He also got a weak arm it appears. Yesterday Ramos on second. Obviously he’s no speed demon. McNeil singles to right and they send Ramos home with no hesitation. Harper’s throw took four bounces to reach home. He missed the cut off man. I have not seen Harper enough defensively to gauge if this play is normal but last night he didn’t look like a $300 million player. Not 5 tool
Mike Trout he's not. But the Phillies needed a "franchise" (whatever that means) face to the team. At the point they changed from rebuilding to winning (last winter) they had two choices. Both very good - neither a generational talent like Trout. One wasn't interested in playing there and the other embraced them. The market determined the price at ~$300M - the Phil's paid it. You can only buy what's available.
I get the critics here saying he's overpaid and he might be now. But five years from now he likely won't be. Keep in mind that ~$300M ($330M?) is over 13 years.
Also the Phils and the fans knew what they were getting. A "franchise face" who can hit 40 HRs in that park and has a .400 OBP and can drive in and score 100 runs. He is what he is and the Phils and the fans are happy with the results. If he hits .250 I still think that's OK. As long as he shows effort he'll be fine in Philly.
Also keep in mind the Phils added Realmuto, Segura and McCutchen. Them's not scraps either.