They are completely different players. Grant has a different pace. No reason to attack the kid. If he leaves, okay, next up. If he stays, okay, let’s go.
I mean, there kind of “is”. I believe this is Pike’s worst defense ever at Rutgers including his first season here. And CJ Gettys wasn’t exactly a lock down defensive center either.
There’s plenty of blame to go around but right now Grant arguably stands out as the biggest problem of all because of the hole left by his lack of help D and failure to rebound (even when the ball comes right to him) when he’s in the game. Buchanan’s lower rebounding metrics are a result of him flying all over the map attempting to provide bail out help D in areas that are not his responsibility. He’s not an amazing defender, but he’s decent. Just constantly playing out of position and covering for others.
Grant’s issues are a black hole because when he sits, our alternatives are unattractive for reasons that aren’t really about individual player shortcomings. The options are:
A) play 3 guards together - can’t really blame the guards for why this limits us - we already play without a starting caliber center so of course playing without the length / physicality of a SF too is going to be a problem. Not to mention our guards are small.
B) play Denis who is a train wreck on D.
C) play Nwuli who has shown flashes but is often dreadfully out of position in typical frosh fashion. Seems lost in the schemes still pretty often.
If I was Pike, I’d play Bryce at the 4 but then again, Ogbole can’t seem to stay on the court more than 15 or so mpg anyway.
So there you have it. The reality is - if Caleb or Mag was on this team, they would be replacing Grant’s minutes in the line up to improve the defense substantially. Not the guards, Buchanan, etc. On the flip side - I don’t think the D would be all the much better if you put JY or Derek Simpson at point instead of one of the guards. Maybe we get a few more steals but at the end of the day the rate limiting issue is we have no answer in the post unless we pack the paint which is why we give up so many 3s. Having one better perimeter defender in the mix wouldn’t much help this problem.