OT - Need a doc

DarthCat

Sophomore
Jun 5, 2001
3,375
194
63
How did that injury happen, out of curiosity?
Probably more than you need to know, but here goes.

Preacher curl. The seat slipped down during a rep. Instead of standing up I tried to just finish out the rep, but was now at an angle that over extended the arm. When I was pulling the weight up from that position, something started to go bad, and it felt like rubber bands snapping in my left forearm.

I did quit after that, but thought I just strained my forearm. Didn’t think about it much and the next few days I was able to get through the other workouts in my split. When back and biceps came around again, I was still good the whole workout. Back exercises and dumbbell curls were no problem. Then I hit a barbell curl, and once I was getting to the 6-8 rep range, it REALLY snapped. Same feeling as before, but worse.

The muscle didn’t retract up into the shoulder like many/most people see with a torn distal bicep, so I diagnosed myself as being okay. The next day was the NU at Illinois game at Soldier Field. I woke up and the inside of my left arm was super bruised. When we got home from the game, I started researching symptoms and got more concerned.

I got into Rush on Monday afternoon, and they were like, “Yeah, you’re having surgery ASAP.” If I waited, they said, the tendon would start to heal detached from the forearm and they would never be able to reattach it. They got me in Wednesday. They told me that there is a sheath through which the tendon runs and while my tendon was snapped, I guess the sheath was still there and is why the muscle hadn’t retracted…..yet.

From a pain and discomfort perspective, maybe the worst part of the whole thing was my nausea from reading about and listening to the description of the injury and the surgery. But the arm was locked in a brace at 90 degrees for a long time, and some long car trips like that did get pretty uncomfortable.
 
Last edited:

stpaulcat

Senior
May 29, 2001
35,284
861
113
Thanks. This is exactly what I was looking for. I had a top shoulder guy and am now looking at shoulder replacement way too early in life. I have heard of Bach, but I think I will travel the road of WJ here. I have been cut three times by Nuber, was at NU as an athlete, then twice more when I returned to Chi, and am surprised he is still operating. - really nice guy.

Not sure how badly I damaged my MCL - but if I have to get cut there too, I want the best I can get.

As a retired med mal defense lawyer and having more than a dozen surgeries, I learned early on to seek out leading physicians (often using guys that I had used as experts in cases). The result is only one bad outcome (couple of digits no better than before), but elbows, ankles and a variety of other fixes that allowed me to continue to play competitive sports as I approach 50.

Anywho, thanks for the input!
Which direction are you approaching 50 from?
 

TheC

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
19,216
1,302
62
I wish I lived closer to Chicago to take advantage of these recommendations. My shoulder has been killing me since the spring and I fear surgery could be in my near future. I already know I have a slight labrum tear that was diagnosed several years ago. It was not enough to bother with surgery then. But this time it hurts even more. Uggh.... getting old sucks. Though I guess the only thing worse is not getting old.
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,810
166
43
Which direction are you approaching 50 from?
This thread is from long ago. Nuber did the knee. Kelikian has done both ankles. Schaeffer cut the elbow a few times. Garrigues is the latest shoulder guru out of Duke at Rush and did my replacement.

All top shelf. I think Schaeffer has died.
 

CatManTrue

All-American
Oct 4, 2008
16,538
5,695
97
I wish I lived closer to Chicago to take advantage of these recommendations. My shoulder has been killing me since the spring and I fear surgery could be in my near future. I already know I have a slight labrum tear that was diagnosed several years ago. It was not enough to bother with surgery then. But this time it hurts even more. Uggh.... getting old sucks. Though I guess the only thing worse is not getting old.
I know a good shoulder guy in the NE. He checked out my old post labrum injury a few years ago and he advised against surgery at the time. How do I DM you his info? Doesn’t look like you have a subscription to allow it.
 

FloridAlum

Senior
May 29, 2001
16,227
588
0
I know a good shoulder guy in the NE. He checked out my old post labrum injury a few years ago and he advised against surgery at the time. How do I DM you his info? Doesn’t look like you have a subscription to allow it.
Wrong. You can initiate a private conversation with him because you are a paid member, and then he can respond. In his post, click on his name and then you should see at the bottom it says start a conversation, click on it
 

CatManTrue

All-American
Oct 4, 2008
16,538
5,695
97
Wrong. You can initiate a private conversation with him because you are a paid member, and then he can respond. In his post, click on his name and then you should see at the bottom it says start a conversation, click on it
Cool! I learned something today. Will shoot C a note.
 

Deeringfish

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2008
21,141
1,383
63
Dr. Michael Terry at Northwestern did a great job on my meniscus.

He’s also the team doctor for NU athletics and the Chicago Blackhawks, so I assume I got a free ride on somebody else’s due diligence...

I don’t know if he does shoulders.
I second this opinion. Ten years ago when I crushed the second joint of my little finger, two doctors had creative ideas about amputation. I lucked into a third opinion who happened to be the surgeon who did most of the work for the Packers. It's not real pretty but I have a 90% functional, pain free little finger.
Fun fact many hand doctors will tell you your little finger is the most important due to grip leverage and spatial awareness.
 

Zootcat

Redshirt
Nov 17, 2008
1,123
11
38
Brian Cole or Kathy Weber at Midwest Ortho (knee consultations)

Gordon Nuber at Northwestern Ortho (did my shoulder and Mrs Jacks ACL)

Mark Schickendantz at Cleveland Clinic (did my knee)
Interesting. A long time ago, I consulted with Schickendantz on product development. But, we thought of him as a shoulder specialist. Regardless, he was a really good surgeon, and an even better guy to work with.
 

Zootcat

Redshirt
Nov 17, 2008
1,123
11
38
I second this opinion. Ten years ago when I crushed the second joint of my little finger, two doctors had creative ideas about amputation. I lucked into a third opinion who happened to be the surgeon who did most of the work for the Packers. It's not real pretty but I have a 90% functional, pain free little finger.
Fun fact many hand doctors will tell you your little finger is the most important due to grip leverage and spatial awareness.
Broke mine too. It amazed me how much depended on my litttle finger. I play a lot of tennis, and it played hell with my backhand grip or a long time.