Wanted to follow-up on this and say thank you for all the great suggestions!
Neither of us ever spent much time in Savannah and we both really enjoyed it. The Spanish Moss gave it a really eerie feel.
We stayed at the Foley House Inn across the street from Chippewa Square (the Forrest Gump bench isn’t there, but you can easily figure out where it was). I don’t know how it compares to other places to stay, but we really liked it. Nice room & atmosphere and you can’t beat the location. We watched Midnight in the Garden of Good & Evil the first night we were there and it gave us some places to search out, so good suggestion there.
We ate at Treylor Park Hitch (another good suggestion) for lunch and it was a good casual place.
Went down to the Riverfront area and checked out the shops and that Power Plant Marriott. It was REALLY cool. It was like going to a free museum. Also went to the huge Basilica of St. John the Baptist, the stained glass and the decor inside are unbelievable.
We ate at Alligator Soul for dinner and had the candied alligator for an appetizer, which was amazing, and had antelope for my main course and it was easily the best meal I’ve eaten in a LONG time.
Spent the next day at Tybee Island, drove by the lighthouse. There are better beaches in the world, but it was about my speed as far as beaches go, not too crowded, pretty clean, and wasn’t junked up with seaweed or views of oil tankers.
Drove back to the B&B through Bonaventure Cemetery and it is simultaneously beautiful and creepy. In that way, it’s an allegory for the whole town.
I am going to echo what everybody else has said about the Savannah Bananas. Go. Ours was a regular Coastal Plains League game and it was still one of the most fun times I’ve ever had at a sporting event. They played in kilts and came out of centerfield like they were in Braveheart behind a galloping horse with their bats held over their heads. There is literally something happening from the time you get in line until the very end of the game. The music is all designed to be sung along with and the players periodically come through the crowd. There are dancing septuagenarians and fan participation and crazy skits during evening inning and mid-inning break. Oh... and all you can eat hot dogs, hamburgers, cheeseburgers, and chicken sandwiches is included in your ticket.
So again, thanks guys. I pulled this thread up multiple times when I was there and you guys really came through.