PSU has 11 2018 commits. We have zero.

Status
Not open for further replies.

scarletbergen

Senior
Aug 17, 2006
2,319
773
66
On and on....from a Creep State group...
https://scontent.fewr1-1.fna.fbcdn....=9d4538466a0c1a696bf3c59929f93d4f&oe=5936BDA6

And nobody helped
 
Last edited:

snowboarder

All-Conference
Aug 3, 2004
1,001
1,094
113
While it is early, there is no need to attach the OP. The information shared is certainly relevant to RU. It's not so much the total number of recruits but the quality that is scary. PSU is recruiting on a Michigan/OSU level right now. Add Maryland as a top 20 type recruiting program and MSU and who do we have a chance at beating in our division?
What did we see last year that would lead us to believe that Ash can overcome the talent gap with coaching?
I am hopeful that Ash can get it done here but not optimistic
 

Panthergrowl13

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2002
13,332
1,718
0
Too early to be concerned with recruiting.

Pitt also has zero recruits so far and we like many other programs are just lining up guys for campus visits.

Trust in your coaching staff.

HAIL TO PITT!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickyNewark51

Burton12

Junior
Oct 3, 2012
1,048
378
83
I have to say, I also think it's misguided to think it's "too early to worry about recruiting." The process is beginning earlier and earlier for a lot of kids. It's important to start building those relationships ASAP.
 

Panthergrowl13

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2002
13,332
1,718
0
The time to conclude how well your school did recruiting in 2017 is in February 2018.

Most schools are actively building up relationships with recruits very early.

Hey Pitt is talking to QB Grant Gunnell (not saying we get him) class of 2019.

Recruiting is not an exact science, trust in your coaches.

HAIL TO PITT!!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: shields

BlockR

Heisman
Dec 28, 2015
23,167
22,167
113
While it is early, there is no need to attach the OP. The information shared is certainly relevant to RU. It's not so much the total number of recruits but the quality that is scary. PSU is recruiting on a Michigan/OSU level right now. Add Maryland as a top 20 type recruiting program and MSU and who do we have a chance at beating in our division?
What did we see last year that would lead us to believe that Ash can overcome the talent gap with coaching?
I am hopeful that Ash can get it done here but not optimistic
“Chris has laid a good foundation,” Kill said. “He’s done everything he needs to do. Now we have to go out and get some players, because you don’t win because of coaches. You win because of players. …
 

Burton12

Junior
Oct 3, 2012
1,048
378
83
“Chris has laid a good foundation,” Kill said. “He’s done everything he needs to do. Now we have to go out and get some players, because you don’t win because of coaches. You win because of players. …

Jimmies and Joes > X's and O's.

Obviously, when you have both, that's when great things happen. But if forced to choose between A talent and C coaching, and C talent and A coaching, give me the players.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,593
61,926
113
While it is early, there is no need to attach the OP. The information shared is certainly relevant to RU. It's not so much the total number of recruits but the quality that is scary. PSU is recruiting on a Michigan/OSU level right now. Add Maryland as a top 20 type recruiting program

Stop. Let Maryland recruit 3-4 consecutive "Top 20" classes before starting this nonsense. Thanks. Also, if you ever read the OP's posts about athletics - any of them - you'll understand why so many have jumped all over him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yesrutgers01

zwicker

Sophomore
Aug 15, 2016
211
125
0
Do you remember who it was? Doesn't ring a bell.


Dante Raymond He ended up at Delaware. He then went to Lackawanna and I think he has moved on from LCCC. PSU was his only P5 offer. Franklin was honest with him from the start and that was the end of the story. Ash did the EXACT thing when he took over. Kiffen and Edsall on the other hand told kids they would honor the scholarships from the previous staff and lead players along. Then at the end they pulled the offer.

Holier than thou.
 
Last edited:

KJB32812

Heisman
Dec 25, 2008
41,593
85,949
113
Dante Raymond He ended up at Delaware. He then went to Lackawanna and I think he has moved on from LCCC. PSU was his only P5 offer. Franklin was honest with him from the start and that was the end of the story. Ash did the EXACT thing when he took over. Kiffen and Edsall on the other hand told kids they would honor the scholarships from the previous staff and lead players along. Then at the end they pulled the offer.

Holier than thou.

Never even heard of the kid. THX
 

RUchip

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2010
27,603
1,505
0
Silver lining: The sooner they fill up, the less we have to worry about competing with them for recruits. (Also, if we won the B1G championship and went to the Rose Bowl, we'd have quite a few recruits by now I'm sure.)
That's a loser mentality to have. Just proves we can not recruit at their level for players we want.
 

RUchip

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2010
27,603
1,505
0
I LOL ....

February 2018 commitments in February 2017 are otherwise known as two things:

1) Future de-commitments

2) Future offer pulls....


Most 16 yo kids don't know what they want to do 6 hours from now...... but, you're worried about what they will do 365 days in the future.......
And you have proof they are future decommitt? Anthony Cioffi committed during his Junior year. I can name about a dozen or so others who committed Jr year as well
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
That's a loser mentality to have. Just proves we can not recruit at their level for players we want.
Win and they will come.
Right now no one should expect RU to recruit like the schools everyone looks on as a top program. Once RU starts proving it can win, is competitive in its games against the best of the B1G, top HS talent will be easier to convince to be part of a program on the way to the top and better able to keep the commits once it is recognized as a winning program.

But not being one of the best now doesn't mean RU fans shouldn't expect Ash to pull in a gem or two on the way to RU becoming a constant winner and considered a contender for major bowl games every year ( maybe even the NC)
 

wcicci

Sophomore
Jan 25, 2012
384
149
0
Win and they will come.
Right now no one should expect RU to recruit like the schools everyone looks on as a top program. Once RU starts proving it can win, is competitive in its games against the best of the B1G, top HS talent will be easier to convince to be part of a program on the way to the top and better able to keep the commits once it is recognized as a winning program.

But not being one of the best now doesn't mean RU fans shouldn't expect Ash to pull in a gem or two on the way to RU becoming a constant winner and considered a contender for major bowl games every year ( maybe even the NC)
Expect a constant winner, major bowl games and maybe even NC? That's a big jump. Realistically, Rutgers should expect to battle for 5/6 in BIG East w/IU and set its sights on catching up with Maryland and possibly MSU, if this season was an aberration.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
Expect a constant winner, major bowl games and maybe even NC? That's a big jump. Realistically, Rutgers should expect to battle for 5/6 in BIG East w/IU and set its sights on catching up with Maryland and possibly MSU, if this season was an aberration.
Didn't say right away, but if everything falls in place like boosters starting to donate generously because RU is playing well. The administration starts caring more. Some big wins get more and more NYC Metro Area college football fans ( that don't feel loyalty to other FCS FB programs) jumping on the bandwagon and past RU supporters jump back on.

Won't say any or all of those things will happen, but can dream it will and maybe, just maybe, RU FB might turn into one of the schools that are thought of as NC material in pre season polls.
I'll only accept 2nd tier status, like many feel RU FB will always be, if I think that status is just a stepping stone to being considered one of the best.
My expectations have gone from hoping RU can beat Colgate 27 out of 42 games) , to hoping RU can have a winning season, to hoping RU can be in bowl games on a regular bases , then hoping for the BE Title and the BCS bid that goes with it.
Each of those hopes became bigger and only the Major bowl has failed to be realized. Unless a co: championship doesn't count.
So I'll just keep on dreaming while others tell me it's an impossible dream.
Won't say Rutgers will be in the NC game or playoffs in my lifetime, but I'll let myself dream they will and feel, if the stars align just right, dreams can come true
 

GSGS

Heisman
Aug 2, 2001
29,450
23,891
113
So not only are you one of, if not the, worst poster on here but you also disobey the rules by posting political garbage.

Guess if you're going to be really bad at something you might as well go all the way.

Speaking about really bad at something, how about a Pedd State fan who:
1) Says he hates flips but Gerald F*cking Hodges is his favorite player,
2) Tells RU fans how they should feel in a thread he starts, where he reveals he is the only Pedd State fan in the world who doesn't care that they lost the Rose Bowl;
3) Spends most of Pedd State's first Rose Bowl in years not only NOT at the game, but posting about 50 times to a RU fan board as he watches on TV.

kjb - scarletbergen is awesome compared to you.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,170
8,516
113
Expect a constant winner, major bowl games and maybe even NC? That's a big jump. Realistically, Rutgers should expect to battle for 5/6 in BIG East w/IU and set its sights on catching up with Maryland and possibly MSU, if this season was an aberration.
It's a tough division for sure. Doesn't mean we can't be a good team. It may take a few years but we don't need a team of 4 stars. Michigan State went to the playoffs with mostly 3 star guys and a select few blue chip guys. Granted they got blown out.

Rutgers goal honestly should be to be ranked in the top 25 in the next 3-5 years. It's a start and I think as the Big Ten money rolls on in and we get our facilities up to date we can hover around that 25 mark. We have the recruiting base. It certainly can be done.
 

KJB32812

Heisman
Dec 25, 2008
41,593
85,949
113
Speaking about really bad at something, how about a Pedd State fan who:
1) Says he hates flips but Gerald F*cking Hodges is his favorite player,
2) Tells RU fans how they should feel in a thread he starts, where he reveals he is the only Pedd State fan in the world who doesn't care that they lost the Rose Bowl;
3) Spends most of Pedd State's first Rose Bowl in years not only NOT at the game, but posting about 50 times to a RU fan board as he watches on TV.

kjb - scarletbergen is awesome compared to you.

I see you didn't care to respond to my post that called you out for being completely clueless. Then again, what's new?

BTW, Hodges wasn't even close to my favorite player on the team. I love the picture because of the jersey he's wearing and the game he was wearing it in.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,477
13,091
113
Stop. Let Maryland recruit 3-4 consecutive "Top 20" classes before starting this nonsense. Thanks. Also, if you ever read the OP's posts about athletics - any of them - you'll understand why so many have jumped all over him.

Your missing the point. Over the last 15 years Maryland had only been getting at most One or two Top 10 Maryland players each recruiting class. This trend even occurred during the successful winning years under the Fridge. This year they pulled in 5 of the Top 9 recruits in Maryland. They continue this with their Staff and we don't improve dramatically we will be in the cellar each year with Indiana.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,593
61,926
113
Your missing the point. Over the last 15 years Maryland had only been getting at most One or two Top 10 Maryland players each recruiting class. This trend even occurred during the successful winning years under the Fridge. This year they pulled in 5 of the Top 9 recruits in Maryland. They continue this with their Staff and we don't improve dramatically we will be in the cellar each year with Indiana.

Actually you're missing the point: until it does happen, 3-4 classes in a 5-year stretch or so, they ARE NOT a "top 20 type recruiting program"

Need consistency before being proclaimed as such. Pretty simple my friend.
 

scarletbergen

Senior
Aug 17, 2006
2,319
773
66
Creep State.......Hey kids, read this.....

It's hard to find reputable statistics about hate group numbers since many are inclined not to mention their membership when statisticians ask. But anyone who lives in the region - and pays attention - can attest to the open presence of hate group activity. This was particularly shocking to me, a product of suburban North Carolina, where racist institutions and stereotypes are far more common than actual hate groups campaigning on behalf of "white power."" How Abuse, Corruption and Silence at Penn State Perpetuate a Poisonous Culture, 26 July 2012, Kristin Rawls, AlterNet | Op-Ed

And nobody helped
 

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,965
38,871
113
Your missing the point. Over the last 15 years Maryland had only been getting at most One or two Top 10 Maryland players each recruiting class. This trend even occurred during the successful winning years under the Fridge. This year they pulled in 5 of the Top 9 recruits in Maryland. They continue this with their Staff and we don't improve dramatically we will be in the cellar each year with Indiana.

Cripes...we just won two games and improved recruiting dramatically. If we had gone bowling you could have added 2 of the other top 5NJ kids to our class.
We are not that far behind. Ash gets a couple of years. But when he has his team on the field, if he is good, we are good.
 

jason21psu

Junior
Jan 9, 2015
608
399
0
I've been thinking about recruiting some recently and I had this thought. Basically there's two end methods and shades of grey in between for building quality teams. Loading up with 4 & 5 star kids that leave with eligibility remaining. Or filling a roster with quality 3's where nearly all exhaust their eligibility.

The first method would be what Bama and OSU have done of late and the second would be what TCU has done. In the first your have more consistent success and in the second you have a class or two that develops really well and you can make a run but the success is harder to maintain. The goal is to transition from the second to the first but there are often bumps along the way ala MSU this season.
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
why would a recruit NOT want to got to PSU? Great education, school, not a liberal bastion of retardation, winning football, school is supported by the state, great alumni network, packed house each weekend, great atmosphere, coaches that can coach and tradition

What do we have besides tradition and education?
 
  • Like
Reactions: zwicker

GSGS

Heisman
Aug 2, 2001
29,450
23,891
113
why would a recruit NOT want to got to PSU? Great education, school, not a liberal bastion of retardation, winning football, school is supported by the state, great alumni network, packed house each weekend, great atmosphere, coaches that can coach and tradition

.. and brand new locker rooms so players don't need to shower where 10 year old boys got raped or slosh around in Jerry Sandusky's ***** any more. What's not to like?
 

LevaosLectures

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2015
3,977
3,156
0
why would a recruit NOT want to got to PSU? Great education, school, not a liberal bastion of retardation, winning football, school is supported by the state, great alumni network, packed house each weekend, great atmosphere, coaches that can coach and tradition

What do we have besides tradition and education?

God, shut up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burton12

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
you two are typical of unrealistic RU fans. First you talk about the scandal (awful but it's not deterring kids from going there so grow the fk up) and now to 'shut up'. lol, pathetic losers think like that

Rutgers has problems, problems that need to be addressed and are not. Get mad at the school and those that run it, not people that don't view things with scarlet glasses

again I'll ask, why choose Rutgers over PSU?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference