Not true at all. I see GoodOl' and e5 already shone some light on this upthread. In terms of naming, Rutgers has never tried to be like Princeton so it's the wrong example to use here, whether it was trying to emulate it in other ways or not.... The first intercollegiate football game was technically between Rutgers and CNJ (perhaps informally as Old Nassau) since it was not called Princeton in 1869 (nor for 27 more years after). Might have been referred to casually as 'Princeton' prior to 1896 if only to note its location. Btw, Princeton moved twice in its first 10 years (Elizabeth & Newark before finally settling further south). Rutgers was chartered and always remained in New Brunswick (although it closed for quite a few years in early 1800s).
Rutgers was always the smaller of the schools until WWII. In fact we were much smaller than Princeton before then.
Even with its official name as the "College of New Jersey" until 1896, it was almost always referred to as "Princeton" by newspapers, students alumni, etc. Far more references as "Princeton" rather than the College of New Jersey.
It's true. Princeton started in 1746 in the parsonage of its first president in Elizabethtown and then moved to Newark the next year. The Board of Trustees put out signals it wanted to move to a more permanent rural location. Two towns were very interested. The town that responded quicker won. The towns were Princeton and New Brunswick. In fact, the first commencement was held in Newark. The second -- on the last Wednesday of September, 1749 -- it was held in New Brunswick. That's right, the College of New Jersey held Commencement in New Brunswick before it ever held one in Princeton.
The first college building in the state was Nassau Hall in 1754 which was also used as an informal reference to Princeton (College of New Jersey).
When Rutgers played Princeton on May 5, 1866 in baseball, the box score identified the two teams as the "Rutgers Base Ball Club" and the "Nassau Hall Base Ball Club."
From July to October in 1783, Nassau Hall hosted the entire American government serving as a temporary capital of the United States of America.