Official '26 PSU - Rutgers game thread

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
Just because you keep saying it, doesn’t make it accurate, especially if the games don’t matter. I don’t think seeing a bad qb getting benched preventing you from getting a portal qb
It's 100% true
Rocco isn't a bad QB--he again wasn't the problem today--he had two awful games--other than that he's been, at worst, average
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
891
949
93
Reminder: Sadly, some of the same players are coming back for the 2027 season.

This program is doomed for the next 3 years minimum. It’s the least talented Penn State roster I have ever seen. Th team is slow, non-athletic, and in desperate need of more speed and difference makers.

Kraft will not survive this debacle.
Kraft has already survived longer than he should have.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
What’s 10 times worse than losing to Rutgers?
I don't understand this nonsense about thinking one loss defines anything
Smith wouldn't have kept together the 2026 class, he wouldn't have been able to recruit for 2027, we'd be behind for 2028
MC is doing well with 2028--he'll need to do well with the portal for 2027
This is all basic stuff most fan bases understand
You care way too much about 1 season
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alphalion75
Nov 1, 2021
606
656
93
Yes, the talent is lacking, but when you lose to Rutgers at home, it is not inspiring confidence in MC's ability to be successful.

You have a QB with cracked ribs and you rush 4 most of the time. Every 3rd/long you bring the house and hit him even at the cost of giving up first downs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

stater02

Senior
Dec 28, 2007
310
532
93
Paint it anyway you want. Reality is a PSU team that can’t beat Rutgers and goes 6-6 in back to back years (or maybe 7-5) generates no excitement in the fanbase. 110k aren’t showing up each week to pay for expensive seats to this **** show. We cannot afford to give CMC years to right the ship. They need a better coach, right ******* now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nittering Nabob

Nitt1300

Heisman
Nov 2, 2008
8,141
15,223
113
Paint it anyway you want. Reality is a PSU team that can’t beat Rutgers and goes 6-6 in back to back years (or maybe 7-5) generates no excitement in the fanbase. 110k aren’t showing up each week to pay for expensive seats to this **** show. We cannot afford to give CMC years to right the ship. They need a better coach, right ******* now.
no top flight coach is coming here as long as Kraft is AD
 
  • Like
Reactions: jp3272 and psuno1

psuno1

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
1,154
1,447
113
So these players are good enough to build multi-score leads late in games, but they aren’t good enough to close out games? I don’t buy that. The coaches clam up and choke,
Right on the money WestSideLion. Coaching and clock management and use of time outs are worse than Franklin I did not think that was humanly possible. One of the worse losses in PSU history.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: thegock

lion4ever76

Sophomore
Mar 24, 2023
77
135
33
You had me until you wanted to keep Terry--that would have been 10x worse
Considering how early we fired Franklin and still messed it up I don't think another year fixes that
Then with Terry you lose 2 classes instead of one because there's no way he was getting more than a year--might lose 3 classes.
Let's start from the beginning. I would have not fired Franklin early - I would have had him finish the year and see where things stood. Once they decided to fire him early and then Kraft botched the search process, keeping Terry short term gave you the opportunity to keep shopping for the right guy instead of settling on a B guy, but giving him an A guy contract. This could be a 5 year problem being locked into Campbell. It was a unique situation with Terry given his history at Penn ST, and I don't think it would have been a recruiting hit any worse than what actually went down. They needed to think a bit unconventional here and buy some time. Instead Kraft panicked and I think long term damage will be the result.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,400
1,370
113
Paint it anyway you want. Reality is a PSU team that can’t beat Rutgers and goes 6-6 in back to back years (or maybe 7-5) generates no excitement in the fanbase. 110k aren’t showing up each week to pay for expensive seats to this **** show. We cannot afford to give CMC years to right the ship. They need a better coach, right ******* now.

Oh, you didn't listen to Dr. Clown? He hired a coach who was going to show us what excellence and championship football looked like..... Dr. Clown's hire just became the first PSU team to lose to Buttgers in two decades (and record only the 3rd loss against Buttgers in PSU Football history! And the most laughable part is that it wasn't even against a good, or even mediocre, Buutgers team - we lost to a Buttgers team that came into this game 3-7 overall and 1-6 in b1g play.... and we managed to blow a 16-0 lead very late in the 2nd QTR to them. Good thing Dr. Clown is showing us what Excellence and championship football looks like.... - aren't we fortunate.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
Let's start from the beginning. I would have not fired Franklin early - I would have had him finish the year and see where things stood. Once they decided to fire him early and then Kraft botched the search process, keeping Terry short term gave you the opportunity to keep shopping for the right guy instead of settling on a B guy, but giving him an A guy contract. This could be a 5 year problem being locked into Campbell. It was a unique situation with Terry given his history at Penn ST, and I don't think it would have been a recruiting hit any worse than what actually went down. They needed to think a bit unconventional here and buy some time. Instead Kraft panicked and I think long term damage will be the result.
I can respect that...we just completely disagree on what hiring Smith would have done to the team and recruiting. His impact was overstated.
I would have still fired Franklin when we did. He lost the team but I would like to think I'd have handled the search better. Elko was still the right first target...just needed to have a better plan B. Stein IMO
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
Are you?
You seem to care more about Rutgers?
How often are you commenting about Women's Volleyball or other Penn State sports?
Most people here aren't Penn State fans or football fans--they only care about Penn State football
Yes I am. I care about losing to Rutgers, wouldn’t get too excited about beating them because we should. I also comment about PSU basketball. I don’t care about the other sports, not because it’s Penn State, but because they’re sports no one cares about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
Yes I am. I care about losing to Rutgers, wouldn’t get too excited about beating them because we should. I also comment about PSU basketball. I don’t care about the other sports, not because it’s Penn State, but because they’re sports no one cares about.
Some people care...
There's no right or wrong for fandom...whatever works for you is fine but pretending being a fan means you have to believe Penn State-Rutgers has more meaning than UCLA-Michigan or Indiana-Washington is batshit crazy
 

SouthHalls410

Senior
Oct 27, 2021
408
877
93
It’s not only football. Lady Lions basketball was a consistent top 25 team and now it’s a bottom dweller. I’m hoping the new coach can turn it around. Loved her as a player.
 

AvgUser

All-Conference
Jul 12, 2016
1,595
2,174
113
Remember when third downs used to be a problem for PSU?

Now the best defense against PSU is to go down two TDs. We will surely fold.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
How? What part of that is untrue?
You don't have to like it but it's factual
Have you ever played a sport? I've been on great teams and bad teams. Bad teams know they're bad and they understand winning doesn't matter though you always want to win--what matters is improving because hopefully that will lead to being truly relevant in the future.
I don't understand how you don't comprehend that losing this game has zero impact on anything other than it gives fans a reason to *****
I’ve played sports and coached sports…every game you play, you play to win. Saying winning doesn’t matter makes your statement non-factual.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knickslions69

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
I’ve played sports and coached sports…every game you play, you play to win. Saying winning doesn’t matter makes your statement non-factual.
Of course...you want to win. That's being a competitor.
But you know when you're eliminated from the post season.
You think NBA players on the Bucks this year don't know. You think the Dolphins players don't know. Everyone knows.
That doesn't mean you don't try or don't want to win. It also doesn't mean you're dumb enough not to understand.
 

KingoftheBigTen

Sophomore
Oct 15, 2025
100
134
32
Becht is the worst starting PSU QB of this millennium. I like CMC but blind loyalty to Becht is what basically got him in this position. Becht isn’t Purdy, not even close. You want to play that game you should have stayed in Ames. CMC doesn’t have the spine to fire Mouser or bench anyone of any real significance. Those secretly hoping PSU will make a splash at QB in the portal don’t hold your breathe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psumatt85

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
Some people care...
There's no right or wrong for fandom...whatever works for you is fine but pretending being a fan means you have to believe Penn State-Rutgers has more meaning than UCLA-Michigan or Indiana-Washington is batshit crazy
Not to a true Penn State fan. That’s like saying the FCS championship game should mean more to me than a Penn State game. Every Penn State game has more meaning to me than any other game. Why would I care who wins between UCLA-Michigan or Indiana-Washington?
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
Of course...you want to win. That's being a competitor.
But you know when you're eliminated from the post season.
You think NBA players on the Bucks this year don't know. You think the Dolphins players don't know. Everyone knows.
That doesn't mean you don't try or don't want to win. It also doesn't mean you're dumb enough not to understand.
But you still play to win. You don’t just fold up after you’re eliminated from the playoffs. I wonder why Rutgers played so hard today…hmm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
Not to a true Penn State fan. That’s like saying the FCS championship game should mean more to me than a Penn State game. Every Penn State game has more meaning to me than any other game. Why would I care who wins between UCLA-Michigan or Indiana-Washington?
lol "a true Pen State fan"
Because those game matter in the grand scheme of things. Penn State is in a sport called FBS in which a champion is crowned--that's the entire purpose of playing. Why are watching a team in that league/sport when you don't care about the sport? It's illogical.
The only actually matters is who is the champ.
The FCS champ would matter if you watch any team in FCS--and, really, you should watch that playoff--it's good football
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
But you still play to win. You don’t just fold up after you’re eliminated from the playoffs. I wonder why Rutgers played so hard today…hmm.
Of course--who said players aren't "playing to win"
We agree
Rutgers for pride--like we did
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
Not what was said...but they should all opt out of a bowl game
You’re being hypocritical again…you keep saying the only thing that matters is making the playoffs, so once you’re out all the games are meaningless, you know, just like a bowl game. So if they should opt out of bowl games because they’re meaningless, then they should opt out of all the games after three losses. At least be consistent.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
You’re being hypocritical again…you keep saying the only thing that matters is making the playoffs, so once you’re out all the games are meaningless, you know, just like a bowl game. So if they should opt out of bowl games because they’re meaningless, then they should opt out of all the games after three losses. At least be consistent.
Not once did I say "like a bowl game"
The outcome doesn't matter--that's not an opinion. That's reality. Tell me, had we won today how does that alter our season? Do we make the playoff or did we still fail to achieve our goal?
I already explained the obligation part--same as in the NFL when you have a contract. The NFL won't tolerate it.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
lol "a true Pen State fan"
Because those game matter in the grand scheme of things. Penn State is in a sport called FBS in which a champion is crowned--that's the entire purpose of playing. Why are watching a team in that league/sport when you don't care about the sport? It's illogical.
The only actually matters is who is the champ.
The FCS champ would matter if you watch any team in FCS--and, really, you should watch that playoff--it's good football
In the grand scheme of things, no game really matters, but the ones that do matter are the ones you have a vested interest in…you know, like the school where you attended and/or are a fan of. The rest don’t really matter in the grand scheme of things. If Penn State isn’t the champ, then I really don’t care who is, so why should I care who wins or loses the other games?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
In the grand scheme of things, no game really matters, but the ones that do matter are the ones you have a vested interest in…you know, like the school where you attended and/or are a fan of. The rest don’t really matter in the grand scheme of things. If Penn State isn’t the champ, then I really don’t care who is, so why should I care who wins or loses the other games?
The entire reason to play, as a competitor you get this, is to win a title
The games that impact who wins the title are relevant hence the expanded playoff creates more games with meaning
If you don't care if Penn State doesn't win then why are you discussing the sport?
You don't like college football then which explain the ridiculous comments you're making
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,485
6,221
113
Not once did I say "like a bowl game"
The outcome doesn't matter--that's not an opinion. That's reality. Tell me, had we won today how does that alter our season? Do we make the playoff or did we still fail to achieve our goal?
I already explained the obligation part--same as in the NFL when you have a contract. The NFL won't tolerate it.
8-4 is better than 7-5 which is better than 6-6. That alters your season. And I never said you said like a bowl game, but if they both don’t matter, then they are the same…see how that works?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psumatt85

RTRMR

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2018
12
9
3
This team will never never, never never never never never never ever ever ever ever ever never never never ever ever ever never ever be better than 8-4, with this clueless moron, Campbell as our coach! He should’ve been fired after the Wisconsin game!
WE ARE……NOT EVEN MEDIOCRE !!!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nittering Nabob

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,487
4,860
113
8-4 is better than 7-5 which is better than 6-6. That alters your season. And I never said you said like a bowl game, but if they both don’t matter, then they are the same…see how that works?
How does it alter your season? It's still a failure--we're not grading on a curve here
You're confusing "matter" with "meaning"
They matter--they're part of the season and your contract to play--a bowl game isn't--it's after the semester. We've discussed this multiple times. Contract law
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Tony Rojas leads Penn State's defense, undecided on future
  2. 02 BWI Football 7 things I think after Penn State's stunning loss to Rutgers: Matt Campbell and co., have a big problem on their hands
  3. 03 BWI Football Everything Matt Campbell said after Penn State's loss to Rutgers
  4. 04 BWI Football What did Rutgers coach Greg Schiano, Penn State players, say about the Scarlet Knights' upset win?
  5. 05 BWI Football Why did Zion Tracy not play on Saturday, and what did Matt Campbell think of the Penn State defense without him?