I get his point, it’s just not a good one.
judging past people by today’s standards isn’t really something I support, especially when you consider what life was actually like in Europe in the 1450s up to the 1490s when Columbus hit Hispaniola.
However, someone who wiped out practically 95% of Hispaniola in the mines feeding them grass, and then proceeded to invade neighboring islands, slaughter all able bodied males, take the women, elderly, and children and proceed to do the exact same to thing to the point where 90% of those native populations were wiped off the face of the earth is an objectively terrible person.