I think coaches are their own worst enemy.Considering Allen was one of our best last year, this is disappointing to hear how using him was maybe not as much of a priority-
“(Whipple) wants everybody involved in the passing game,” Beckton said. “There are certain plays that tight ends know they’re the first option. We used to be third or fourth, now we have plays where we’re the first option.”
I don't disagree he could have been used a little differently. However, people have been screaming to get the ball to Manning, or Betts, or Toure, or even to "run the damn ball". There's only so many plays and only 1 football. If we're giving more 1st looks to Allen, then we're not giving them to the other guys & vice versa. We can't have it both ways unfortunately.Considering Allen was one of our best last year, this is disappointing to hear how using him was maybe not as much of a priority-
“(Whipple) wants everybody involved in the passing game,” Beckton said. “There are certain plays that tight ends know they’re the first option. We used to be third or fourth, now we have plays where we’re the first option.”
That is why it is great being a fan! We get to ***** about it...we don't have to actually make the calls!I don't disagree he could have been used a little differently. However, people have been screaming to get the ball to Manning, or Betts, or Toure, or even to "run the damn ball". There's only so many plays and only 1 football. If we're giving more 1st looks to Allen, then we're not giving them to the other guys & vice versa. We can't have it both ways unfortunately.
I think coaches are their own worst enemy.
Few years back I had to call plays on offense (Hated it and sucked at it). I called this play and it got us a few yards and I called that specific play because I was "outsmarting" the other team.
An asst coach on staff said "Hey, just run that again but run it with the other kid", okay, sure. So I did that.
Kid took off for a 50 yard TD.
After the play was over I said "What made you think to have me call that?"
He looked at me and goes "Because that kid is bigger, faster and stronger than everyone else on the field"
He was right.
Long boring story short: Allen should have been targeted 5-8 times a game.
According to an article I read a couple of months ago, Whipple will go to great lengths in game planning to maximize an advantage.Sometimes coaches call plays that don't make sense to us but there's a rhyme & reason. Setting up plays for later in the game or even later in the season does take place. Yes, you want every play to score & they are all designed to do so in certain situations, but even personnel can be used to set things up. You're wrong if you think for a minute that Whipple doesn't try to outsmart the opponent & utilize plays & personnel to see reactions & set up something for later.
Yeah, this is just looking at tendencies.Sometimes coaches call plays that don't make sense to us but there's a rhyme & reason. Setting up plays for later in the game or even later in the season does take place. Yes, you want every play to score & they are all designed to do so in certain situations, but even personnel can be used to set things up. You're wrong if you think for a minute that Whipple doesn't try to outsmart the opponent & utilize plays & personnel to see reactions & set up something for later.
What you say is absolutely true. And even if he was a late read, Allen finished second in receptions (38) behind Toure.I don't disagree he could have been used a little differently. However, people have been screaming to get the ball to Manning, or Betts, or Toure, or even to "run the damn ball". There's only so many plays and only 1 football. If we're giving more 1st looks to Allen, then we're not giving them to the other guys & vice versa. We can't have it both ways unfortunately.
How do you know he didn’t have audible rights? I’m not disputing, just curious how you know that for a fact.What you say is absolutely true. And even if he was a late read, Allen finished second in receptions (38) behind Toure.
Betts and Manning simply did not seem to be targeted as much despite having pretty reliable hands and respectable 20-26 catches respectively. So I don’t know how much they were taking away from Allen.
There’s also an element of how a QB is trained to read a defense pre-snap. Do we know if Adrian had “flexibility” in the order of his reads? Or (my impression) is they taught him one way to run a play, which certainly poses disadvantages. I know he didn’t have audible rights, so it makes me question what he knew about where to go with the ball (combined with generally slow decision making).
I keep thinking of him missing Falck and Vokolek running wide open for potential TDs.
It happens, but was there ever a chance to be clued in on their likelihood of getting open based on pre-snap reads? Maybe, maybe not.
While not 100%, I’m pretty sure it was discussed in the past, as well as just from observation.How do you know he didn’t have audible rights? I’m not disputing, just curious how you know that for a fact.
Pre-snap reads from the QB spot aren’t that difficult in its basic form. When defenses disguise coverages, it becomes much more difficult but can be done. Either way, you have to process it all quickly which I don’t think AM did very well some games. I actually do think he did a good job sometimes but he seemed very inconsistent to me. Zach Taylor was very good at it as I remember.
I believe this to be accurate. I don't remember many plays at all, where the audible didn't come from the sideline. Hell I don't remember very many plays where they simply lined up and ran the play called in the huddle. There was always a check to the sideline. The exception being late in halfs or games when the clock was running.While not 100%, I’m pretty sure it was discussed in the past, as well as just from observation.
It’s also different because their audibles came in the form of sideline checks. So it doesn’t mean we never audibled, it just came from the coaches, not QB. Adrian’s decisions focused more on zone read stuff, plus route progressions.
I agree it greatly reduces the need for an audible but I would expect the QB to still have that option. When they've rec'd the play, and the defense changes so he looks over for another play and with time ticking off the play clock, the defense changes again. It will be rare but still has to be an option. Now, did the QB get prepared enough during the week to make an audible or is he just going to call a time out because he's confused and doesn't have enough time to look over for a 3rd play & set the offense? I've never seen an offense that didn't have a "go to" audible to keep a team out of a bad play. I'm not saying I know for a fact that AM was given options but I would still be surprised if he wasn't.I believe this to be accurate. I don't remember many plays at all, where the audible didn't come from the sideline. Hell I don't remember very many plays where they simply lined up and ran the play called in the huddle. There was always a check to the sideline. The exception being late in halfs or games when the clock was running.
Yeah, I thought the same thing.Nice to see our snaps haven’t improved at all.![]()
Agreed. And it could be the same play to audible to in several scenarios. If the defense does this, audible to that. Just change up the HOT callI agree it greatly reduces the need for an audible but I would expect the QB to still have that option. When they've rec'd the play, and the defense changes so he looks over for another play and with time ticking off the play clock, the defense changes again. It will be rare but still has to be an option. Now, did the QB get prepared enough during the week to make an audible or is he just going to call a time out because he's confused and doesn't have enough time to look over for a 3rd play & set the offense? I've never seen an offense that didn't have a "go to" audible to keep a team out of a bad play. I'm not saying I know for a fact that AM was given options but I would still be surprised if he wasn't.
In theory, yes. I am just asking, when did you see Martinez make a call, walk up and down the line and let the OLine know the play call, make the hand funnel to yell out to receivers the new play or whatever? I don't remember seeing it, is all I am saying. They huddled, went to the line, did a fake snap, looked to the sideline to see if they need to run the original play or get the new play, then ran the play.Agreed. And it could be the same play to audible to in several scenarios. If the defense does this, audible to that. Just change up the HOT call
This is cool, but you have to watch closely.
I can't remember any. And quite frankly that whole " line up and then look to the sideline " just totally flew into the face of the "play fast" philosophy coming inIn theory, yes. I am just asking, when did you see Martinez make a call, walk up and down the line and let the OLine know the play call, make the hand funnel to yell out to receivers the new play or whatever? I don't remember seeing it, is all I am saying. They huddled, went to the line, did a fake snap, looked to the sideline to see if they need to run the original play or get the new play, then ran the play.
I am just saying I don't remember Martinez making many of those calls, they all seemed to come from the sidelines and signaled in to the players.
Play fast was as much to catch the opponent in with certain personnel as it was to catch them in a certain formation.I can't remember any. And quite frankly that whole " line up and then look to the sideline " just totally flew into the face of the "play fast" philosophy coming in
Never REALLY saw it at NU much. There were times/flashes of it. That's funny because like you say Frost was successful with it at Oregon and saw it at ucf as well.Play fast was as much to catch the opponent in with certain personnel as it was to catch them in a certain formation.
The best display I saw with that was the Oregon vs Florida St game in the Rose Bowl CFP semi final. There was so many times that Frost caught Charles Kelly with a personnel group in and got a big play, then ran that exact play a few times in a row until they scored or until Florida St called a time out.
There was a significant amount of hurry up in Frost’s offense here too. Again hurry up doesn’t have to mean getting to the ball fast and running a play every 20 seconds. To be effective you just have to play fast enough to keep the opponent from being able to substitute if you get the matchups you want.Never REALLY saw it at NU much. There were times/flashes of it. That's funny because like you say Frost was successful with it at Oregon and saw it at ucf as well.
Good caveat that it’s not only about when the snap comes.There was a significant amount of hurry up in Frost’s offense here too. Again hurry up doesn’t have to mean getting to the ball fast and running a play every 20 seconds. To be effective you just have to play fast enough to keep the opponent from being able to substitute if you get the matchups you want.