He was better with BOB.
I am a professional BGJ loather, but I think its fair to point out Hack under BOB had Allen Robinson.
Hack did have Godwin and Blacknell but as freshman and sophmores.
He was better with BOB.
It's the truth. Franklin is incapable of adapting his questionable coaching to the players on roster.Blaming Franklin is really a stretch.
Military forces?How about becht?
Where do you see him getting drafted?
I said this was allars best possible scenario getting with Rodgers.How Rodgers Is Helping Allar Develop
- On-field mechanics and drills. According to reports from The Athletic and NBC Sports, Rodgers frequently pulls Allar aside during practice to offer specific pointers on drill work, drop depths, footwork, and hand signals.
- Film room sessions. Allar noted that Rodgers quizzes him during film study—asking what he sees on specific plays, where his eyes are looking, and why he makes certain reads—to help speed up his processing against NFL defenses.
- System familiarity. Because Rodgers spent over a decade playing in head coach Mike McCarthy's West Coast offense in Green Bay, he has served as an extra resource helping Allar master the nuances of McCarthy's scheme.
The weapons weren't the issue--the scheme wasI am a professional BGJ loather, but I think its fair to point out Hack under BOB had Allen Robinson.
Hack did have Godwin and Blacknell but as freshman and sophmores.
I am noticing a trend with smooth brain "thinkers" on here, lol. Hack was a pure prostyle pocket passer and he fit BOB's scheme perfectly. Did he have an excellent freshmen year? No. Was it solid? Yes. He made plenty mistakes. Then you bring in a coach that has a totally different scheme and a QB coach that teaches different mechanics to fit it. Its a no brainer why Hack regressed. Rigi amazes me with his ineptitude, hence the smooth brain comment above, lol.The weapons weren't the issue--the scheme was
It's just odd people can't acknowledge scheme may have helped some QBs (Trace) it hindered others (Clifford, Allar and Hack)...I am noticing a trend with smooth brain "thinkers" on here, lol. Hack was a pure prostyle pocket passer and he fit BOB's scheme perfectly. Did he have an excellent freshmen year? No. Was it solid? Yes. He made plenty mistakes. Then you bring in a coach that has a totally different scheme and a QB coach that teaches different mechanics to fit it. Its a no brainer why Hack regressed. Rigi amazes me with his ineptitude, hence the smooth brain comment above, lol.
It's just odd people can't acknowledge scheme may have helped some QBs (Trace) it hindered others (Clifford, Allar and Hack)...
What did scheme have to do with Allar’s frequent inability to throw accurate swing passes to backs coming out of the backfield which is a problem he had his entire career at Penn State. I like the kid and I hope he has a great career in the pros. You also have a fair point about Franklin’s scheme not being idealThe weapons weren't the issue--the scheme was
A QB coach teaches different mechanics to fit the scheme. Those mechanics sometimes do not translate well with certain individuals. Its pretty simple really. The pick against ND was undoubtably a poor decision. Allar would agree, because he has said it himself. So, Allar was not fit for the scheme.What did scheme have to do with Allar’s frequent inability to throw accurate swing passes to backs coming out of the backfield which is a problem he had his entire career at Penn State. I like the kid and I hope he has a great career in the pros. You also have a fair point about Franklin’s scheme not being ideal
for Allar but not all of his problems were the result of coaching. Exhibit A was his frequent poor decision making such as throwing the pick in the ND playoff game on FIRST DOWN when the receiver was coveted.
The scheme didn’t have a damn thing to do with that decision and throw. Throwing mechanics are throwing mechanics irrespective of scheme.A QB coach teaches different mechanics to fit the scheme. Those mechanics sometimes do not translate well with certain individuals. It’s pretty simple really. The pick against ND was undoubtably a poor decision. Allar would agree, because he has said it himself. So, Allar was not fit for the scheme.
The weapons weren't the issue--the scheme was
I remember being very hesitant about Hackenberg after his freshman year. My hope was in growth for him but it didn’t happen.I am a professional BGJ loather, but I think its fair to point out Hack under BOB had Allen Robinson.
Hack did have Godwin and Blacknell but as freshman and sophmores.
You dont like the kid...when you put a kid in a bad situation with bad coaching they're going to fail. The clock speeds up because they aren't comfortable. The pick against ND was the perfect example of how Drew was broken by scheme. Like most talented QBs he forced a throw. That happens when you lack quality receivers and you put your QB in that situation. What QB hasn't forced a throw into coverage? His stats also don't support frequent bad decisions...he was so mental beaten down about undethrowing the ball intentionally and not taking chances he was playing scared. Again, McCarthy acknowledged he had to UNDO everything he learned here.What did scheme have to do with Allar’s frequent inability to throw accurate swing passes to backs coming out of the backfield which is a problem he had his entire career at Penn State. I like the kid and I hope he has a great career in the pros. You also have a fair point about Franklin’s scheme not being ideal
for Allar but not all of his problems were the result of coaching. Exhibit A was his frequent poor decision making such as throwing the pick in the ND playoff game on FIRST DOWN when the receiver was coveted.
I'd like to see Penn state make a run at GrunkO'Brien had him for 1 year--which was his best--he would have continued to improve had he received decent or real coaching
By the time he left Penn State he was broken beyond repair
You can't watch Hack as a freshman and pretend he wasn't on the right track--you can't. It's insincere.
Watch Grunk--the proof is right there. He's scared in the pocket already--it will get worse.
I'm not opposed to that. Sadly, I think he one of those guys (like Drew) that will stay loyal to James at his own detriment. Hope I'm wrong. Grunk seems like a good kid.I'd like to see Penn state make a run at Grunk
Well neither is his QB coach.Franklin is a large reason Hack didn't make it
You're right but Franklin isn't good developing QB--especially pocket passers--watch Grunk regressing
Sth bozo.Well neither is his QB coach.
Removing the mental side of it, do you think Rocco has NFL arm talent?Rocco’s issues aren’t talent related. They are decision making. He throws some inaccurate balls but what kills him are poor decisions. Can’t find holes to run, throws late, stares down receives.
Penn State doesn’t have enough resources and that ship has sailed As well. Had Aw Shucks Campbell stuck with Grunk and not blundered by bringing along his crutch last year, next season could have been special. Take it for what it is worth.I'd like to see Penn state make a run at Grunk
Who hires the QB coach and OC? Who dictates scheme?Well neither is his QB coach.
1. We have plenty of resourcesPenn State doesn’t have enough resources and that ship has sailed As well. Had Aw Shucks Campbell stuck with Grunk and not blundered by bringing along his crutch last year, next season could have been special. Take it for what it is worth.
Hopefully, if Manske is s good as advertised, next season can be pretty solid.
I just stated that decision was a poor one and that Allar said it himself. I never said that particular throw was because of poor mechanics. I am agreeing in that Allar was not a fit for the scheme. That certain type of system requires a more mobile QB, Allar was definitely not a gazelle, lol.The scheme didn’t have a damn thing to do with that decision and throw. Throwing mechanics are throwing mechanics irrespective of scheme
I highly doubt that Campbell will pursue Grunk. I agree with your take about him staying loyal to James, unfortunately. He does seem like a good kid. I would love for him to wear the blue and white again, but I think that's a pipe dream. Although, that would be absolutely hysterical stealing a guy from James, lol.I'm not opposed to that. Sadly, I think he one of those guys (like Drew) that will stay loyal to James at his own detriment. Hope I'm wrong. Grunk seems like a good kid.
It would be hysterical for sureI highly doubt that Campbell will pursue Grunk. I agree with your take about him staying loyal to James, unfortunately. He does seem like a good kid. I would love for him to wear the blue and white again, but I think that's a pipe dream. Although, that would be absolutely hysterical stealing a guy from James, lol.
I could see him at Clemson. That is if Tait Reynolds xfers out. He is from Arizona, so maybe they try to pull him away?It would be hysterical for sure
For his sake I hope he leaves and goes anywhere that would fit what he does. Arizona would be a great fit for example with Fifita leaving.
BWI Football
Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
BWI Football
Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
BWI Recruiting
Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
BWI Football
Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
BWI Football
Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph