News today

dtrain79

Heisman
Jul 13, 2006
49,289
28,025
113


What is he talking about? None of the narrative on Ukraine from the fringe right is true.

There were protests in Kyiv about Yanukovich’s attempt to reorient Ukraine towards Moscow (pretty far into his term). Government forces shot a bunch of protestors and Yanukovich fled while the Ukrainian Parliament voted overwhelmingly to remove him. I am unsure how this was a coup.

I do think Putin decided that Ukraine was leaving his orbit and took Crimea as to avoid losing it to a Western looking Ukraine. He’d have probably gotten away with it had he not invaded Ukraine proper.

And of course, Zelenskyy won his election against Yanukovich’s successor (the more pro-Western candidate). Z is a Russian speaker and won his biggest margins in the places Russia invaded.
 

Uncoach

Heisman
Dec 8, 2011
7,928
11,716
113
I believe they said that publicly.

I don't think JD was totally wrong on Iran. The way they executed with no real plan to eliminate the IRGC is not something I would endorse either. Trump should have seen he couldn't just remove the IRGC like the Venezuelan leadership. Trump was also pretty clear he didn't want the boots on the ground or the civilian casualties it would take to remove them. So, unless you are a leader that can build a coalition to do those things(Trump clearly is not), this conflict was flawed from jump.

I assume JD sat in the pre-attack meetings and decided this was a bad idea for the administration.

Iran could still end in a good place, but I doubt it. Ya, they were greatly diminished, but their bad leaders were replaced with other bad leaders. And the Rs were wiped out with some help from the Mullahs being ideologically stubborn and wanting to hurt the US with new dipsh*t leadership in congress. Just look at what they said about the US post election. This was way better than any pain they could inflict onto the US on the battlefield.

In hindsight, JD was right imo.
You made a good point about not having much of a plan. If the situation was actually dire, I understand not having a deeply thought out plan of removal, much like stonedhead has no plan for cranial RFBE. Our military wiped out everything. The halting for negotiation was lame. To your point they needed to arm the Kurds and somehow arm the civilians. Tall task. So get in with the air strikes, get out and come up with a strategy where the Iranian people could have to opportunity to overthrow the IRGC/mullahs. Plenty of criticism from different angles. My only criticism at the time and still is, Trump came back to the Monroe Doctrine in a big way. Cuba should have been next, not Iran. This wasn’t ever going to be a forever war like Iraq, so the comparison isn’t quite the fit of OJ’s glove, but just as Bush blew any capital/good will by going into Iraq, Trump has done the same by how the Iran conflict has been executed.
 

Uncoach

Heisman
Dec 8, 2011
7,928
11,716
113
Cotton assumes Trump is willing to do what it takes to win the conflict. He is not. Assuming a victory is to remove the Mullahs that insist on having Nukes for mass casualty events.

Their military is wiped out. Their economy is in shambles. These are good outcomes, but...

The IRGC is still in charge and they hate us worse than they already did.
The IRGC can’t hate us any more than they already did. They have been at war with the US since they took power in 1979.
 

stoneaxe27

All-American
Sep 22, 2006
6,098
6,792
113
The IRGC can’t hate us any more than they already did. They have been at war with the US since they took power in 1979.
They hate us much more. The great majority of them were not alive in 1979 their hatred was an abstract idea. They have now lived thru the bombing killing of their leaders, twice over, the bombing of civilian sites and the killing of children, and the economic stranglehold.
 

ILisBest

All-American
Jun 16, 2007
8,095
6,592
113
The IRGC can’t hate us any more than they already did. They have been at war with the US since they took power in 1979.
I agree we were already "the great satan" to them, but their current variety of crazy leadership may want a large reconing at some point. The US will need to keep the economic pressure on to completely topple any hope of short term economic recovery. Hopefully that will be combined with some overthrow event. I am starting to doubt that will happen, especially now the loons in congress will be trying to stop us for them.
 
Orange and Blue News

Latest

  1. 01 Orange and Blue News Illinois vs. Iowa: Behind Enemy Lines with Hawkeye Report
  2. 02 Orange and Blue News Andrej Stojakovic scores 46 at Duke, breaking a Cameron record that stood since 1957
  3. 03 Orange and Blue News Recap: Illinois ends Duke’s 35-game home streak with historic rout at Cameron
  4. 04 Orange and Blue News How Tomislav Ivisic’s expanded offensive game could test Duke’s frontcourt
  5. 05 Orange and Blue News Illinois vs. Duke: Why Brad Underwood embraces a tough nonconference schedule