OT; The 150th Open Championship

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Please do share why it’s in PGA’s interest to let their top players go to play in LIV? What’s the benefit? Your problem is you think you know everything.
Exposure. They would be playing the 15 PGA mandatory and 8 more.
What is the benefit of throwing them out of the PGA? It has not stopped anyone from leaving to go to the LIV.
You keep harping on the players losing sponsors. Big deal. Phil is making more from his appearence fees PLUS he can earn 20× in purse money on top of that!
Let's add in your stupidity about seltzers in the NJ brewery thread. You argue without facts!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: T2Kplus20

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Didn't the players sign on with the LIV before the PGA suspend/ ban them from participating in any PGA tour venues.?
If they signed a contract to participate in LIV tours for x amount of money as a signing bonus , they signed on with a PGA rival and the PGA is treating them as their rival's employees.
Not all of them. The PGA wouldn't know if they signed on unless the player confirmed it. Phil was banned while he sat out of golf altogether.
They aren't rival employees. The are co employees. 1099 guys playing on their off days.
 

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,529
12,645
82
Exposure. They would be playing the 15 PGA mandatory and 8 more.
What is the benefit of throwing them out of the PGA? It has not stopped anyone from leaving to go to the LIV.
You keep harping on the players losing sponsors. Big deal. Phil is making more from his appearence fees PLUS he can earn 20× in purse money on top of that!
Let's add in your stupidity about seltzers in the NJ brewery thread. You argue without facts!!
Exposure? PGA didn’t lose Speith, Morikawa, Schauffele, or any of the top 10. That’s winning. i never argue about seltzer. I asked and was appreciate of the facts. Unlike you, I can admit I don’t know everything.
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Exposure? PGA didn’t lose Speith, Morikawa, Schauffele, or any of the top 10. That’s winning. i never argue about seltzer. I asked and was appreciate of the facts. Unlike you, I can admit I don’t know everything.
Yes you did. Go back and read the part you said it was my opinion crap.
I don't know everything but golf, beer and business is in my wheelhouse certainly not yours. Stay in your lane!
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
Not all of them. The PGA wouldn't know if they signed on unless the player confirmed it. Phil was banned while he sat out of golf altogether.
They aren't rival employees. The are co employees. 1099 guys playing on their off days.
Didn't Phil sign on with the LIV while he wasn't playing in any PGA events, then get suspended/banned from PGA tour events.
The PGA might have a way to know who signed on with who because info about the LIV tour and players involved might be easily obtainable .

Seems like the players banned never said they weren't part of the LIV, so I'm guessing the PGA has a way to know whose involved with the LIV, then takes action.
If not I would expect lawsuits would already have been filed by the p[layers that never said they signed on with the LIV tour

As for co-employees, they are independent contractors that are bound by both the LIV & PGA Tour rules.
Both tours should have the right to say who plays in their tour events and if they feel letting a player participate or not would be if either tour felt that player would be a PR asset or detrimental to their image

You could be right on all counts, I just don't see how the PGA could have acted like you said without some legal blow-back from Phil and other players you claimed were banned by the PGA
for joining the LIV tour if they weren't signed on at the time of ban
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Didn't Phil sign on with the LIV while he wasn't playing in any PGA events, then get suspended/banned from PGA tour events.
The PGA might have a way to know who signed on with who because info about the LIV tour and players involved might be easily obtainable .

Seems like the players banned never said they weren't part of the LIV, so I'm guessing the PGA has a way to know whose involved with the LIV, then takes action.
If not I would expect lawsuits would already have been filed by the p[layers that never said they signed on with the LIV tour

As for co-employees, they are independent contractors that are bound by both the LIV & PGA Tour rules.
Both tours should have the right to say who plays in their tour events and if they feel letting a player participate or not would be if either tour felt that player would be a PR asset or detrimental to their image

You could be right on all counts, I just don't see how the PGA could have acted like you said without some legal blow-back from Phil and other players you claimed were banned by the PGA
for joining the LIV tour if they weren't signed on at the time of ban
Well the DOJ got involved so the government thinks the PGA did something wrong...again.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
Well the DOJ got involved so the government thinks the PGA did something wrong...again.
Actually the DOJ is just making sure nothing is amiss.
Could be decided on their own because of all the publicity surrounding the PGA and LIV tour players or a complaint was made by someone and the DOJ is investing what was complained about in order to make sure labor or any other government regulations weren't being ignored.

In 1994 the FTC investigated the PGA over it's rules and in 2022 the PGA roles being looked at by the PGA back then are still in effect.
One of the rules investigated was the one that forbids golfers to play in a non-PGA event without the PGA commissioner’s permission. The other PGA rule gave the PGA veto power over tour players appearances on televised golf programs.
It was claimed that while the tour’s disputed policies control players, the restraints are necessary to assure TV networks and sponsors a reliable supply of quality golfers..
The FTC didn't change that and dropped the investigation , though the investigation did last four years before the FTC ended it

Being investigated doesn't necessarily mean something's amiss, just that the government is making sure their isn't any wrong doing involved and the reason for the look-see is because of the publicity surrounding the issue make it best to make sure everything is on the up and up or someone asked the DOJ to become involved and they are following up on a complaint
 
Last edited:

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,529
12,645
82
Yes you did. Go back and read the part you said it was my opinion crap.
I don't know everything but golf, beer and business is in my wheelhouse certainly not yours. Stay in your lane!
Yes, please go back and read. I gave you a like for teaching me about how hard seltzer is made. I literally said learned something new today In that thread. like I said before, PGA has nothing to gain by voluntarily letting competition take their best product. PGA did what they have to protect their league and it’s working.
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Actually the DOJ is just making sure nothing is amiss.
Could be decided on their own because of all the publicity surrounding the PGA and LIV tour players or a complaint was made by someone and the DOJ is investing what was complained about in order to make sure labor or any other government regulations weren't being ignored.
iN 1994
Actually apparently no one involved in the LIV complained. The announcement was made by the DOJ itself without any reference of a complaint.
Either way it's not like the previous investigation by the FTC in 1994. This is the DOJ investigating this time. Big difference. Anti Trust violation issues. I don't disagree that nothing may come from it but all should agree that being investigated indicates that there is a perceived possible violation. They don't investigate on a whim.
Yes, please go back and read. I gave you a like for teaching me about how hard seltzer is made. I literally said learned something new today In that thread. like I said before, PGA has nothing to gain by voluntarily letting competition take their best product. PGA did what they have to protect their league and it’s working.
After the fact. You cried about why could brewers make seltzers. Then I called you out and explained why you were totally wrong. Embarrassing argument on your part. It's not like seltzers are new this year.
 

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,529
12,645
82
Actually apparently no one involved in the LIV complained. The announcement was made by the DOJ itself without any reference of a complaint.
Either way it's not like the previous investigation by the FTC in 1994. This is the DOJ investigating this time. Big difference. Anti Trust violation issues. I don't disagree that nothing may come from it but all should agree that being investigated indicates that there is a perceived possible violation. They don't investigate on a whim.

After the fact. You cried about why could brewers make seltzers. Then I called you out and explained why you were totally wrong. Embarrassing argument on your part. It's not like seltzers are new this year.
Dude, the thread is there. read it. We argue about bar/rest vs breweries. I never argue with you about seltzer. SMH
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Dude, the thread is there. read it. We argue about bar/rest vs breweries. I never argue with you about seltzer. SMH
I did read it. Why the hell did I correct you? You tried to us it against breweries producing stuff they shouldn't have. It was the reason you brought it up!
 

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,529
12,645
82
I did read it. Why the hell did I correct you? You tried to us it against breweries producing stuff they shouldn't have. It was the reason you brought it up!
I give up. You correct me because I agreed with rujohnny that breweries are operating more like a bar, not about Seltzer. Anyways, we are now arguing about our previous arguments. Good times.
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
I give up. You correct me because I agreed with rujohnny that breweries are operating more like a bar, not about Seltzer. Anyways, we are now arguing about our previous arguments. Good times.
Well your right about a past correction on my part. Since this is a golf thread maybe you should give up about LIV players losing money too. Because you can't argue that point correctly either.
 
Jul 10, 2002
2,467
419
67
Didn't the players sign on with the LIV before the PGA suspend/ ban them from participating in any PGA tour venues.?
If they signed a contract to participate in LIV tours for x amount of money as a signing bonus , they signed on with a PGA rival and the PGA is treating them as their rival's employees.
That’s a fact. You want o play in a competitive renegade tour? Fine. But don’t expect the PGA Tour to cut you a break. People who leave our company for a rival get walked out the door the same day. We’ send your personal effects back to you in the mail.

plus, what’s the whole demand for another tour. Are fans clambering for more access to golf tournaments. If 10,000 people actually show up Bedminster to see Pat Perez, then it’ll be proof that they’ve papered the house. What makes the local PGA Tour events work are the local community support for the local organizations that actually sells the tickets and a TV contract. LIV only has a sugar daddy that few like or respect.
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
That’s a fact. You want o play in a competitive renegade tour? Fine. But don’t expect the PGA Tour to cut you a break. People who leave our company for a rival get walked out the door the same day. We’ send your personal effects back to you in the mail.

plus, what’s the whole demand for another tour. Are fans clambering for more access to golf tournaments. If 10,000 people actually show up Bedminster to see Pat Perez, then it’ll be proof that they’ve papered the house. What makes the local PGA Tour events work are the local community support for the local organizations that actually sells the tickets and a TV contract. LIV only has a sugar daddy that few like or respect.
Have you seen what TV, Amazon, YouTube is paying for content? Yes a true world tour can exist. The European soccer Leagues looked at it and were defeated by the fans of each team. There isn't any true golf fans that doesn't want more golf instead of Dart Leagues or Cornhole on ESPN or Skysports. Why do you think the Big Ten added just two PAC12 schools??
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
Actually apparently no one involved in the LIV complained. The announcement was made by the DOJ itself without any reference of a complaint.
Either way it's not like the previous investigation by the FTC in 1994. This is the DOJ investigating this time. Big difference. Anti Trust violation issues. I don't disagree that nothing may come from it but all should agree that being investigated indicates that there is a perceived possible violation. They don't investigate on a whim.
The FTC lawyers were checking for anti-Trust violations back then and came close to recommending that the FTC file a formal legal complaint to nullify the rules..
But that didn't happen and rules stayed in place.
That FTC investigation was around the time Greg Norman was trying to start a tour ( World Golf Tour) that would compete with the PGA tour .
If the FTC found the PGA were in violation of the anti-Trust act Norman's World Tour would have happened

The DOJ might find fault now and give Norman the win that eluded him in 1994 when the FTC dropping their PGA investigation doomed his world tour into oblivion.and allowed the PGA to conduct business as usual.
Or find the PGA is going by the book and just protecting itself from a competitor.

But no one can be sure what the DOJ will find different than the FTC did in 1994 or because of changing times find the PGA did violate anti-Trust laws and base it on the same type of evidence the FTC didn't pursue when they ended their investigation.
The FTC didn't absolve the PGA, they just dropped their investigation allowing the PGA to keep their rules in place

Strange how Greg Norman had a personal interest in the FTC investigating the PGA in 1994 and has a stake in the current DOJ investigating of the PGA
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
The FTC lawyers were checking for anti-Trust violations back then and came close to recommending that the FTC file a formal legal complaint to nullify the rules..
But that didn't happen and rules stayed in place.
That FTC investigation was around the time Greg Norman was trying to start a tour ( World Golf Tour) that would compete with the PGA tour .
If the FTC found the PGA were in violation of the anti-Trust act Norman's World Tour would have happened

The DOJ might find fault now and give Norman the win that eluded him in 1994 when the FTC dropping their PGA investigation doomed his world tour into oblivion.and allowed the PGA to conduct business as usual.
Or find the PGA is going by the book and just protecting itself from a competitor.

But no one can be sure what the DOJ will find different than the FTC did in 1994 or because of changing times find the PGA did violate anti-Trust laws and base it on the same type of evidence the FTC didn't pursue when they ended their investigation.
The FTC didn't absolve the PGA, they just dropped their investigation allowing the PGA to keep their rules in place

Strange how Greg Norman had a personal interest in the FTC investigating the PGA in 1994 and has a stake in the current DOJ investigating of the PGA
The FTC investigation wasn't just a Greg Norman thing. It was a players thing. Funny how everyone is making the FTC thing just about Norman now.
The huge difference now is the PGA Tour is a year round Tour preventing them to play anywhere without approval
 

ClassOf02v.2

Heisman
Sep 30, 2010
14,020
15,694
103
@WhiteBus and @jtung230 with an epic rally here
Ping Pong Cat GIF
 
  • Haha
Reactions: WhiteBus

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
The FTC investigation wasn't just a Greg Norman thing. It was a players thing. Funny how everyone is making the FTC thing just about Norman now.
The huge difference now is the PGA Tour is a year round Tour preventing them to play anywhere without approval
didn't see Norman made an investigation issue by anyone unless you feel my saying it's strange Norman tried to start the World tour around the time the FCC was investigating the PGA .
Being involved with the LIV now and the DOJ investigation the PGA over LIV players being kept from the PGA tour gives a connection there, but no one said he was reason for either investigation.

Just pointed out he had an interest in how the FTC investigation turned out and being involved with the LIV makes him have a stake in the way this DOJ look-see turns out
No one said he started either, just a known fact both investigations were over players and the outcome had an effect on the last golf tour venture he was involved with, just like this one will effect the present golf tour he's a part of

You're are seeing things that don't exist
 
Last edited:
Jul 10, 2002
2,467
419
67
didn't see Norman made an investigation issue by anyone unless you feel my saying it's strange Norman tried to start the World tour around the time the FCC was investigating the PGA .
Being involved with the LIV now and the DOJ investigation the PGA over LIV players being kept from the PGA tour gives a connection there, but no one said he was reason for either investigation.

Just pointed out he had an interest in how the FTC investigation turned out and being involved with the LIV makes him have a stake in the way this DOJ look-see turns out
No one said he started either, just a known fact both investigations were over players and the outcome had an effect on the last golf tour venture he was involved with, just like this one will effect the present golf tour he's a part of

You're are seeing things that don't exist
the Same week Biden headed to Saudi Arabia to beg for oil, his DOJ leaked that it was reviewing the LIV and PGA Tour issue. Coincidence? I think not.
 

Knightmoves

Heisman
Jul 31, 2001
30,972
17,083
113
The LIV rumors get worse for the PGA Tour. $300M for Matsuyama?

  • Former Masters champ Hideki Matsuyama is expected to announce his LIV membership sometime next month, most likely after the FedEx Cup playoffs get underway next month, per a report from The Mirror. The Japanese star will reportedly command a contract worth as much as $300 million.
  • Mere hours after he hoisted the Claret Jug, Smith was linked to LIV along with fellow Aussie Marc Leishman, according to a report from IrishGolfer.ie. With those two blokes in the fold, Norman would be well positioned to lure Adam Scott and assemble an All-Australian squad for the exhibition series, per the Telegraph (UK).
 

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,529
12,645
82
The LIV rumors get worse for the PGA Tour. $300M for Matsuyama?

  • Former Masters champ Hideki Matsuyama is expected to announce his LIV membership sometime next month, most likely after the FedEx Cup playoffs get underway next month, per a report from The Mirror. The Japanese star will reportedly command a contract worth as much as $300 million.
  • Mere hours after he hoisted the Claret Jug, Smith was linked to LIV along with fellow Aussie Marc Leishman, according to a report from IrishGolfer.ie. With those two blokes in the fold, Norman would be well positioned to lure Adam Scott and assemble an All-Australian squad for the exhibition series, per the Telegraph (UK).
Congrats to Hideki. If DJ only got 120mm, he should fired his agent asap. Maybe C Smith should hold out for 400mm.
 

Section124

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
17,625
23,596
96
I doubt Hideki would get that much, but who really knows how much these guys were offered. I read Finau was part of the rumor with Hideki and the Aussies. It will be interesting after the PGA Tour playoffs to see what happens.
 

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,529
12,645
82
I doubt Hideki would get that much, but who really knows how much these guys were offered. I read Finau was part of the rumor with Hideki and the Aussies. It will be interesting after the PGA Tour playoffs to see what happens.
If all the rumors were true, LIV already got majority of the top 10 players.
 

Section124

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
17,625
23,596
96
I was just looking at the current OWG rankings. Once you get past 20, not so great. A lot of players that look like current LIV or future LIV.
 
Jul 24, 2001
8,866
921
0
The LIV rumors get worse for the PGA Tour. $300M for Matsuyama?

  • Former Masters champ Hideki Matsuyama is expected to announce his LIV membership sometime next month, most likely after the FedEx Cup playoffs get underway next month, per a report from The Mirror. The Japanese star will reportedly command a contract worth as much as $300 million.
  • Mere hours after he hoisted the Claret Jug, Smith was linked to LIV along with fellow Aussie Marc Leishman, according to a report from IrishGolfer.ie. With those two blokes in the fold, Norman would be well positioned to lure Adam Scott and assemble an All-Australian squad for the exhibition series, per the Telegraph (UK).

Yeah I am not buying these rumors. For starters, Cam Smith apparently has confirmed he's not jumping to LIV, at least not yet. He's going to finish out the 2022 season. I guess he may make the jump later.

And Smith was rumored to be offered around $90-100 million. Matsuyama getting $300 million? That seems completely out of whack with what other top stars got. DJ didn't get close to that. Neither did Koepka. As I noted, Smith is rumored at $90 million.
 
Jul 24, 2001
8,866
921
0
I doubt Hideki would get that much, but who really knows how much these guys were offered. I read Finau was part of the rumor with Hideki and the Aussies. It will be interesting after the PGA Tour playoffs to see what happens.

Yeah that and the Presidents Cup. Once those take place, I wonder if you see way more movement. Conversely, if not much happens after those events, then maybe LIV has petered out a bit, for now.
 
Jul 24, 2001
8,866
921
0
Exposure. They would be playing the 15 PGA mandatory and 8 more.
What is the benefit of throwing them out of the PGA? It has not stopped anyone from leaving to go to the LIV.
You keep harping on the players losing sponsors. Big deal. Phil is making more from his appearence fees PLUS he can earn 20× in purse money on top of that!
Let's add in your stupidity about seltzers in the NJ brewery thread. You argue without facts!!

Exposure how? The top golfers get more than enough exposure. And right now, LIV is relegated to streaming services (and with events overseas - odd times for the US audience to watch).
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod