Yet many feel - and perhaps rightly so - that he left the most talented roster in MSU football history. How'd he do that?
(1) He wasn't as bad as people say. He hated recruiting and it's hard to be great at anything you hate, but he wasn't awful.
(2) Recruiting is just as much if not more about assistant coaches. His biggest limitation was that b/c he hated recruiting, he accepted some less than stellar efforts from assistants in his inner circle, and he let Hevesy be Hevesy (although I think that was just as much a tradeoff for coaching ability). That said, we are extremely lucky Buckley swooped in and picked up Reese. We constantly played with fire with OL recruiting. Landing Reese and Eiland, both of whom were solid as RS freshmen, saved us from disaster.
(3) He and the staff were good at player development outside of WR. Part of this was I think they were a good evaluator of not just talent but character. The only character risks we took were for high ceiling guys. Basically Nick James, the Morton DL whose name escapes me, Justin Cox, Nick Brassel (not that he was ever really coming), a couple of the JUCO transfers. I don't think Simmons was really ever a character risk, but I'm also not sure we let him come to campus as a three star. There may be some I'm forgetting but we've had a pretty tame group.