get lost! Have you any idea how good our recruiting has been? Think!And recruiting coordinator.
Someone else's idea, but I liked it so much I thought I'd start a new thread.
get lost! Have you any idea how good our recruiting has been? Think!
Why not get Urban Meyer or Bill Belliceck?Yes, not nearly good as it could be! You clearly have no clue about Ianello's recruiting chops.
Ianello is rated one of the top recruiters in the last 30 years. He has recruited top 5 classes. He brought a bunch of 4 stars to Kansas of all places.
Why not get Urban Meyer or Bill Belliceck?
Look, anyone can toss around names of people at the top but our RC is doin a very good job. In America we say "If its not broke...."
-1 for Ecat
you put too much weight on stars. Besides who the hell would come here over stanford unless they want to play early or live closeby. We have a bootleg football program.Getting an assistant from the University of Buffalo to step up to the B1G isn't quite like trying to get Meyer or Belliceck. -10000 Turk
Also, recruiting is broke according to many who want to retain our coaches on the offensive side of the ball who say we don't have the talent.
Recruiting is broke when you only bring in one 4 star a year. See Tennessee fans thread on this - which is spot on - and the reason we got pummelled.
Another reason Stanford is sitting on a top 5 ranking, won yet another conference champ, and has been to multiple BCS/NY6 bowls while we have not. When you put it in that lens, yes, recruiting is broken.
Who would choose NU over Stanford?
Somebody who wants to actually be certain their offer will be honored and have a good chance to play right away?
We have all pointed to deficiencies in our WR corps. And we have changed recruiting coordinators over the years within the group. Cushing was for a while. Our WR corps need help. What is wrong with looking at a name of someone who has been successful in the position at other schools?get lost! Have you any idea how good our recruiting has been? Think!
In other words, someone who isn't good enough to play for Stanford.....NU as Stanford's safety school.
Stanford is in a talent rich location. Plus they have done well over the last 5-10 years which recruiting has been a beneficiary. They have significantly more talent. How much is it that talent playing up to that level?That's the truth as it stands right now. The truth hurts sometimes. The question is why is that that the truth?
Part of it's the weather, and part of it is that Stanford is just Stanford and that's that. But a large part of it is coaching, decisionmaking, a winning attitude, winning practices and winning ethos. And that means you have to be willing to let folks go that you like for the good of the organization when somebody better is available. It should be fairly easy when those people oversee the single worst offense in Division I and the single worst component of that single worst offense. But for some reason, we struggle with the obvious at Northwestern sometimes for whatever reason. I personally think it's the Little Engine that Could syndrome. Since we were in fact the single worst program in the nation with every single disadvantage going against us, and we did in fact get to the Rose Bowl anyway, folks who were part of that (obviously, including Coach Fitz) don't let little things like not having the best available staff get in their way. Generally, of course, that's a wonderful thing. It's amazing and fantastic and admirable. However, you have to wonder whether there's a downside to having that mindset, the mindset that the ant actually can pick up the rubbertree plant? Maybe folks who think like that sometimes almost prefer that everything be harder than it needs to be because they don't know what the easier way feels like? I don't know. I just know that there's something weird going on when we are constantly feeling like we're about to break through, and we seem to keep suffering from the same self-inflicted issues, with seemingly no desire to actually do what is necessary to get to the point where people start asking "why would anybody go to Stanford for football when they can go to Northwestern?" That's where I'd like to see this program get. But we need to take the steps to get there, not convince ourselves that but for X, Y, Z and 1, 2 and 3, we are right there already. We most decidedly are not.
In other words, someone who isn't good enough to play for Stanford.....NU as Stanford's safety school.
Stanford probably wins more than they lose to us today. That's reflective of where their recruiting is. It has NOT always been that way, nor does it have to be in the future. We have held our own against Stanford, particularly for mid-west based recruits. We have more than a few players on our roster who turned down the Cardinal to be purple. Our goal should be to win more than we lose to them. It is doable.
Forget about football for a moment. If you have a choice as a member of the 2020 graduating class to enroll in either Stanford or NU, which do you choose? My hunch is a majority of students would choose Stanford. They are smack in the middle of once in a 100-years hub of innovation and business opportunities. The school is awash in money and the connections a student can make there are unreal. Now if you happen to also be a football player and can play for a staff that puts their best players into the NFL, why would you think twice and go anywhere else? Seems to me like a complete no-brainer.
How the hell did we lose that kid to UCONN? Or Larkin to Cincy (at least for a moment)? Or William and Mary (on the hoops side)?
Better lookin' babes.
I think we were in Salem Virginia
From 2002-2006, the Teevens-Harris era, Stanford went 16-40 (10-31). In the first two years of the Harbaugh era, Stanford went 9-15. That's 25-55 for a seven year stretch. During that time, NU went 41-45, despite RW's death and the installation of PF as inexperienced head man.Stanford probably wins more than they lose to us today. That's reflective of where their recruiting is. It has NOT always been that way, nor does it have to be in the future. We have held our own against Stanford, particularly for mid-west based recruits. We have more than a few players on our roster who turned down the Cardinal to be purple. Our goal should be to win more than we lose to them. It is doable.
They were definitely in a down period. But they did get (on paper) more talent. But when Harbaugh got there, they started winning pretty regularly. And with his recruiting tactics, the talent level increased even more.From 2002-2006, the Teevens-Harris era, Stanford went 16-40 (10-31). In the first two years of the Harbaugh era, Stanford went 9-15. That's 25-55 for a seven year stretch. During that time, NU went 41-45, despite RW's death and the installation of PF as inexperienced head man.
NU was significantly better than Stanford for seven years, and it's like it's ancient history.
They were definitely in a down period. But they did get (on paper) more talent. But when Harbaugh got there, they started winning pretty regularly. And with his recruiting tactics, the talent level increased even more.
At the end of the day, that's exactly what it is. Win, and we will see our recruiting get better and better (and those facilities should help). During the Teevins, Harris, and even Willingham era, you are flat out wrong - during that period we crushed Stanford recruiting, even when we were relatively mediocre. Barnett's post Rose Bowl classes were stocked with kids, including a bunch of California kids who rejected Stanford for NU (Bentley, Albrecht, Silva to name a few). Their recruiting got better because a) they brought in a coach who was great at it (which is why I think we can use Rob Ianello) and b) because they started winning. They didn't land tons of 4/5 stars until Harbaugh started turning things around. Just like Barnett.
If we can win another 10 games next year and the year after that, we will start seeing the same recruiting upswing that Barnett and Harbaugh enjoyed.
What are the chances that we would hire Ianello, though? He doesn't have any connections to Fitzgerald, does he? Also, we don't know for sure, but our assistant salaries are probably terrible by Big Ten standards.
What are the chances that we would hire Ianello, though? He doesn't have any connections to Fitzgerald, does he? Also, we don't know for sure, but our assistant salaries are probably terrible by Big Ten standards.
At the end of the day, that's exactly what it is. Win, and we will see our recruiting get better and better (and those facilities should help). During the Teevins, Harris, and even Willingham era, you are flat out wrong - during that period we crushed Stanford recruiting, even when we were relatively mediocre. Barnett's post Rose Bowl classes were stocked with kids, including a bunch of California kids who rejected Stanford for NU (Bentley, Albrecht, Silva to name a few). Their recruiting got better because a) they brought in a coach who was great at it (which is why I think we can use Rob Ianello) and b) because they started winning. They didn't land tons of 4/5 stars until Harbaugh started turning things around. Just like Barnett.
There was no time in the last 14 years that we ever "crushed Stanford recruiting" The best we ever did was about equal. For a period we were more successful in what we did with that talent. That ended during the Harbaugh tenure and has continued under Shaw. But we never "crushed them" in recruiting.At the end of the day, that's exactly what it is. Win, and we will see our recruiting get better and better (and those facilities should help). During the Teevins, Harris, and even Willingham era, you are flat out wrong - during that period we crushed Stanford recruiting, even when we were relatively mediocre. Barnett's post Rose Bowl classes were stocked with kids, including a bunch of California kids who rejected Stanford for NU (Bentley, Albrecht, Silva to name a few). Their recruiting got better because a) they brought in a coach who was great at it (which is why I think we can use Rob Ianello) and b) because they started winning. They didn't land tons of 4/5 stars until Harbaugh started turning things around. Just like Barnett.
If we can win another 10 games next year and the year after that, we will start seeing the same recruiting upswing that Barnett and Harbaugh enjoyed.
That said, those were rating service ratings and as we also know, during that period, we were able to find a few of those 2 star diamonds. We definitely did more with the players we had during those periods.This from the King of "Flat out Wrong"!
Your statement is 100% wrong for the Teevens and Harris era (no Rivals info for the Willingham era). From 2002 to 2006 during the Teevens and Harris era, Stanford beat NU in recruiting in terms of Rivals star ratings every single year. Stanford has topped NU in recruiting according to Rivals average star ratings every year for the past 14 years except in Harbaugh's first year (2007).
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2002-2009: Stanford 27, NU 2
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2002-2004 (Teevens): Stanford 12, NU 1
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2005-2006 (Harris): Stanford 5, NU 0
Average star ratings for Stanford and NU from 2002 to 2009 (Stanford first, NU second):
2002: 3.06, 2.32
2003: 2.77, 2.36
2004: 2.58, 2.13
2005: 2.88, 2.50
2006: 2.56, 2.24
2007: 2.63, 2.74 . . . Harbaugh's first year
2008: 2.71, 2.30
2009: 3.27, 2.67
Stanford has kicked our butt in recruiting from 2010 to 2015 and is poised to kick our butt again this year
Can anybody be more "flat out wrong" than ECat here? hdhntr1 deserves an apology.
There was no time in the last 14 years that we ever "crushed Stanford recruiting" The best we ever did was about equal. For a period we were more successful in what we did with that talent. That ended during the Harbaugh tenure and has continued under Shaw. But we never "crushed them" in recruiting.
Oh no! Here it comes. Wait till Glades sees this post using average star ratings to judge the quality of recruiting.........Wait. You are Glades. Are you OK, Buddy?This from the King of "Flat out Wrong"!
Your statement is 100% wrong for the Teevens and Harris era (no Rivals info for the Willingham era). From 2002 to 2006 during the Teevens and Harris era, Stanford beat NU in recruiting in terms of Rivals star ratings every single year. Stanford has topped NU in recruiting according to Rivals average star ratings every year for the past 14 years except in Harbaugh's first year (2007).
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2002-2009: Stanford 27, NU 2
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2002-2004 (Teevens): Stanford 12, NU 1
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2005-2006 (Harris): Stanford 5, NU 0
Average star ratings for Stanford and NU from 2002 to 2009 (Stanford first, NU second):
2002: 3.06, 2.32
2003: 2.77, 2.36
2004: 2.58, 2.13
2005: 2.88, 2.50
2006: 2.56, 2.24
2007: 2.63, 2.74 . . . Harbaugh's first year
2008: 2.71, 2.30
2009: 3.27, 2.67
Stanford has kicked our butt in recruiting from 2010 to 2015 and is poised to kick our butt again this year
Can anybody be more "flat out wrong" than ECat here? hdhntr1 deserves an apology.
This from the King of "Flat out Wrong"!
Your statement is 100% wrong for the Teevens and Harris era (no Rivals info for the Willingham era). From 2002 to 2006 during the Teevens and Harris era, Stanford beat NU in recruiting in terms of Rivals star ratings every single year. Stanford has topped NU in recruiting according to Rivals average star ratings every year for the past 14 years except in Harbaugh's first year (2007).
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2002-2009: Stanford 27, NU 2
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2002-2004 (Teevens): Stanford 12, NU 1
Numbers of 4-star players recruited from 2005-2006 (Harris): Stanford 5, NU 0
Average star ratings for Stanford and NU from 2002 to 2009 (Stanford first, NU second):
2002: 3.06, 2.32
2003: 2.77, 2.36
2004: 2.58, 2.13
2005: 2.88, 2.50
2006: 2.56, 2.24
2007: 2.63, 2.74 . . . Harbaugh's first year
2008: 2.71, 2.30
2009: 3.27, 2.67
Stanford has kicked our butt in recruiting from 2010 to 2015 and is poised to kick our butt again this year
Can anybody be more "flat out wrong" than ECat here? hdhntr1 deserves an apology.
I stand corrected. I should have known better. This was the Walker era we're talking about. I stand by my statement on the Willingham and Barnett tenure.
Although Rivals, Scout and 24-7 ratings are subjective, we have a record of them. Where is your source for this "statement." It may be true, but where's the evidence?
Back to the subjectivity, since we know the ratings are flawed, what good does it do to argue NU or Stanford recruited better in a span of years using said ratings?
Before Rivals, etc.. there was Athlon and BCI, etc... Barnet's classes were very well rated post Rose Bowl, and Stanford's were not (they were going through their version of the Dark Ages). We had multiple kids from Cali with Stanford offers turn them down (that doesn't really happen anymore).
The point I'm making is to refute the idea that Stanford is destined to recruit better than we do because of natural advantages, and that their success is not attainable or a reasonable goal. There is a little bit of chicken and egg at play, but if we can win (and the facilities go on-line), there is no reason in my mind why we cannot recruit at their level or reach their level of success on the playing field (in terms of championships and rankings, not just one game where we did absolutely dominate them already).
No, we CRUSHED them during Barnett's post-Rosebowl years. Multiple California and Western US recruits with Stanford offers ended up at NU (Craig Albrecht, Billy Silva, Kevin Bentley, Rasheedi Wheeler, Mike Souza, just to name a few).
Wildcat Report
The 3-2-1 after Northwestern's loss to Ohio State
Wildcat Report
Three Wildcat commits crack new Rivals300
Wildcat Report
Recruit Roundup: WR Moseley scores three TDs, QB Phifer accounts for four
On3 Football
College Football Bowl Projections Week 12: Full list of matchups, playoff predictions
Wildcat Report
Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Snaps Analysis