into the NFL with the world champs, nah, he is going to give up the opportunity with a little luck and hard work to get a possible second chance at NFL glory to come back to Piscataway. The man left what was in fact a job for life for the NFL dream, he may now have a second bite of the apple if he plays his cards right, but he is going to give that all up and come back to the job he left in the first place for the NFL. None of it makes any sense, unless you are a highly emotional and sentimental Rutgers football fan.
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,764
7,798
113
I always get a chuckle by posters who think he is coming back to Rutgers. He is 52 and failed at his first stint as an NFL head coach. He now apparently has worked his way back into the NFL with the world champs, nah, he is going to give up the opportunity with a little luck and hard work to get a possible second chance at NFL glory to come back to Piscataway. The man left what was in fact a job for life for the NFL dream, he may now have a second bite of the apple if he plays his cards right, but he is going to give that all up and come back to the job he left in the first place for the NFL. None of it makes any sense, unless you are a highly emotional and sentimental Rutgers football fan.

This is completely logical unless that same man decides that he doesn’t want to chase the NFL anymore, and he wants to do things here that he always believed were possible. I don’t think he’s coming back but I know plenty of folks professionally who decide for one reason or another to perhaps take what is perceived to be a “step back” because they’ll ultimately be more happy.
 

BlockR

Heisman
Dec 28, 2015
23,151
22,150
113
I always get a chuckle by posters who think he is coming back to Rutgers. He is 52 and failed at his first stint as an NFL head coach. He now apparently has worked his way back into the NFL with the world champs, nah, he is going to give up the opportunity with a little luck and hard work to get a possible second chance at NFL glory to come back to Piscataway. The man left what was in fact a job for life for the NFL dream, he may now have a second bite of the apple if he plays his cards right, but he is going to give that all up and come back to the job he left in the first place for the NFL. None of it makes any sense, unless you are a highly emotional and sentimental Rutgers football fan.
and nobody knows if his desire is to become a head Coach again and figures College may be an easier path,as he showed by trying to land Vols job.
At RU, if he wins five or six games by year two/three it would far eclipse the Ash/Hobbs prison era we are all currently stuck in.
 

rutgersac88

Junior
Oct 13, 2007
229
316
53
When he left RU was in the AAC/Big East and thought that Rutgers would be left out of the Power 5. Would Schiano have left if RU was in the B1G? Who knows.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,838
50,365
98
When he left RU was in the AAC/Big East and thought that Rutgers would be left out of the Power 5. Would Schiano have left if RU was in the B1G? Who knows.
Only on this board did people think we would be left out. RU knew they were going to the B1G, was just a matter of when
 
  • Like
Reactions: TRU2RU_rivals

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,208
17,015
113
Will this stop the "Bring Schiano Back" posts on this board? I hope so.
Nope, that looks like it will never end and now every defensive play NE does next year ( in every game) will be subject to criticism by those who don't want Schiano back.

I don't expect Greg to be named NE's DC ,that title wasn't used this year.
But I expert Schiano will be blamed ( by some on this board) for every score against the Patriots D next season whether he's calling the defensive plays or not. :p

Right now the hiring is just a rumor, wait till you see the threads started if it doesn't happen.:eek:
 
  • Like
Reactions: patk89 and RUnTeX

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,960
14,044
78
Nope, that looks like it will never end and now every defensive play NE does next year ( in every game) will be subject to criticism by those who don't want Schiano back.

I don't expect Greg to be named NE's DC ,that title wasn't used this year.
But I expert Schiano will be blamed ( by some on this board) for every score against the Patriots D next season whether he's calling the defensive plays or not. :p

Right now the hiring is just a rumor, wait till you see the threads started if it doesn't happen.:eek:
Half the Rutgers fan will blame him for any loss and will be rooting for him to fail.
 

RUfinal4

All-Conference
Apr 24, 2006
15,759
1,931
0
Lots of pressure for Greg on the Pats

They are off of 3 SuperBowl appearances. It is tough in the NFL to repeat.

If the Pats fail to make the playoffs Greg may be blamed for it.

At Ohio St he had a significant talent gap that helped him a lot. That doesn't exist in the NFL.

I expect a step back for the Pats to 10-6 or 9-7 next year with some potential ligering key injuries.
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
  • Like
Reactions: bitnez

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,764
7,798
113
Lots of pressure for Greg on the Pats

They are off of 3 SuperBowl appearances. It is tough in the NFL to repeat.

If the Pats fail to make the playoffs Greg may be blamed for it.

At Ohio St he had a significant talent gap that helped him a lot. That doesn't exist in the NFL.

I expect a step back for the Pats to 10-6 or 9-7 next year with some potential ligering key injuries.

No one gets the real credit (or the blame) for the Pats defense except B.B. Sure, they throw out the obligatory, Brian Flores has done a nice job comment, but it’s always all about B.B. At the same time, if the defense performs well enough even though B.B. has a huge hand in it, GS could get another look at a HC position given that Patricia and Flores have been hired away in consecutive years
 

RUfromSoCal?

Heisman
Nov 26, 2006
35,379
43,766
113
Will this stop the "Bring Schiano Back" posts on this board? I hope so.


Unless he gets the top DC spot (which I have yet to see confirmed anywhere), then no it won't........

..in fact, it makes his return in 2020 even more likely........
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlockR

RAA-1

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2004
4,389
1,001
0
It would take him several years to fail and he will have made $3 million more. I'll take the job and would be ok with failure.
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
I always get a chuckle by posters who think he is coming back to Rutgers. He is 52 and failed at his first stint as an NFL head coach. He now apparently has worked his way back into the NFL with the world champs, nah, he is going to give up the opportunity with a little luck and hard work to get a possible second chance at NFL glory to come back to Piscataway. The man left what was in fact a job for life for the NFL dream, he may now have a second bite of the apple if he plays his cards right, but he is going to give that all up and come back to the job he left in the first place for the NFL. None of it makes any sense, unless you are a highly emotional and sentimental Rutgers football fan.

Plus, if he can't land a better job than RU HC after being the DC of OSU and the Patriots, it's time to think about early retirement and enjoying that stockpile of dough.

It amazes me that people still cling onto this silly idea. Schiano returning home as savior was a storyline that sounded romantic for about 5 minutes. It didn't happen. Nothing that's happened since has strengthened the notion that it could ever happen. Move on.
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
Plus, if he can't land a better job than RU HC after being the DC of OSU and the Patriots, it's time to think about early retirement and enjoying that stockpile of dough.

It amazes me that people still cling onto this silly idea. Schiano returning home as savior was a storyline that sounded romantic for about 5 minutes. It didn't happen. Nothing that's happened since has strengthened the notion that it could ever happen. Move on.

What’s the more silly idea: ash succeeding here or schiano coming back here?
 
  • Like
Reactions: WhiteBus and BlockR

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
Not sure why we have to pin the two against each other?

We aren’t pinning the two against each other . I think it’s related because most rutgers fans believe ash stinks and hope someone will be our savior. If Ash was doing a good job, you wouldn’t have the savior threads ...or at least a lot less of them .
 
Last edited:

RUfromSoCal?

Heisman
Nov 26, 2006
35,379
43,766
113
I vacillate back and forth on GS coming back....

but, you can't simply dismiss it as silly. (while I certainly have no idea), I've heard multiple guys in the media (and not just nj.com) say they they have spoken with "greg's people" (whatever that means) over the years (and as recently as the last 12 months) and greg would consider it (though there would be clear hurdles to over-come re: Barchi and Hobbs).... but, the point is - it's something you could put on the table...

combine that with the challenges we all see with needing someone with a vision, who has a plan, who can be a salesman for the program, who has gravitas when he speaks, who has had success, who can recruit, who wants RU and NJ to be a big player, who has contacts, who knows what it takes to win in this state and at this level............... sorry, the list of real options gets pretty short.......
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
I vacillate back and forth on GS coming back....

but, you can't simply dismiss it as silly. (while I certainly have no idea), I've heard multiple guys in the media (and not just nj.com) say they they have spoken with "greg's people" (whatever that means) over the years (and as recently as the last 12 months) and greg would consider it (though there would be clear hurdles to over-come re: Barchi and Hobbs).... but, the point is - it's something you could put on the table...

combine that with the challenges we all see with needing someone with a vision, who has a plan, who can be a salesman for the program, who has gravitas when he speaks, who has had success, who can recruit, who wants RU and NJ to be a big player, who has contacts, who knows what it takes to win in this state and at this level............... sorry, the list of real options gets pretty short.......

The amount of energy people expend discussing it is absolutely silly. Schiano was already available the last time we needed a coach. He was available this year if we woulda canned Ash. No guarantee he'll be available next time.

You go out of your way to list very specific attributes, but is Schiano 2019/2020 really what we need? Maybe, but only thing for sure is that Schiano in his 30s was what we needed at the time of a weakening Big East. Really not sure that Schiano in his 50s, coming here, because of no better options, is what we need in the B1G East.

As for "real options," don't tell me that teams as bad and well worse than us, all over the country, can find the right coach, but we only have a tiny list that's Schiano and one other guy. It's always a gamble, but just because we lost once doesn't mean we should just resign ourselves to Schiano until he's 80.
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
The amount of energy people expend discussing it is absolutely silly. Schiano was already available the last time we needed a coach. He was available this year if we woulda canned Ash. No guarantee he'll be available next time.

You go out of your way to list very specific attributes, but is Schiano 2019/2020 really what we need? Maybe, but only thing for sure is that Schiano in his 30s was what we needed at the time of a weakening Big East. Really not sure that Schiano in his 50s, coming here, because of no better options, is what we need in the B1G East.

As for "real options," don't tell me that teams as bad and well worse than us, all over the country, can find the right coach, but we only have a tiny list that's Schiano and one other guy. It's always a gamble, but just because we lost once doesn't mean we should just resign ourselves to Schiano until he's 80.

Part of the reason we get these Schiano threads is 5 of our last 6 coaching hires we have whiffed . Schiano was the only one that didn’t miss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU_DIO

BlockR

Heisman
Dec 28, 2015
23,151
22,150
113
The amount of energy people expend discussing it is absolutely silly. Schiano was already available the last time we needed a coach. He was available this year if we woulda canned Ash. No guarantee he'll be available next time.

You go out of your way to list very specific attributes, but is Schiano 2019/2020 really what we need? Maybe, but only thing for sure is that Schiano in his 30s was what we needed at the time of a weakening Big East. Really not sure that Schiano in his 50s, coming here, because of no better options, is what we need in the B1G East.

As for "real options," don't tell me that teams as bad and well worse than us, all over the country, can find the right coach, but we only have a tiny list that's Schiano and one other guy. It's always a gamble, but just because we lost once doesn't mean we should just resign ourselves to Schiano until he's 80.
its wether the Coach can naviagte all the BS from RU culture at school,recruit against B10 peers and also keep Jersey kids (to some degree ) home.
As we can see hiring an asst from Ohio,via Iowa and Wisconsin didnt work.
 

rudad02

All-American
Nov 7, 2010
8,853
5,773
0
Schiano clearly under performed with the outstanding talent he had--Rice, Leonard, Britt, Harris, Underwood, McCourty, McCourty, Harmon, Green, Sosa, Zutah, Davis, Meekins, Thompson, Foster, etc. Most of them NFL'rs. Never won a conference championship. Terrible game day coach.
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,764
7,798
113
Schiano clearly under performed with the outstanding talent he had--Rice, Leonard, Britt, Harris, Underwood, McCourty, McCourty, Harmon, Green, Sosa, Zutah, Davis, Meekins, Thompson, Foster, etc. Most of them NFL'rs. Never won a conference championship. Terrible game day coach.

He wasn’t a great game day coach but he gets credit for developing all of those guys into NFL players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MADHAT1

Knightmoves

Heisman
Jul 31, 2001
30,961
17,066
113
Nope, that looks like it will never end and now every defensive play NE does next year ( in every game) will be subject to criticism by those who don't want Schiano back.

I don't expect Greg to be named NE's DC ,that title wasn't used this year.
But I expert Schiano will be blamed ( by some on this board) for every score against the Patriots D next season whether he's calling the defensive plays or not. :p

Right now the hiring is just a rumor, wait till you see the threads started if it doesn't happen.:eek:

If Greg is named Pats DC then I will apologize for saying that would never happen.

But if Greg is not the Pats DC then he is a position coach.
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,764
7,798
113
If Greg is named Pats DC then I will apologize for saying that would never happen.

But if Greg is not the Pats DC then he is a position coach.

The Pats didn’t have a DC this past year. Flores was the LB coach, but he called plays. Don’t get hung up on the title — the key is who will be calling plays.
 

Dpgru

All-Conference
Jan 17, 2015
4,603
4,761
0
What’s the more silly idea: ash succeeding here or schiano coming back here?
because Ash succeeding here is the more silly of two options.

Believing Ash might succeed isn't being silly, it might very well be wrong and more hopeful than realistic but he is the current coach so there is at least a chance he might succeed. Schiano returning is silly, it will not happen and all the treads wanting it to happen will never change that. So, Schiano returning is a more silly belief than Ash succeeding, which may simply be unrealistic or more wishful thinking. But at least Ash being successful has a chance of happening only because he is here. Reminds me of the joke about which is more likely to happen, being eaten by a shark or being mugged in NYC? Well, if you are in the ocean in shark infested water there is a better chance of being eaten by a shark and, since you are not in NYC you have no chance of being mugged in NYC. No chance Schiano returns. Believing it will happen is silly.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,449
13,071
113
everyone Shifty disagrees with suddenly is a "jerkoff" or has "Reading comprehension problems",even though Shifty can be easily proven wrong from what he posted prior. Give it a rest Shifty. Act is tiresome.

Forget him. That Shi#ty has sailed.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,208
17,015
113
If Greg is named Pats DC then I will apologize for saying that would never happen.

But if Greg is not the Pats DC then he is a position coach.
notice I stated: "I don't expect Greg to be named NE's DC ,that title wasn't used this year."
So I don't expect an apology from anyone who thinks Schiano won't be named Belichick's DC >
I don't either.

But think Greg might be the one who calls the defensive alignments game-day , even without the DC title.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Men's Soccer earns NCAA Tournament berth for first time since 2022
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football versus Michigan State Game Time Announced
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball Rutgers vs. Albany: How to Watch, Starting Lineups, Rankings & More
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Wrestling Takes Down No. 13 Lehigh - Breaking Down Huge Ranked Win - TKR Pod
  5. 05 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026