OT - Craig's List and Accompanying Trollers

bomanishus

Sophomore
Mar 17, 2009
432
132
43
Almost immediately when I put an item for sale on Craig's List, I started getting troll-like responses from people. Has anybody else had this experience?

For example, I put a bicycle on the site. Over the next few days I got emails and texts (I put my phone number on the site - it's optional) from people who didn't identify themselves saying 'I want the bike, hold it for me, I will send you money.' In essence, this is what their message said.

Early on, I didn't realize these were trollers but later came to the conclusion. It simply wouldn't occur to me to do this.

One of them actually said they would send a check for the amount of the bike 'plus some money for me to pay the delivery service' that was going to ship the bike back to him in Florida. I said 'fine.'

The bike was $ 500, so I assumed he would a) never send a check but b) if he did, the amount would be $600 or something like that. Well, the check arrived and I was astonished to see that it was for almost $2,000. Up to this point I had only assumed this guy was not legit - this confirmed it.

A quick call to the bank on which it was drawn revealed that the account was closed. I'm sure this is some sort of mail fraud but I'm not inclined to pursue it at this point.

Ok, so end of that chapter of the story, but what is the end game of these trollers? Why send me a check for $2,000, knowing that I wasn't going to release the bike to anybody until the check cleared. What did he hope to gain -

It's made me a bit skittish on putting anything else on Craig's List.

Anybody else had this experience?

PS - I have a great road bike for sale. Specialized.
 

missouridawg

Junior
Oct 6, 2009
9,407
309
83
Almost immediately when I put an item for sale on Craig's List, I started getting troll-like responses from people. Has anybody else had this experience?

For example, I put a bicycle on the site. Over the next few days I got emails and texts (I put my phone number on the site - it's optional) from people who didn't identify themselves saying 'I want the bike, hold it for me, I will send you money.' In essence, this is what their message said.

Early on, I didn't realize these were trollers but later came to the conclusion. It simply wouldn't occur to me to do this.

One of them actually said they would send a check for the amount of the bike 'plus some money for me to pay the delivery service' that was going to ship the bike back to him in Florida. I said 'fine.'

The bike was $ 500, so I assumed he would a) never send a check but b) if he did, the amount would be $600 or something like that. Well, the check arrived and I was astonished to see that it was for almost $2,000. Up to this point I had only assumed this guy was not legit - this confirmed it.

A quick call to the bank on which it was drawn revealed that the account was closed. I'm sure this is some sort of mail fraud but I'm not inclined to pursue it at this point.

Ok, so end of that chapter of the story, but what is the end game of these trollers? Why send me a check for $2,000, knowing that I wasn't going to release the bike to anybody until the check cleared. What did he hope to gain -

It's made me a bit skittish on putting anything else on Craig's List.

Anybody else had this experience?

PS - I have a great road bike for sale. Specialized.

The scammers do incredibly dumb things for incredibly smart reasons. It's a filter to help highlight the most vulnerable.

Because you are not one of the most vulnerable, you put an end to the discussion around the check pretty quickly. But for someone who doesn't see what's coming, they could've already shipped the bike.... or worse, they've could've deposited the check and before it bounced, sent the rest of the balance back to the scammer prior to realizing the check bounced.

Those ridiculous e-mails from Nigeria about boats (and other things)... they are so completely and entirely outlandish, that only the biggest of fools would even contemplate a response. And that's exactly who the scammers are trying to identify.
 

Oxford Andrew

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
1,748
4,207
113
It's a basic check scam.

They want you to deposit the check and send them the difference, then they have the merchandise and whatever money you sent them. They'll often use a fake cashier's check since your bank has to immediately post the balance and it can take days or weeks before the check comes back as fraudulent and the bank removes it from your account. Basically, they'll send you a fake cashier's check and then ask you to wire the difference to them. They get your money and in a week or two the cashier's check bounces.
 

OleMissLogo

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2014
15,573
0
0
Scams are pretty common, but I have done a LOT on Craigslist and it is rare for me to get a scam response (paid my fraternity dues by flipping stuff on Craigslist.)

The check/wire scam that you are talking about is the most common "distance scam" on there. They send you a worthless check for more than the amount of the item plus fees (like shipping) hoping that you try to deposit it and send them the back the balance before it bounces. So, they sent you a nice piece of paper worth nothing, and you would (if you fell for it) send them $1400 back that they can really use.

I don't recommend putting a phone number on there, and don't write your email in the body of the post. Spam bots can pick out phone numbers and email addresses from the body. And don't do any deals over long distance unless you set up a PayPal link. You will lose about 3% due to fees, but it is secure.
 

FQDawg

Senior
May 1, 2006
3,076
618
113
Probably common knowledge, but don't list your address either.

A buddy of mine (not the brightest bulb in the pack) wanted to sell his car a few years ago and listed his address so people could drive by and take a look at it. Somebody came by and stole the car in the middle of the night.
 

MadDawg.sixpack

Redshirt
May 22, 2006
3,358
0
0
Almost immediately when I put an item for sale on Craig's List, I started getting troll-like responses from people. Has anybody else had this experience?

For example, I put a bicycle on the site. Over the next few days I got emails and texts (I put my phone number on the site - it's optional) from people who didn't identify themselves saying 'I want the bike, hold it for me, I will send you money.' In essence, this is what their message said.

Early on, I didn't realize these were trollers but later came to the conclusion. It simply wouldn't occur to me to do this.

One of them actually said they would send a check for the amount of the bike 'plus some money for me to pay the delivery service' that was going to ship the bike back to him in Florida. I said 'fine.'

The bike was $ 500, so I assumed he would a) never send a check but b) if he did, the amount would be $600 or something like that. Well, the check arrived and I was astonished to see that it was for almost $2,000. Up to this point I had only assumed this guy was not legit - this confirmed it.

A quick call to the bank on which it was drawn revealed that the account was closed. I'm sure this is some sort of mail fraud but I'm not inclined to pursue it at this point.

Ok, so end of that chapter of the story, but what is the end game of these trollers? Why send me a check for $2,000, knowing that I wasn't going to release the bike to anybody until the check cleared. What did he hope to gain -

It's made me a bit skittish on putting anything else on Craig's List.

Anybody else had this experience?

PS - I have a great road bike for sale. Specialized.

They are looking for the 1 out of 1,000 not smart enough to be suspicious.
 

BulldogBlitz

Heisman
Dec 11, 2008
18,733
27,712
113
when i use craigslist, i have only done it to sell things... like my entire 2 bedroom apartment full of furniture when i got married. listed everything individually on a friday, last item was picked up sunday afternoon. i had a couple g in my hand. never posted my phone number, forced all communication through craigslist. some savvy folks would move it off that email right away and some others that were equally as skeered of all the horror stories.

i've sold single items over the years with the same method. would imagine posting fone and address would come with its traps.
 

SwampDawg

Sophomore
Feb 24, 2008
2,193
122
63
I put a house rental on Craig's List. Got an email from (drum roll) a professor at Oxford University in England. In spite of his position, his written communications sounded more like that that of a third world person. He was so interested he did not ask for pictures of the house and neighborhood or ask any intelligent questions. He told me he would be in the U.S. in a couple of months but wanted to close on the rental to make sure he would get it. I sent him an email saying I would be glad to rent it to him, but that if this deal included any thing like me cashing a big check and sending the balance back to him it was no deal. Never heard back.
 

OleMissLogo

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2014
15,573
0
0
I put a house rental on Craig's List. Got an email from (drum roll) a professor at Oxford University in England. In spite of his position, his written communications sounded more like that that of a third world person. He was so interested he did not ask for pictures of the house and neighborhood or ask any intelligent questions. He told me he would be in the U.S. in a couple of months but wanted to close on the rental to make sure he would get it. I sent him an email saying I would be glad to rent it to him, but that if this deal included any thing like me cashing a big check and sending the balance back to him it was no deal. Never heard back.

The "professor at Oxford" is Craigslist's Nigerian prince.
 

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,038
12,932
113
Posted an item a month ago using old cell phone w/ WiFi phone/texting app on it as my contact number. Got text w/in 10 minutes that a guy wanted it, said he would call asap. He called we talked, told me his first name and agreed to meet in a parking lot and told each other what we would be driving. He drives up later and its guy that I know pretty well that's tailgated w/ us in starkville a couple times. Not all Craigslist transactions are scams but a bunch are. I sell alot on eBay via PayPal and have never in 10 years been burned. Had a few that never paid after buying but I never shipped either. I have read some stories on forums where people have gotten burned though i.e. sent a good iphone or whatever somewhere, buyer claimed it wasn't working and sent a totally different phone back and kept good one, crap like that and eBay sided w/ fraudulent buyer. My time will probably come though....
 

Hump4Hoops

Redshirt
May 1, 2010
6,611
13
38
Never Craigslisted but I eBay a good bit - never burned, but know some that have

With eBay/Paypal, someone can buy an item from you, claim that it's damaged, then demand a refund (you are responsible for shipping). Assuming insurance was included, your options are:

A) Agree to the refund. You pay extra shipping for the return, they damage the item themselves, and send it back to you at no cost to them. Now you're out however may dollars or hundreds of dollars because the scammer purposefully damaged the item.

B) (What they want you to do): Take the insurance claim - the insurance pays the buyer for the price they paid. They are not obligated to return the (not actually damaged) item. They keep it for free, and you're out listing/selling fees.

I'm surprised this doesn't happen more often, but it's happened to two of my friends.
 

xxxWalkTheDawg

Redshirt
Oct 21, 2005
4,262
0
25
Craigslist is a cesspool of scams

never post your number like you usually do. Scammers have programs that scan the entire site for numbers and so forth. Post you number by digit..then spell out a number... Another digit And so on.

i scan the autos for sale, bikes and ATVs, and auto parts. I have found some deals on vehicles on there, go wave cash in front of them for a better deal, send it to a detail shop, and make 500 to 1000 bucks on em. One time I actually relisted the same vehicle after having it detailed and sold it to someone in the same town I bought it in.

I never take anyone seriously as a buyer unless I speak to them. And never meet someone at a residence. If they don't come to you... Meet them in a very public place.
 

notoriousD_O_G

Redshirt
Apr 1, 2013
2,710
0
0
I sell on Craigslist quite a bit and have sold everything from a PS3 to tires. What has always worked for me is to type out the number (six six two instead of 662) and only deal through phone calls. Everyone I have ever sold to has been very nice and just as scared of getting screwed over as I was.
 

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,038
12,932
113
Hump4hoops, my return policy states "14 day money back, Buyer pays return shipping" and I havent had a problem so far. You should always request pictures too of damaged goods for insurance claims, that makes buyer think that if claim is denied then they have a useless damaged item they can't do anything about and my experience is insurance claim goes to seller who then refunds buyer through PayPal, claim isnt paid to buyer directly. I only do free shipping maybe 10% of the time too and only if its a small lite weight item or I'm making a killing on the item. I'm a "Top Rated Plus" seller for now although eBay is trying to force us all into free shipping and returns to compete w/ Amazon.
 

Kicking Bird

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
60
0
0
I recently had the same experience as the bike, but I was selling 2 upholstered chairs. The original inquiry looked legit so I sent my address. The next message said I will forward you a check and so on. Then they said my accountant made a terrible mistake and made the check out for more than we had agreed on. I never responded. A day later USPS delivered a check for $1950. The next text said I have conformation the check has been delivered. Please go to your bank and get the extra money.......I still have not responded. A day later another text that said I have conformation the check has been deposited and please forward extra money and gave an address in Palm Springs, California. I responded by saying, "The check has been deposited with the local sheriff's office. They will be working with you going forward, now 17 off".
 

Old Fart Dawg

Junior
Sep 2, 2012
1,982
273
83
I found a car real cheap on C-list, ridiculously cheap. Flags up, but I had to check it out anyway. Called the number and it turns out the car wasn't for sale. the owner told me his recently ex-girlfriend had listed the car and posted his phone number. Revenge of the beyotch
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,032
6,873
113
I fix up 80's road bikes and sell them on CL(I know, very specific hobby) and deal with the scammers all the time. Its just one of those things you have to chalk up to being part of if you want to use the service.
On a bike I just listed last week, I have had 4 people try to scam. 1 from LA, 1 from NY, 1 from FL, and 1 from who knows where.

I list my cell # as a contact option along with CL email because it makes for a lot easier communication. 2 of the scammers texted me, it just isn't tough to delete a couple texts.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 86-83 UCF: Bulldogs earn road win in fight from start to finish with Golden Knights
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 88-46 Alabama State: Bulldogs beat the Hornets in annual Kids' Day game
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times
  5. 05 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability