OT: Your 2018 QB NFL draft board

MorrisAsh

All-Conference
Dec 5, 2015
2,637
4,429
113
This year’s class if full of talent. List your 2018 NFL draft eligible QBs in order of preference

Here’s mine:
1) Darnold- super accurate passer. Best chance to be the next Peyton
2) Baker Mayfield- brash, needs to grow up, mobile, can make every throw, teammates love him. Best chance to be the next Brees
3) Rosen- bad attitude, concussions, teammates don’t like him but has a great arm and pocket presence. Could be Ryan Leaf or could be Aaron Rodgers.
4) Josh Allen- Big dude with a strong arm that has scouts saying he has tremendous upside. It will be interesting to see if someone like Denver reaches for him. Obviously being compared to Carson Wentz
5) Lamar Jackson- great runner and a string but inaccurate arm. Needs a few years on the bench to grow. Could be the next Russell Wilson.
 

ScarletStateofNJ

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2011
3,176
2,588
0
As a Giants fan, I am hoping that Darnold doesn’t go to the Browns because I think Rosen is a punk and could be a problem in NYC. I’d trade down to the Jets slot, let them take Rosen and then draft Allen or Mayfield.

My order is Darnold, Allen, Rosen, Mayfield, and Lamar Jackson as a 2nd round WR.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AreYouNUTS

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
I think people are deluded by the Wentz/Goff/Prescott success into overeating the impact of this QB draft class. If you look at real data (go back the last 10-15 years) the hit rate for even early round QBs is less than 50%.

At best 2-3 of your list of 5 will have a big NFL impact, but from recent accounts they will all be drafted in the top 15.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletStateofNJ

NickyNewark51

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2015
2,729
1,000
0
1-Rosen
2-Mayfield/3-Lamar Jackson,
(Cam Newton-lite)
4-Allen,Josh
*Doesn't Josh Darnold already have serious concussion issues? Pass on damaged #1 pick and trade down for extra pick.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletStateofNJ

asgot

All-Conference
Aug 8, 2017
2,132
2,365
113
My concern with the California guys is how will they adjust to playing in the cold, like Josh Allen as he has proven he can playing in the cold.

This is why I think they should draft a OL or move back
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutger80

MorrisAsh

All-Conference
Dec 5, 2015
2,637
4,429
113
My concern with the California guys is how will they adjust to playing in the cold, like Josh Allen as he has proven he can playing in the cold.

This is why I think they should draft a OL or move back
Aaron Rodgers, a California kid, seems to have adapted to the frozen tundra, soooo....moreover its only really cold in Philadelphia-DC-NY for the last month of the season.
 

Rutgers1976

Senior
Dec 30, 2005
3,438
769
0
Allen
Darnold
Rosen
Mayfield
Jackson

Allen didn't face the opponents but didn't have the supporting crew
Rosen is injury prone and I worry about his shoulder history
Darnold needs maturing
Jackson is kind of like RGIII IMHO--he'll get busted up in the NFL--but he might could out to be like our old friend Sanu.
I like Mayfield's mojo, but until I see a Big 12 QB make it in the pros, he's going to have to prove himself to me.
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
I like darnold and then Allen.
If I were the giants , I would take one of them.
Giants reporter on wfan - Paul d- said today that they probably wouldn’t take a quarterback and that they would go forward with eli and webb. I find that hard to believe unless they really think Webb is the future. But how come he wasn’t good enough to beat out geno smith then?
 

asgot

All-Conference
Aug 8, 2017
2,132
2,365
113
I am not sure I see a can’t miss QB in this class and the Giants have so many needs moving down to collect picks is not a bad idea. They need to remake their OL or they will have the same issues no matter who the QB is
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saint Puppy

MorrisAsh

All-Conference
Dec 5, 2015
2,637
4,429
113
I like darnold and then Allen.
If I were the giants , I would take one of them.
Giants reporter on wfan - Paul d- said today that they probably wouldn’t take a quarterback and that they would go forward with eli and webb. I find that hard to believe unless they really think Webb is the future. But how come he wasn’t good enough to beat out geno smith then?
He needed a redshirt year. If that is the case then the giants will trade down and should draft one of the ND OL.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
27,144
19,432
113
As a Giants fan, I am hoping that Darnold doesn’t go to the Browns because I think Rosen is a punk and could be a problem in NYC. I’d trade down to the Jets slot, let them take Rosen and then draft Allen or Mayfield.

My order is Darnold, Allen, Rosen, Mayfield, and Lamar Jackson as a 2nd round WR.

A bigger problem with Rosen is that he might get another concussion or two (particularly if he plays behind the Giants OL with no high draft pick help) and retires at age 25.
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
Darnold
Allen

"Meh" after those two. Rosen is injury prone and a crankyish preppy. Jackson is probably yet another running QB who lasts but a few years under NFL contact. Mayfield is another Big 12 cookie cutter stat monster (like Bryce Petty etc).
 
Sep 29, 2005
14,051
16,131
0
I would put Darnold 1, Mayfield 2 and Allen 3. I would not draft Rosen that high, not because of attitude but because of the two concussions this year. I've seen enough of Jackson where I question his accuracy, his ability to make all necessary throws and that he runs at the first hint of pressure, and would not take him in first round.
 

SkilletHead2

All-American
Sep 30, 2005
24,503
9,416
113
The Jints need a QB for the future and this is the best chance they will have to get a highly rated one. QB drafting is always a gamble, but it's one the Giants have to take right now. If they don't, they might go 8-8 next year and will not have a high pick to use.

There is a lot to like in both Darnold and Rosen, and some not to like. They are clearly and deservedly the top two prospects.

The question becomes how much potential do you see in Jackson, Mayfield, and Allen? And then there are a couple of sleepers as well.

New York fans have been enamoured of insanity of "The future is now" ever since the days of Patrick Ewing. It is a massively dumb strategy. Love Eli. Best thing the Giants can do right now is trade him for picks. They are never going to win it all again with him.

I'd go for Darnold or Rosen if they are available (there's a chance neither one will be when the Giants pick). Should they trade down if they could get one of the other three? I like all three of them. I would say that Darnold and Rosen both have about a 75% chance of being franchise-type QBs and that the other three have about a 50%-60% chance. Add those odds up and you have two of the five being franchise types. That's what I'd put it at.

(The one thing they shouldn't do is what the bozo in that article linked said to do. Pass on three proven college QBs for a speculation? That's what they did last year.)
 

Sec 127

Sophomore
Sep 23, 2014
231
162
0
I see Allen dropping. The knock on him is that he makes more than his share of WTF decisions. He may have entered the season as the most highly regarded QB. Unless the new GM wants to put his stamp on the team, I don't think a QB will be drafted. Either I would take Barkley or trade down to a team like the Jets or Denver who would like to move up and take a QB.
The conventional wisdom is that this season is an abberation and they won't get a chance to draft this high in the near future. That doesn't warrant a reach.
 

1stand3rd

Sophomore
May 13, 2008
670
193
43
After watching the Rose Bowl, I don't think Baker Mayfield can make NFL throws, plus there's the Big 12 thing. Give me Josh Allen as the first QB picked.
 

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
As a Jets fan this is my list:

Lamar Jackson
Josh Rosen
Josh Allen
Sam Darnold
Baker Mayfield
The Jets, with their huge amount of cap room for next year, should sign Cousins or another free agent QB and use their pick on an OL, CB, or edge rusher.

Being at pick #6 they would have to trade one or both of this year's round 2 picks as well as next year's 1st rounder to move up for Rose/Allen/Darnold (Jackson is a project if he even turns out to be a QB in the NFL). It is hard to see QBs falling to the Jets with the Browns taking one with the 1st and the Colts at 3 and the Browns at 4 likely candidates to trade down with teams that want a QB.
 

Doctor Worm

Heisman
Feb 7, 2002
31,306
23,268
113
As a Giants fan, I am hoping that Darnold doesn’t go to the Browns because I think Rosen is a punk and could be a problem in NYC. I’d trade down to the Jets slot, let them take Rosen and then draft Allen or Mayfield.

My order is Darnold, Allen, Rosen, Mayfield, and Lamar Jackson as a 2nd round WR.
I don't think your strategy will work for the Giants, because Colts will likely trade down from 3, to some team hungry for a QB. Would not be surprised if Browns also trade down from 4. Giants will not get Allen at 6. Jets will have to trade up if they want him.

That said, all our analyses are as of this point in time, and we all know the draft board will move a lot between now and April. So who knows.
 

KingHigh

All-American
Apr 12, 2005
21,293
9,216
0
As a giants fan, I do not like any of the qbs yet. Every one of them has some real issues that increase their bust potential versus past top qb prospects. Can't afford that. The giants have Eli still. Fix the team, and Eli will still be a solid qb. Davis webb is getting rave reviews from coaches and teammates. The gamble at qb should be to stay put.

I like the idea of grabbing Barkley at 2 - he is a generational talent. Never pass up generational talent. Otherwise, trade down and collect hog-mollies. That was always the main problem with this team, and us the top priority this off season.
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
This is the most overrated bunch of QBs ever.
Darnold's best game was last year, Rosen's was the first game this season. Neither lived up to the hype. I don't think any of them are worthy of a top 5 pick. But since the NFL has become one dimensional, great QBs are a must to win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU old timer

ponyfoot19

Senior
Dec 19, 2007
2,596
509
0
Giants are really in an interesting position. Give Manning help up front and he can still be a good qb. The big unknown is Webb. They've had a whole year with him, seen him in practices, meetings relating to other players etc. Its possible they feel he has as much upside as any of the five coming out.Therein is the rub. Will the new coach keep any of the Giants' existing offensive coaches. I would think the GM is getting feedback from the coaching staff on personnel,plus whatever observations he has had a chance to make.I'd like Barkley,but how effective can he be unless the OL is substantially upgraded. In the end I would not be surprised to see the Giants trade down, perhaps picking up a good young OL and draft picks.
 

Section124

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
17,612
23,587
96
My order would be (not specific to Round 1):

Darnold
Allen
Mayfield
Rudolph

That being said, I would rather get Barkley and OL. I think Barkley is the type of player the Giants need and miss. I think he will break the Penn St RB jinx.
 

ScarletSince86

All-Conference
May 18, 2004
1,496
1,112
38
As a jet fan I would like cousins and would even consider keenum/bridgewater. If I had to go with a new guy it would be mayfield. I don’t like Allen at all. I think he is a huge bust. Which is why the jets love Allen. Frankly, I can’t believe mccagnan gets to pick another qb after the hack disaster. But they are the jets.....
 
Sep 1, 2014
258
201
0
This year’s class if full of talent. List your 2018 NFL draft eligible QBs in order of preference

Here’s mine:
1) Darnold- super accurate passer. Best chance to be the next Peyton
2) Baker Mayfield- brash, needs to grow up, mobile, can make every throw, teammates love him. Best chance to be the next Brees
3) Rosen- bad attitude, concussions, teammates don’t like him but has a great arm and pocket presence. Could be Ryan Leaf or could be Aaron Rodgers.
4) Josh Allen- Big dude with a strong arm that has scouts saying he has tremendous upside. It will be interesting to see if someone like Denver reaches for him. Obviously being compared to Carson Wentz
5) Lamar Jackson- great runner and a string but inaccurate arm. Needs a few years on the bench to grow. Could be the next Russell Wilson.
For me, the QB with the most upside is,
Mason Rudolph!!!
 

SkilletHead2

All-American
Sep 30, 2005
24,503
9,416
113
As a giants fan, I do not like any of the qbs yet. Every one of them has some real issues that increase their bust potential versus past top qb prospects. Can't afford that. The giants have Eli still. Fix the team, and Eli will still be a solid qb. Davis webb is getting rave reviews from coaches and teammates. The gamble at qb should be to stay put.

I like the idea of grabbing Barkley at 2 - he is a generational talent. Never pass up generational talent. Otherwise, trade down and collect hog-mollies. That was always the main problem with this team, and us the top priority this off season.
The only rationale for not picking a QB in this very strong class is that they really believe they have a great QB in Davis Webb. Eli is no longer Eli. They will not have the #2 pick again for a long time. QB is by far the most important position on the team. This is a simple calculus.
 
Jan 30, 2007
903
234
0
My concern with the California guys is how will they adjust to playing in the cold, like Josh Allen as he has proven he can playing in the cold.

This is why I think they should draft a OL or move back
Yeah, Aaron Rogers had a terrible time transitioning from Cal to the frozen tundra. What an exaggerated, nonsensical presumption.
 

Scarlet_Monster

All-Conference
Jan 8, 2011
6,164
4,234
0
Yeah, Aaron Rogers had a terrible time transitioning from Cal to the frozen tundra. What an exaggerated, nonsensical presumption.

Yeah, and people assume any QB not 6' + will have all their passes knocked down at the LOS, except the QB who lead the league in passes knocked down at LOS this past year was the 6'6 Blake Bortles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scarletschuyler

mikebal9

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2005
5,742
4,989
113
Because I don't think Darnold or Rosen will be any good, is rather roll the dice on Allen. I don't necessarily think he's a future star either, but maybe I can get him later. If I were a GM, I'd be trading down. Even the Browns. These guys all have bust written all over them.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,525
61,846
113
My concern with the California guys is how will they adjust to playing in the cold, like Josh Allen as he has proven he can playing in the cold.

This is why I think they should draft a OL or move back

Cali and southern guys have been "adjusting" to the cold forever and Eli still has a few years left so that one of these guys COULD have that "adjustment period" for sure. I'd wait for a QB as well, however, if we can land a stud LT.
 

160louis_rivals149488

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2014
4,428
3,565
0
If I had five 7th round picks I still wouldn’t draft Lamar Jackson. Mayfield, meh, he gets drafted but I don’t like him whatsoever. I wouldn’t draft him unless he dropped to 5th round. Doesn’t have the arm talent or size.

What’s important here is you’re projecting who will have the better career. Career, in 3-4 years whose better. Don’t fall into the rookie year hype see: RG3, Dak and eventually Watson.

Darnold
Rosen
Allen

That’s the three I like and am interested in.
 
Mar 1, 2007
673
733
93
This year’s class if full of talent. List your 2018 NFL draft eligible QBs in order of preference

Here’s mine:
1) Darnold- super accurate passer. Best chance to be the next Peyton
2) Baker Mayfield- brash, needs to grow up, mobile, can make every throw, teammates love him. Best chance to be the next Brees
3) Rosen- bad attitude, concussions, teammates don’t like him but has a great arm and pocket presence. Could be Ryan Leaf or could be Aaron Rodgers.
4) Josh Allen- Big dude with a strong arm that has scouts saying he has tremendous upside. It will be interesting to see if someone like Denver reaches for him. Obviously being compared to Carson Wentz
5) Lamar Jackson- great runner and a string but inaccurate arm. Needs a few years on the bench to grow. Could be the next Russell Wilson.



lots of gossip and fake news being passed out about Josh Rosen and character assaults
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.sb...fl-draft-josh-rosen-browns-giants-ucla-bruins
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  2. 02 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener