Revisiting the 1998-99 season

RutgersNYCB1G

Freshman
Jan 8, 2020
122
86
0
Rutgers was in the driver's seat for an NCAA bid in 1998-99. This was the best Kevin Bannon team with a loaded roster that included seniors Geoff Billett and Rob Hodgson to go along with young stars like Dahntay Jones, Jeff Greer and Rashod Kent. I'm sure many also remember Joel Salvi, who was one of the country's best sixth men.

The 1998-99 team started 9-2 before two excruciatingly close losses to WVU and St. John's. They held their own in the Big East, however, and were 17-7 on Feb. 13, 1999, with 4 regular season games left. The tournament seemed like a lock.

Rutgers lost all 4 games to close the season, including a brutal loss to Seton Hall at the Meadowlands that ended when Hodgson dribbled the ball off his foot (I was there). We beat Pitt in the first round of the Big East tournament before losing to St. John's. Rutgers was shown on Selection Sunday waiting for a bid that never came and wound up in the NIT.

The point of this thread is not to say the current team is going to fold and/or get terrible breaks down the stretch like 1998-99. It's to say that nothing is a sure thing and to remind folks (especially those saying that 19 or even 20 wins get us in) that when you leave things to chance like the 1998-99 team did, the committee might not extend an invitation.

Hopefully this thread is mostly moot later tonight after a win at Maryland. Go RU.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,116
113
well this is a better team right off the bat with better wins and the Big 10 is better than the Big East was that year. I remember the SJU game and they were the 2? or was it 3 seed and RU was the 7 and yet there was very little confidence that RU could win that game.

I just think our resume is much stronger than the wins we had that year and also remember we have 68 schools not 64 making the field now.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,116
113
I still want to see more games. It may come down to Ron and Geo. We have more of a sample size with Geo. Is Ron Harper Jr. the player most thought he was? I am not sure myself.


its a better team....remember that team got shredded by an average Clemson team in the NIT quarters.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,462
61,723
113
I still want to see more games. It may come down to Ron and Geo. We have more of a sample size with Geo. Is Ron Harper Jr. the player most thought he was? I am not sure myself.

He’s a sophomore, he’s in a slump, just like Geo had last year and his frosh year. Just like most non-superstars have.. You’ll be fine.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
its a better team....remember that team got shredded by an average Clemson team in the NIT quarters.

who wouldn't be shredded in the NIT after collapsing down the stretch.

If we end up in the NIT I wouldn't expect us to be up for any games.
 

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
HAHAHA that can never happen again... I mean... what are the odds...

hehehehe

 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,116
113
who wouldn't be shredded in the NIT after collapsing down the stretch.

If we end up in the NIT I wouldn't expect us to be up for any games.


they beat like 2 NCAA teams...Syracuse and mediocre Nova....it wasnt a good year in the BE. They lost to two bad teams at the end of the year. They didnt deserve to get in. I see very little comparison with the metrics and resume and makeup to that team. That team literally screamed NIT...and they played hard that Clemson game, its that they were overmatched to a NIT team, RU has already shown they can beat possible sweet 16 teams
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,116
113
they have a better resume than RU...I would put it at 70/30 but I would put RU at 80/20 if it makes sense
 

PiscatawayMike

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
17,571
15,730
113
Postponed a work trip by a day to be at that game on Senior Night. Not a good move.
It was absolutely brutal. We win that game and we would have gone dancing. The saddest part is that Georgetown was very mediocre that season.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
Let me back track the SFA prediction......

13 teams and only 8 make the conference tournament
Round 1
5-8
6-7

Round 2
4 vs 5-8
3 vs 6-7

Semis
1 vs 4,5 or 8
2 vs 3,6 or 7

FInals


Tournament held in Katy, TX (3 hour drive from SFA)

75% chance of winning semi
64% chance of winning final

SFA 48% chance of winning Southland conference tournament
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
they have a better resume than RU...I would put it at 70/30 but I would put RU at 80/20 if it makes sense
Wed 2-05 A 37 (I) Minnesota +2.2, 62-60 40%
Sun 2-09 H 12 (I) Ohio St. -1.1, 62-60 55%
Sat 2-15 A 128 (III) Nebraska -5.3, 69-64 71%
Tue 2-18 H 21 (II) Purdue -2.5, 57-55 63%
Sun 2-23 H 13 (I) Rutgers -1.6, 60-59 58%
Thu 2-27 A 24 (I-A) Michigan +3.5, 65-61 35%
Sun 3-01 H 37 (II) Minnesota -4.2, 63-59 69%
Wed 3-04 H 96 (III) Northwestern -9.3, 66-57 85%
Sat 3-07 A 47 (I) Indiana +1.3, 62-61 44%

They are 13-9 6-5.

4-5 the rest of the way they are 17-14 and are 10-10 in conference. B1Gt game would be very interesting.

I said before we played them that how Wisconsin does against RU may determine if they dance.

For a B1G schedule it looks sort of tame with 2 Nebbiewestern games....don't think they are immune to losing 1 of those.
 

FrankZ_RU93

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
25,570
11,240
113
It was absolutely brutal. We win that game and we would have gone dancing. The saddest part is that Georgetown was very mediocre that season.

Really had little doubt in my mind we would win that game on Senior Night. Still a bit stunned now that this torture was resurrected. :cry:
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,116
113
Wed 2-05 A 37 (I) Minnesota +2.2, 62-60 40%
Sun 2-09 H 12 (I) Ohio St. -1.1, 62-60 55%
Sat 2-15 A 128 (III) Nebraska -5.3, 69-64 71%
Tue 2-18 H 21 (II) Purdue -2.5, 57-55 63%
Sun 2-23 H 13 (I) Rutgers -1.6, 60-59 58%
Thu 2-27 A 24 (I-A) Michigan +3.5, 65-61 35%
Sun 3-01 H 37 (II) Minnesota -4.2, 63-59 69%
Wed 3-04 H 96 (III) Northwestern -9.3, 66-57 85%
Sat 3-07 A 47 (I) Indiana +1.3, 62-61 44%

They are 13-9 6-5.

4-5 the rest of the way they are 17-14 and are 10-10 in conference. B1Gt game would be very interesting.

I said before we played them that how Wisconsin does against RU may determine if they dance.

For a B1G schedule it looks sort of tame with 2 Nebbiewestern games....don't think they are immune to losing 1 of those.


sos of 3 and 5-7 in Q1 games

wins over Maryland, Michigan State,at Penn State, at Ohio State, Marquette this is an awesome resume complete with 2 quality road wins, one bad loss to New Mexico

at worst I see them 18-13...thats good enough to dance, even at 17-14 they will get in...thats where sos and road wins matter...so Wisky at 17-15 might have an advantage over 19-13 Rutgers
 

JavaDunk18

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2011
1,102
1,014
0
I do remember reading the USA today when Rutgers was at 17-7. The article said “Rutgers is a lock for the tournament, barring collapse”..well, they lost the last 4. That was then, this is now. There are lots of occasions Rutgers could have already collapsed. They will make it this year...
 
Last edited:

scarletrat

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2003
10,990
1,048
0
ahh yes, that year. I was a season-ticket holder as it was my last year of pharmacy school and wow, that was painful--the GTown loss was the worst I've experienced as a fan. That team just ran out of gas at the end, didn't have any depth (was 7 deep at best with Salvi). That was a down year in the BE, but yes, when we were 17-7 and 9-5 in BE, 4th place, we were projected by ESPN as I recall as a 6 seed. I think our rating was 42, the highest team not to get in as an at-large, but I doubt many felt we would get in.

What's potentially eery is if we split the next 2, we will be 17-7 and 8-5 in B10.

This team has more impressive wins, is deeper, and plays in a much better and deeper Big 10. And we are young--we just learning how win, hence why road games are close but can't pull them out...98-99 was an experienced team other than Jones, Greer, and Kent.

it's not just NCAAs:
--to finish above .500 in league--last time I think was all the way in A-10. We finished .500 a few times in BE, one under Bannon and one under Waters.
--to get to 20 wins--last time was 2004 and was due to winning 4 games in NIT
--win at least 1 game in B10...last year was disappointing finish
 

DirtyRU

All-American
Nov 16, 2002
6,528
6,125
113
I don't remember the G'Town game that much that year (although I do remember Earl's dunk) but what I DO remember is RU pulling a large screen out and having a watch party at the RAC for our end of season game @Nova. The Nova game was the crucial game I thought? Win it and we likely dance, lose it and we're prob. out. But we struggled to contain their SF Ricky Wright (I think it was him) and ended up losing. That's what I remember, but without referencing the 98-99 schedule, I could be wrong.

I also remember how much of a pain in the *** Miami was back then with Johnny Helmsley, Tim James and the big (but undersized) center who matched up well with Rashod... I forget his name.

Edit: Mario Bland was his name I think.
 
Last edited:

rucoe89

All-American
Jul 31, 2001
13,465
7,584
113
Rutgers was in the driver's seat for an NCAA bid in 1998-99. This was the best Kevin Bannon team with a loaded roster that included seniors Geoff Billett and Rob Hodgson to go along with young stars like Dahntay Jones, Jeff Greer and Rashod Kent. I'm sure many also remember Joel Salvi, who was one of the country's best sixth men.

The 1998-99 team started 9-2 before two excruciatingly close losses to WVU and St. John's. They held their own in the Big East, however, and were 17-7 on Feb. 13, 1999, with 4 regular season games left. The tournament seemed like a lock.

Rutgers lost all 4 games to close the season, including a brutal loss to Seton Hall at the Meadowlands that ended when Hodgson dribbled the ball off his foot (I was there). We beat Pitt in the first round of the Big East tournament before losing to St. John's. Rutgers was shown on Selection Sunday waiting for a bid that never came and wound up in the NIT.

The point of this thread is not to say the current team is going to fold and/or get terrible breaks down the stretch like 1998-99. It's to say that nothing is a sure thing and to remind folks (especially those saying that 19 or even 20 wins get us in) that when you leave things to chance like the 1998-99 team did, the committee might not extend an invitation.

Hopefully this thread is mostly moot later tonight after a win at Maryland. Go RU.
From here on out this team better understand it needs to play with urgency as the next loss drops them further and further back. They don't get the benefit of being a blueblood. I hope they don't learn that lesson the hard way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutgersNYCB1G

Scarlet Shack

Heisman
Feb 3, 2004
26,407
16,328
73
To be fair ...couple of things happened to that team that lead to the 17-7 build up

1) three of the last four on the road and two were top 15 Miami and number 1 UConn

2.) the hall and gtown were decent teams

3.) Kent got hurt ...and Dabney was out for most of the year already ...so we were short a big man at the end. Salvi and Rob played the 4 and 5 with tenys giving them a rest

4.) even with that ...we led St. John’s (who got a ncaa 3 seed) in the garden in the second half before tired legs got us ...

For what I was told, we were the last team out ....
 

scarletrat

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2003
10,990
1,048
0
the best half of basketball I have ever seen RU play was that season, at home vs a very good Johnnies team, I think RU was up 47-40 at half. Lost game.
 

BigEastPhil

Heisman
Nov 25, 2007
19,393
13,694
66
Yep. If URI's Lamar Odom didn't knock in that buzzer-beater to upset Temple in the A-10 title game, RU would have been in and URI would have been out.
Gosh I remember watching that game on tv at msg prior to the BE finals that night. Ugh
 

RutgersNYCB1G

Freshman
Jan 8, 2020
122
86
0
well this is a better team right off the bat
I completely disagree. Better coached, yes. Better defense, yes. But that 1998-99 team had a far superior offense run by two senior leaders, Billet and Hodgson, along with a major young star in Dahntay Jones and an electric sixth man in Salvi. Greer was also a better shooter than anyone on this year's team. If they played 10 head-to-head games, I'd say the 1998-99 team wins 7 or 8 times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers56_rivals

RutgersNYCB1G

Freshman
Jan 8, 2020
122
86
0
This season is starting to look more like 1998-99 by the day, although I still think that team was better than this one. Hodgson and Billett were polished veteran scorers, Jones was a freshman phenom, Greer was a reliable sharpshooter, Kent was an excellent rebounder and Salvi was one of the best sixth men in the country. Pikiell is a better coach than Bannon ever was, but that's about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers56_rivals

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,100
182,116
113
this years team has way better wins

and that team was overmatched at home in the NIT by Clemson
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Men's Soccer earns NCAA Tournament berth for first time since 2022
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football versus Michigan State Game Time Announced
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball Rutgers vs. Albany: How to Watch, Starting Lineups, Rankings & More
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Wrestling Takes Down No. 13 Lehigh - Breaking Down Huge Ranked Win - TKR Pod
  5. 05 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026