NCAA burden of proof??

Barry MuCockinher

All-Conference
Nov 10, 2010
1,581
1,310
36
I'm curious, say this ledger is the only piece of "tangible evidence" tying any player to Andy Miller &being paid. Can the NCAA enforce any punishment if this is all they have to go on? If they're not able to find any bank statements, phone records, etc linking our guys to ASM/ being paid..... is there an outlet in the rules that allow them to come down on UK? Or will the NCAA be forced to simply change rules and nothing more? Thoughts.
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
Or say it is tangible evidence that he reported these as expenses but they are fraudulent and part of a tax fraud case. Just one reason why I would love to know just what the FBI is investigating.
 
A

anon_9qtxg60vqzy0y

Guest
I'm curious, say this ledger is the only piece of "tangible evidence" tying any player to Andy Miller &being paid. Can the NCAA enforce any punishment if this is all they have to go on? If they're not able to find any bank statements, phone records, etc linking our guys to ASM/ being paid..... is there an outlet in the rules that allow them to come down on UK? Or will the NCAA be forced to simply change rules and nothing more? Thoughts.
They allowed Katina Powell's college ruled notebook with handwritten entries as evidence.
 

AU Tebow

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2016
2,440
4,537
113
They can do anything they want. They aren't a legal entity, don't have to prove anything if they don't want. They've taken kids eligibility with zero proof, just because the kid couldn't prove it didn't happen.
Yup. That’s exactly what happened with Austin Wiley this year. Person told the fake agent he gave money to Wiley’s family, there was absolutely no other evidence or proof (unlike our other suspended player Purifoy). Yet, ncaa said since we couldn’t PROVE his family never got money, he’s out for the year.

Just the way it works.
 

bluejesus

Sophomore
Nov 25, 2009
78
122
0
Or say it is tangible evidence that he reported these as expenses but they are fraudulent and part of a tax fraud case. Just one reason why I would love to know just what the FBI is investigating.

The FBI doesn't care about the NCAA or whether players are receiving money..that's not illegal in the real world...what the FBI is looking for are signs of people paying to steer kids towards particular agents to sign....that's bribery...they say it's a reach to do that but the little man in robes will decide that.
 

ib4ky_rivals111873

All-Conference
Dec 18, 2005
1,323
2,302
113
They allowed Katina Powell's college ruled notebook with handwritten entries as evidence.

Don't forget pictorial evidence..........
 

Barry MuCockinher

All-Conference
Nov 10, 2010
1,581
1,310
36
They allowed Katina Powell's college ruled notebook with handwritten entries as evidence.
Yes but that wasn't the only evidence correct. They had phone records and wire payments from Mcgee correct? Plus testimony from collegiate athletes involved.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,678
2,362
113
They can do anything they want. They aren't a legal entity, don't have to prove anything if they don't want. They've taken kids eligibility with zero proof, just because the kid couldn't prove it didn't happen.
They have to follow their internal rules. Although that could mean that they have a rule that states the earth is flat and refer to it as the Kyrie Irving clause. If they don't follow the Kyrie Irving clause they could get sued. :alien:
 

eppsfan

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2010
826
1,508
0
Depends on who the burden of proving is against. The burden for a Duke or UNC is much higher than for anyone with an Italian name or associated with a guy that goes by initials like www.
 

Blueworld_3.0

Heisman
Sep 23, 2008
14,138
11,272
113
I think in UofL's case there was also some records of wire transfers and bank withdrawals where the amounts corroborated what Katina Powel claimed was paid. NCAA also interviewed several recruits that backed up her story as well.
Now, the FBI may have wiretaps of agents talking to recruits or coaches (like RP at UofL) but, there is nothing that says they have to share those with the NCAA.
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
They have to follow their internal rules. Although that could mean that they have a rule that states the earth is flat and refer to it as the Kyrie Irving clause. If they don't follow the Kyrie Irving clause they could get sued. :alien:

Has a member institution ever successfully sued the NCAA? Individuals have been successful but few if any member institutions have been. It seems the NCAA is considered a benevolent despot where those institutions are concerned. They are not held to due process or following precedent.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,678
2,362
113
Has a member institution ever successfully sued the NCAA? Individuals have been successful but few if any member institutions have been. It seems the NCAA is considered a benevolent despot where those institutions are concerned. They are not held to due process or following precedent.
The NCAA's rules do not require due process or precedent. A school could sue and possibly win if the NCAA does not follow its own rules although they could be told to use the NCAA's internal procedures to have the rule changed. Schools would probably not sue but if they are a state school they would just have the state government sue like in Penn State's case.

The NCAA is the schools. It is a private firewall for them to do business. Even though every school that is part of the NCAA receives government money in some form the NCAA is still a private entity which I think is a massive joke.
 

TCHooSier

Junior
Sep 1, 2001
119,926
223
0
I'm curious, say this ledger is the only piece of "tangible evidence" tying any player to Andy Miller &being paid. Can the NCAA enforce any punishment if this is all they have to go on? If they're not able to find any bank statements, phone records, etc linking our guys to ASM/ being paid..... is there an outlet in the rules that allow them to come down on UK? Or will the NCAA be forced to simply change rules and nothing more? Thoughts.

The NCAA won't have to prove up anything ... the FBI will do it for them. The FBI has the power to compel testimony and the production of documentation. They will get the evidence for the NCAA and the same will eventually be part of the public record.
 

Spanish Radio

All-Conference
Moderator
Nov 18, 2004
3,678
2,362
113
The NCAA won't have to prove up anything ... the FBI will do it for them. The FBI has the power to compel testimony and the production of documentation. They will get the evidence for the NCAA and the same will eventually be part of the public record.
Only if the FBI is interested. They are not investigating NCAA rules violations.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Listen to KSR's Pregame Show before Kentucky vs. Mizzou
  2. 02 KSR A Brief History of Weird Football Between Kentucky and Missouri
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR DJ Miller will play homecoming game against Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Football Underdogs have owned Kentucky vs. Missouri series