Poll Zion Williamson
- Thread starter etowncatfan
- Start date
I can’t hate on Zion. Even though he plays for the enemy he seems like a good person. I’m not ready to put him in the hall of fame yet. I went with the butler pick
I would guess he will be on a tier between Jimmy Butler and Lebron. That’s a pretty wide gap.
Lol Tatum is average? Come on now. Dudes a future all star. Far drop from that to Okafor
I don’t know how good he can be, but right now, as a #1 pick, he sure looks better next to AD to me than as a player you build a franchise around.
Agreed. I think Tatum has a very bright future ahead of him. Now that Kyrie is likely gone, I think he’ll improve a lot.
The return of Hayward. They have an overload of guys who play the same position. Add to that a ball dominant guard in Kyrie. Just seemed a regression was bound to happen under their current roster construction.
Still put a near 16 a game and shot 45%. Had to look that up
It’s untelling where Zion ends up. But these choices, dang. Just because you’re an All-Star doesn’t mean you’re on MJ and LeBron’s level. And I wouldn’t call Tatum average, not yet anyways.
Not to compare college level players to NBA, but I recall a lot of people on here saying Zion is overhyped because he was just dunking on 5 ft nothing white boys in high school and that he would struggle at Duke. I think he is a future HOF and 1st team All-NBA level player
Tatum is way above average. He is very good
LeBron and MJ choice should have been "All Time Great"
Needs a wedge in there for perrenial All Star...
Then you could do your other options.
IMO, based shearly off athletic ability- specifically body control, speed and strength Zion will be a perrenial All Star.....all time great, I doubt.
Needs a wedge in there for perrenial All Star...
Then you could do your other options.
IMO, based shearly off athletic ability- specifically body control, speed and strength Zion will be a perrenial All Star.....all time great, I doubt.
You're leaving out a pretty important level - and IMO the most likely spot for Zion - between Lebron and Butler. You're jumping from "top 5 all time player" to "never one of the 10 best in any season" (Butler has been 3rd team all NBA).
He’ll put up numbers in the regular season because it’s a dunk fest. Post season, no real threat imo
He won’t be a bust. You don’t have his PER in college, and all of a sudden you’re a bust. Only way he’s a bust, is if he stays injured.
IMO, which really doesn't matter at all, I think he's going to have to change his game to really last. He's a borderline 300 pound freight train, going from a 40 game season to at least an 82 game season. I don't see his body holding up.
That being said, I'm pretty sure he could still kick my ***.
That being said, I'm pretty sure he could still kick my ***.
A guy that big can't move that quick and jump that high, can't do so without being chemically enhanced. Williamson is a drug test or blown out knee from obscurity. Even before either of the 2 aforementioned things happen, he will not be allowed to just run over everybody in his path without ever getting offensive fouls called on him. Just let him try to bully the Boogie Man and see what happens.
I would put him in kyrie terrritory. I think he will be strong when he plays but will be often injured in an 82 game season. I don’t think he has the durability to get through 82 game season where each game is 8 min longer. If he has to carry the Pelicans he will probably Peter out pretty quick. He needs davis
Well, technically 285lbs is 95% of 300lbs. I'd say that's pretty close to three bills.
Lebron isn’t on Jordan’s tier. Sorry.
Jordan is on a tier alone. He’s not that
Next tier is Lebron / Bird tier. Nope.
He’s just below that. I’m guessing a Carmelo in his prime or something similar in terms of importance.
Jordan is on a tier alone. He’s not that
Next tier is Lebron / Bird tier. Nope.
He’s just below that. I’m guessing a Carmelo in his prime or something similar in terms of importance.
This is what everyone said before he got to college. He's not going to be MJ or LBJ, but hes going to be in that Harden, Westbrook, Griffin stratosphere of being one of the top players at his position for as long his knees hold out. He will have a good first year or 2 but once he gets used to the game and gets a little more trimmed down, hes gonna be at that level for years barring an injury.
Zion is an amazing basketball player. I am not sure how his body can handle the wear and tear of a NBA schedule.
Honestly being an NBA All Star is as much about being popular as being one of the best in the league sometimes. I mean let's be honest Jamal Magloire was an All Star as was BJ Armstrong, Dale Davis and Kyle Korver who averaged around 12 ppg in his all star season and has never averaged more than 14.
Last edited:
Since I am not an NBA fan or watch the NBA my last image of Zion will be his going down in the NCAA tournament like fire falling from the sky. Good memories.
He got by on his freak size and athletic ability at dook. He isn't terribly skilled and he isn't a great shooter. When he gets to the NBA he will find out that everyone is long and athletic. He will be good but he will not be a hall of fame caliber player.