Poll #2: Do you think we WILL fire him?

Will Jeff Lebby be fired?

  • FIRED - does not coach in 2027

    Votes: 62 27.4%
  • Only fired if we lose to Tennessee Tech, otherwise back

    Votes: 97 42.9%
  • RETAINED - even if we finished 4-8, he's back next year.

    Votes: 67 29.6%

  • Total voters
    226

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,386
3,334
113
We see from the earlier poll that 95% want him fired and 85% don't even want him coaching against Auburn.

But do you believe that Keenum and Selmon will actually pull the trigger, or will they deliver a brutal betrayal?
 

Bulldawg77

All-American
Dec 1, 2019
4,894
9,572
108
Depending on contractual language with some assistants we are looking at 10-13MM for the entire staff buyout. Now, that number is heavily driven by the 7.65 of Lebbys contract, mitigating . Arnette still has two years left the others just have one year left or contract runs out.
10-13MM is a lot but we are a P4 teams and shouldn’t blink at that number
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,522
3,097
113
I’m afraid it’s going to take 4-8 including a smashing by OM.
 

bulldognation

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2004
3,837
1,654
113
We will do the most MSU thing. The administration won’t pull the trigger until after he’s lost 8 straight. And by then we will be late to the coaching search which will result in us grabbing some “hopeful diamond in the rough” coordinator from a mid major for cheap. Steve will praise the hire claiming he’s not only a magic man, but also leaving salary room for better coordinators or NIL.
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,386
3,334
113
We will do the most MSU thing. The administration won’t pull the trigger until after he’s lost 8 straight. And by then we will be late to the coaching search which will result in us grabbing some “hopeful diamond in the rough” coordinator from a mid major for cheap. Steve will praise the hire claiming he’s not only a magic man, but also leaving salary room for better coordinators or NIL.
That sounds like a best case scenario at this point...
 

FactCheckerBot

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2025
839
1,440
93
I'm a pessimist. We're gonna keep him another year and the suck will continue.
Fact.

KT1 will re-commit but Lebby won’t be able to recruit an OL and KT1 will go down yet aGAIN and Lebby will be hung out to dry but he will never be let go while KT1 is here to make him look like a genius. Once KT1 is gone, Lebby will be…is “exposed” the correct word? I ask because he’s already been exposed to those with eyes and intelligence.

Letting this program sink further into the abyss is infuriating for fans. Administration must know something we don’t if they feel keeping on this road is better than providing hope for fans that things are being done. The stands the next two weekends should be a message to Selmon and Keenum but maybe “subtle” hints aren’t they’re forte.
 

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
I'd like to vote he will be fired no matter what but I have no faith in that happening.

Here is the kicker for me. The only positive vibe that has come out of Lebby's tenure is attributable to just one player. One player that made us a winner. One player that made us a playoff contender. We can say that because once he got hurt we reverted back into the hapless bottom feeder we have been the past two seasons. That one player was not recruited or signed by Jeff Lebby. One player, that Lebby did not sign, is collectively better than the sum total of every player he brought in for the past three years. Let that sink in folks.
 

Baddog11

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2013
4,494
3,500
113
We just gotta make the lay ups on first down. Because if we don’t make the lay ups on first down, we have no chance at getting 2nd down or 3rd down.

IMG_3215.png
 
  • Haha
Reactions: peewee.sixpack

40 acres and a mule

All-Conference
Dec 9, 2018
992
1,001
93
We will do the most MSU thing. The administration won’t pull the trigger until after he’s lost 8 straight. And by then we will be late to the coaching search which will result in us grabbing some “hopeful diamond in the rough” coordinator from a mid major for cheap. Steve will praise the hire claiming he’s not only a magic man, but also leaving salary room for better coordinators or NIL.
Cheap is the operative word here.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,467
33,328
113
Note that the "Lebby defender" line was always "he's safe as long as he beats Vanderbilt, and of course he'll do that," and the goalposts have shifted to "he's safe as long as he beats Tennessee Tech, as of course he'll do that."
I'm definitely not a Lebby defender. But I always thought 5-7 would be enough for him to keep his job. I've been resigned to the fact he's coming back next year since the Missouri game. Of course at the time, I was starting to think I might be wrong about him and he might be a good coach after all. He's pushed that crazy thought far from my mind since then.
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,386
3,334
113
I'm definitely not a Lebby defender. But I always thought 5-7 would be enough for him to keep his job. I've been resigned to the fact he's coming back next year since the Missouri game. Of course at the time, I was starting to think I might be wrong about him and he might be a good coach after all. He's pushed that crazy thought far from my mind since then.
Same. But after the last 5 games, I don't think he could ever win me over again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

RiverCityDawg

All-American
Dec 30, 2009
3,410
5,426
113
Note that the "Lebby defender" line was always "he's safe as long as he beats Vanderbilt, and of course he'll do that," and the goalposts have shifted to "he's safe as long as he beats Tennessee Tech, as of course he'll do that."
Not a Lebby's defender, I think he's a bad HC and I want him gone. But I did think a Vandy win would for sure save him and I still believe he might be safe with the hurt QB free pass as long as we beat Tenn Tech.

But I don't think it's certain that we beat Tenn Tech. They will have the better offense and will have much better morale. A loss there would obviously be the end.
 

downwarddawg

Sophomore
Mar 3, 2008
531
112
43
I'm definitely not a Lebby defender. But I always thought 5-7 would be enough for him to keep his job. I've been resigned to the fact he's coming back next year since the Missouri game. Of course at the time, I was starting to think I might be wrong about him and he might be a good coach after all. He's pushed that crazy thought far from my mind since then.
This is where I'm at also. I thought it was a bad hire from the beginning. After that Missouri game, I was just like you. I had to admit this is possibly the best MSU offense I've ever seen. I thought maybe I was wrong.
Turns out, the only thing I was wrong about, is thinking that I was wrong. (It's like I tell my wife all the time)
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
6,386
3,334
113
I mean for pete's sake, Robbie Faulk left a comment on IG that "there are more metrics than just winning percentage..." - I mean is that how our University looks at this? If so, this isn't fixable with any of the current leadership in place.
It's not like the other metrics are good either. In 2025 we could delude ourselves into saying some of the losses to good teams were close so maybe he's on the cusp. This year we only kept it close with Vanderbilt.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,467
33,328
113
I mean for pete's sake, Robbie Faulk left a comment on IG that "there are more metrics than just winning percentage..." - I mean is that how our University looks at this? If so, this isn't fixable with any of the current leadership in place.
Good lord! We are M-State! There is literally ONLY ONE metric. Obviously you have to be reasonable in setting your goal and defining what's acceptable. But 3-20 has to be way below the acceptable threshold. And 2-7 in year 3 has to be as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gtowndawg

thekimmer

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2012
8,968
3,192
113
I mean for pete's sake, Robbie Faulk left a comment on IG that "there are more metrics than just winning percentage..." - I mean is that how our University looks at this? If so, this isn't fixable with any of the current leadership in place.
He's right but all of those suck too.
 

gtowndawg

Senior
Jan 23, 2007
2,451
939
113
It's not like the other metrics are good either. In 2025 we could delude ourselves into saying some of the losses to good teams were close so maybe he's on the cusp. This year we only kept it close with Vanderbilt.
The only way to measure a coach after 3 years is wins and losses. They say if KT was healthy, we would have won more. Ok, if we never had KT we would have lost more. The scoreboard is what matters, that's even more important in the modern day of college (pro) football. Win games, you get into the playoffs and make money. Lose games, lose money. Pretty simple and it's not open to interpretation, feelings, "they're good guys" or any other ridiculous form of measurement.
 

Chesusdog

All-American
May 2, 2006
5,223
5,738
113
I mean for pete's sake, Robbie Faulk left a comment on IG that "there are more metrics than just winning percentage..." - I mean is that how our University looks at this? If so, this isn't fixable with any of the current leadership in place.
Sure there are other metrics. Fan support. Attendance. Points per game and points allowed. The good ol' eye and smell tests.

Which one paints him in a positive light, Robbie?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darryl Steight

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,467
33,328
113
The only way to measure a coach after 3 years is wins and losses. They say if KT was healthy, we would have won more. Ok, if we never had KT we would have lost more. The scoreboard is what matters, that's even more important in the modern day of college (pro) football. Win games, you get into the playoffs and make money. Lose games, lose money. Pretty simple and it's not open to interpretation, feelings, "they're good guys" or any other ridiculous form of measurement.
Injuries happen. Coaches have to be prepared for them and deal with them. Lebby's recruitment and coaching of backups is as bad as I've ever seen. As is his total inability to make any adjustments to this offense to generate anything at all is pathetic. It sucks that KT got injured. But injuries happen. And sometimes the way a coach deals with it costs him his job. Lebby has no valid complaint if he's fired.
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,869
3,328
113
Sure there are other metrics. Fan support. Attendance. Points per game and points allowed. The good ol' eye and smell tests.

Which one paints him in a positive light, Robbie?
He has increased his number of SEC wins year after year. Clearly an upward trajectory**
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,558
7,037
113
Injuries happen. Coaches have to be prepared for them and deal with them. Lebby's recruitment and coaching of backups is as bad as I've ever seen. As is his total inability to make any adjustments to this offense to generate anything at all is pathetic. It sucks that KT got injured. But injuries happen. And sometimes the way a coach deals with it costs him his job. Lebby has no valid complaint if he's fired.
Yep. And one step further, Lebby's inability to recruit and develop an effective offensive line has been a hindrance to keeping the QB healthy. Yeah, I can easily argue that the team is completely different with KT running the offense. I have eyes. That could also translate to a big season next year IF he stays healthy.

But are really going to put all our eggs in this basket? What's the point of running it back when whatever QB we have is going to have his hip and shoulder thrust in the dirt multiple times a game due to a C level offensive line that will inevitably show up on game days. We will just be wasting a rare talent. Shapen missed 8 on yr 1. KT will miss 8 practically in yr 3. That's like 40% of your entire history of HC coached games having to rely on Plan B or C at the most important position in the game. The backups this year are constantly harassed and have had to come out of at least 1 game due to injury. I don't like this trend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,558
7,037
113
I mean for pete's sake, Robbie Faulk left a comment on IG that "there are more metrics than just winning percentage..." - I mean is that how our University looks at this? If so, this isn't fixable with any of the current leadership in place.
😂😂😂😂 What metric is he proud of?
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  2. 02 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights