Question about the overturned blocking foul?

SophiesDad

Heisman
Mar 23, 2018
6,384
20,886
0
Everybody knows you can’t draw a charge if inside the restricted area. You also can’t review a judgment call according to the rulebook. But if the call on the floor was a block why in the hell were they reviewing to see if he was in the restricted area or not anyways?
 

SophiesDad

Heisman
Mar 23, 2018
6,384
20,886
0
I think it can be reviewed in last two minutes tho not 100% sure.

But it was clearly a charge so they got it right in the end.
You can’t review a judgement call so how’d they get it right? They called a block initially so seeing if the Utah player was in the restricted area or not would be irrelevant
 
  • Like
Reactions: AGEE11

cat_in_the_hat

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2004
5,909
4,457
0
You can’t review a judgement call so how’d they get it right? They called a block initially so seeing if the Utah player was in the restricted area or not would be irrelevant
According to the announcers it was called a block because they thought he was in the restricted area. They can review if he was or wasn't in the restricted area. Since he wasn't in the restricted area, the call was reversed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ala_kat2

Blue till I die

All-Conference
Dec 20, 2004
1,647
3,378
113
I have never seen it done that way. I have seen a charge called, then when reviewed, the defender was in the circle and the call was changed to a block.

What they did last night was not right, changing a judgement call upon review. That is not how basketball is officiated.
 

Brettv13

Redshirt
May 26, 2008
76
48
0
It was a player control foul. If the player driving is out of control he can’t just run over defenders, set or not. He was clearly out of control.
out of control? didnt drive his shoulder into him, and if anything the defender was more out of control than him..he even tried to go around to the left... I'm not even saying its a blocking foul.. if anything there should of been no call
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
Everybody knows you can’t draw a charge if inside the restricted area. You also can’t review a judgment call according to the rulebook. But if the call on the floor was a block why in the hell were they reviewing to see if he was in the restricted area or not anyways?

Because the issue was whether or not the defender was inside the arc. Under the rules, that is reviewable because it's a black and white call more than a judgment call.

The official who blew the whistle mistakenly thought he was inside the restricted area at first. As the replay shows, he was obviously wrong.
 

Ben101er

Heisman
Apr 21, 2004
25,982
61,135
103
Everybody knows you can’t draw a charge if inside the restricted area. You also can’t review a judgment call according to the rulebook. But if the call on the floor was a block why in the hell were they reviewing to see if he was in the restricted area or not anyways?


Because that was the only excuse they could use to reverse the call.
 

Brettv13

Redshirt
May 26, 2008
76
48
0
out of control? didnt drive his shoulder into him, and if anything the defender was more out of control than him..he even tried to go around to the left... I'm not even saying its a blocking foul.. if anything there should of been no call
and don't get me wrong i'm not in anyway saying this cost us the game the first 35 minutes did..
 
  • Like
Reactions: westerncat

SophiesDad

Heisman
Mar 23, 2018
6,384
20,886
0
Because the issue was whether or not the defender was inside the arc. Under the rules, that is reviewable because it's a black and white call more than a judgment call.

The official who blew the whistle mistakenly thought he was inside the restricted area at first. As the replay shows, he was obviously wrong.
Go back and watch where the foul was drawn. If that official honestly thought that the Utah player was in the restricted area initially then he doesn’t need to be officiating at this level. It wasn’t even close
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
Go back and watch where the foul was drawn. If that official honestly thought that the Utah player was in the restricted area initially then he doesn’t need to be officiating at this level. It wasn’t even close

I agree. It wasn't even close. But apparently that is what he thought, because that is what the review was about.

It was an offensive foul. But it was still a terrible job of officiating. No review should've ever been needed to make that call.
 

westerncat

Heisman
Feb 19, 2012
15,923
20,891
0
I thought it was bad officiating all through the game. As other pointed out that one call did not cost us the game. There was some questionable calls on both teams on blocking and charging. We just did not play a good game and Cal IMO just got out coached.
 

AGEE11

All-American
Jan 10, 2014
3,222
6,651
0
Thing is, the signal for a ref about the circle is to make the block.charge call and point.

The baseline official NEVER did that. That is his call and he has the best view and he called the block. The other officials came over, said who knows what and they reviewed it. Think they got in to the upset is happening mentality.

And as that player is moving and impeded the freedom of movement of the offensive player, that is by rule a block
 

sluggercatfan

Heisman
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,631
0
Everybody knows you can’t draw a charge if inside the restricted area. You also can’t review a judgment call according to the rulebook. But if the call on the floor was a block why in the hell were they reviewing to see if he was in the restricted area or not anyways?
Mike Pratt said something about a new rule this year. Never seen that before. Wonder if Cal well ever admit that this is on his shoulders. His focus on the program needs to change.
 

Comebakatz3

Heisman
Aug 8, 2008
44,377
34,268
113
The ref blew the call, realized it too late, and used the review of the restricted area as a cop out. The kid was 4 feet from the restricted area.

This is what happened, and it ended up being an abuse of the replay.

There needs to be an indication that there was a restricted area violation that led to the call being a block before they go to the monitor. That way you at least know that they are not looking at the play and are only looking at whether he was in or out of the restricted area. Without there being an indication, they can always change a judgement call.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RipThru

Comebakatz3

Heisman
Aug 8, 2008
44,377
34,268
113
Thing is, the signal for a ref about the circle is to make the block.charge call and point.

The baseline official NEVER did that. That is his call and he has the best view and he called the block. The other officials came over, said who knows what and they reviewed it. Think they got in to the upset is happening mentality.

And as that player is moving and impeded the freedom of movement of the offensive player, that is by rule a block

Exactly. If they do not have to make the indication at the time of the call that the reason for the call was the restricted area, then it gives them relatively free reign to go back and change their judgment, which they cannot (to my knowledge) do with review.


Also... why the hell was Maxey attacking with 22 seconds left to begin with?! Why is he not holding for the last shot and driving with about 8-10 seconds left!?
 
  • Like
Reactions: AGEE11

ukwildcat2004

Heisman
Jan 12, 2003
5,223
12,540
113
Go back and watch where the foul was drawn. If that official honestly thought that the Utah player was in the restricted area initially then he doesn’t need to be officiating at this level. It wasn’t even close

This 100%. If your depth perception is that bad you miss it by 4 or 5 feet then there is no way you should be an official. Tony Greene is average but the other two were absolutely garbage and need to find the unemployment line quickly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bluemoonofky
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Halftime: Red Zone Nightmares for Kentucky
  2. 02 KSR Football Kenny Darby makes Kentucky history with two freshman receiving records
  3. 03 KSR Football LIVE BLOG: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri
  4. 04 KSR Football Listen to KSR's Pregame Show before Kentucky vs. Mizzou
  5. 05 KSR A Brief History of Weird Football Between Kentucky and Missouri