That should’ve been a triple. Why didn’t they send the runner home? I never saw a good view of where the ball was. Obviously it worked out, but what happened there?
Rowdy’s double
- Thread starter jethreauxdawg
- Start date
Hatcher got a bad jump and had to wait and see if the ball was going to be caught. You don’t send the runner in that situation unless you are 100% sure he will make it home. You can’t afford an out at home plate with Allen coming up to bat.
It was an egregious base-running error by someone. Whether it was on Rowdey or Hatcher, or whether both got bad advice from Cheesebrough I’m not sure…but you can’t ever run that far past 2nd base without confirmation that the guy is moving from 3rd. Signals got crossed somewhere. Fortunately, it worked out.
Im going to be honest here…. But that ball (along with Cumbests RBI triple against Texas) should’ve been caught. CFer took a horrendous route to that ball that seemed to just float a little as it got out there. Thank God is got over his head.
Nobody on OR 2 outs, it’s a triple. But Hatch and Cheese were right, waiting to make sure it wasn’t caught before taking off and holding at third. Rowdey just ran with his head down. Fortunately, no one covered 2nd. And the other reason you don’t push it: TA.
The angle from the line between first and second makes that hard to read if the centerfielder is close to that ball. I think Hatcher did right. Then you can't get out 2 at home so I agree with the conservative play by the coach because I don't think Hatcher is a plus runner. Rowdy has to read the runner in front of him.
It was kind of a mix up on both Hatcher and Rowdey. Cheese was actually the one who made the right call.
Hatcher got a really bad jump. I thought at the time it wasn’t aggressive enough but it ended up working out with TA on deck. Cheese was right to hold him because if there is any chance of getting thrown out at home in that situation, you cannot send Hatcher.
Rowdey could have made third but wasn’t looking ahead to see what was happening in front of him. Got caught assuming Hatcher would score easily (which he probably should have), but luckily UVA for some reason flat out did not cover second base. It ended up costing them the game, IMO.
Hatcher got a really bad jump. I thought at the time it wasn’t aggressive enough but it ended up working out with TA on deck. Cheese was right to hold him because if there is any chance of getting thrown out at home in that situation, you cannot send Hatcher.
Rowdey could have made third but wasn’t looking ahead to see what was happening in front of him. Got caught assuming Hatcher would score easily (which he probably should have), but luckily UVA for some reason flat out did not cover second base. It ended up costing them the game, IMO.
Hatcher was about 10 feet from 2nd base when the ball hit the turf...
When he approached third the ball was still in center field. He should have gotten home easily standing up. The fact that Jordan had third easily tells you that hatch would have scored easily. We should have had 3 runs in and a runner on third. Cheese made a big mistake there. It happens and thank the lord TA erased it. Also thankfully nobody was covering second. I really don't blame Rowdey because he's watching the baseball and knows Hatch should have already been in the dugout.
When he approached third the ball was still in center field. He should have gotten home easily standing up. The fact that Jordan had third easily tells you that hatch would have scored easily. We should have had 3 runs in and a runner on third. Cheese made a big mistake there. It happens and thank the lord TA erased it. Also thankfully nobody was covering second. I really don't blame Rowdey because he's watching the baseball and knows Hatch should have already been in the dugout.
The question is not whether or not Hatcher should have been sent. The problem was when Hatcher arrived at 3rd. He should have been rounding 2nd when the ball was missed and he would have easily scored. He slowed before 2nd and then the ball was missed. Getting that run in that situation (and having Rowdy on 3rd) could have been the difference in our winning or losing. Fortunately, it was not.
Bottom line, it was a baserunning error by Hatcher. And had the ball been caught, he would have had plenty of time to retrace his steps back to 1st to not be doubled up.
Bottom line, it was a baserunning error by Hatcher. And had the ball been caught, he would have had plenty of time to retrace his steps back to 1st to not be doubled up.
Last edited:
Hatcher's run didn't matter there. You had TA coming up with the tying runs on. It wasn't worth risk of getting hatch thrown out (and it would have been a close play).
Rowdey is the one who made the mistake because he didn't pick up the 3b coach. Thankfully Virginia's defense fell asleep there.
It was 4-2, top of the 8th, and "Hatcher's run didn't matter there"???? It absolutely mattered and not getting it could have been huge. In addition, Rowdy would have been on 3rd with 1 out--a TA pop fly would have then tied the game.
Again, he should not have been sent based on when he arrived but he should have arrived earlier and been sent.
Again, he should not have been sent based on when he arrived but he should have arrived earlier and been sent.
No, it didn't matter on THAT PLAY. If TA gets a hit they both score, so you don't want to erase one of them before he gets the chance.
What you guys are missing by griping over that play by Hatcher is that there was a very good chance that he would have been a dead duck at home. If he gets thrown out in that spot, it's catastrophic.
Geez.
I think he would have been out at the plate anyway. He wasn’t exactly greased lightning running the bags
^^^. This. ^^^. Only Hatcher didn't get a bad jump. He played it exactly right. You can tell it from the position Hatcher was in when the camera switched to third base. He was in the perfect spot, about 2/3s of the way between first and second, waiting to see if the ball was caught. The second the ball got by the center fielder, he was off like a rocket. Rowdey was running full speed the whole time. Rowdey is the one who almost blew it. He should have looked up sooner. We're really fortunate that it didn't cost us. UVa's first baseman should have been following the play and should have been standing on second to tag Rowdey when he returned.
No, Allen had third easily because the throw was going home. And the ball was not still in CF. It was going to be bang/bang at the plate and you don't take that chance and throw away a rally chance in that spot.
Cheese was right. Hatcher was right. Rowdey can't go into business for himself - he has to pick up his 3b coach there. I'm sure he was reminded of that later, along with a scolding for showing up his coach.
Please reread my post. The play at home wouldn't have been close if Hatcher hadn't paused before 2nd base.
He had to. He couldn't tell if the CF was going to catch the ball. Their CF almost got to that. What he did there was textbook.....go 3/4ths of the way and read the play.
It was absolutely the right move to hold the runner up. I didn't see at first
but the throw was coming in hot. Would have been a bang bang play. With Allen up next with just 1 out, you have to hold him at third.
but the throw was coming in hot. Would have been a bang bang play. With Allen up next with just 1 out, you have to hold him at third.
Multiple things can be true at once.
1. Given where Hatcher was, I think it was the right call for Cheese to hold him. You don't risk getting thrown out at home with TA coming to bat.
2. Hatcher should have scored and it should have been a triple for Rowdey. But Hatcher held up too soon. If he's standing on 2B when that ball drops, he scores. And with the ball carrying away from 1B, he could have afforded to hold up a bit later, because if the CF catches it, his momentum is taking him away from the throw back to 1B.
3. Rowdey should have had his eyes up toward Cheese to see what was happening in front of him.
1. Given where Hatcher was, I think it was the right call for Cheese to hold him. You don't risk getting thrown out at home with TA coming to bat.
2. Hatcher should have scored and it should have been a triple for Rowdey. But Hatcher held up too soon. If he's standing on 2B when that ball drops, he scores. And with the ball carrying away from 1B, he could have afforded to hold up a bit later, because if the CF catches it, his momentum is taking him away from the throw back to 1B.
3. Rowdey should have had his eyes up toward Cheese to see what was happening in front of him.
I was thinking this too . . . where was the first baseman on that play?
I watched the play again, and the first baseman was the cutoff man for the throw to home plate. Thus, he was on the infield grass near the pitcher's mound when he cut off the throw.
The shortstop was out on the outfield grass as the cutoff man for a throw to 3rd base and the second baseman was backing him up. (I think this is the typical play on a ball driven to left-centerfield that gets over the centerfielder's head.)
Because Hatcher was on 1B when Rowdy hit the ball, the first baseman had to be the cutoff for the throw home. This left nobody to cover 2B when Rowdy overran the bag.
If Rowdy had hesitated another 1/2 second before returning to 2B, then the first baseman would've been able to tag him.
Yeah. There's no chance Hatcher gets doubled off on that ball. It's just a bad read by him. He thought it was a routine fly ball and he wasn't as aggressive as he should have been.
Perez points this out in the broadcast. He says "(Hatcher) has to continue to run. He already pulled up a little too early. You have to be at 2nd base or close to it." Looks like Hatcher was roughly half way between 1st and 2nd when the ball gets by the CF. Hatcher is just past 2nd base when the CF picks the ball up off the wall.
Perez points this out in the broadcast. He says "(Hatcher) has to continue to run. He already pulled up a little too early. You have to be at 2nd base or close to it." Looks like Hatcher was roughly half way between 1st and 2nd when the ball gets by the CF. Hatcher is just past 2nd base when the CF picks the ball up off the wall.
Why the 17 are we over analyzing and arguing about this play when we ended up with two baserunners safe and won?
Asking for a friend.
Asking for a friend.
Some Grade A idiots in this thread.
You don't give away outs when you're down 2 runs. Homeboy and 57strat, for the love of God, stop.
You don't give away outs when you're down 2 runs. Homeboy and 57strat, for the love of God, stop.
Latest
-
01
Maroon and White
Mississippi State Keys to Victory against Missouri
-
02
Maroon and White
No. 24 Mississippi State vs. No. 19 Mizzou: How, where and when to watch the Bulldogs
-
03
Maroon and White Football
Mississippi State DL Eddie Kelly Jr. active for the Bulldogs against former team
-
04
Maroon and White Football
Mississippi State vs. Mizzou History
-
05
Maroon and White
Mississippi State Week 4 Preview: Who Carries the Load?