MSU ranked #10 in CFB pre-season?

Hanmudog

Redshirt
Apr 30, 2006
5,853
0
0
Seriously? I want whatever they are smoking. I think we will make a lower tier bowl and win about 7 games but top 10? I don't even want to do that to myself again with the expectations.
 

Seinfeld

All-American
Nov 30, 2006
11,769
8,215
113
Wow, I'm gonna have to read through all the details of this when I have more time tonight, but it seems like there are three problems at the surface level

1) His recruiting weighted average gives the most weight to current class which doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Unless you're Bama, the current class isn't going to do much for you this season

2) Any ranking that has us listed with the 8th most returning production in the country has to be questioned. Even if you want to somehow say that the offense is a wash after losing Fitz, we lost a crapload on defense

3) Even though nearly all polls do it, I don't like like any ranking that uses historical performance as a metric. Every year is different for every team
 

GTAT

Redshirt
Jan 23, 2019
399
0
0
S&P doesn't project your record, it's more of a 'strength' indicator.

And he's usually more accurate than the rest.

Some jump on him for saying we'd go 7-5 in 2016 (he does project ranking a little later on in the year, in the individual preview). People forget we lost 3 games (USA, BYU, UK) that we had no business losing.
 

bulldognation

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2004
3,837
1,653
113
Maybe Moorhead's YEAR-2 is supposed to be like Howland's YEAR-4. Doesn't it work that way? Hey commentators... am I doing it right?
 

ShrubDog

Redshirt
Apr 13, 2008
5,307
3
38
We looking to win 6-7 games next year and don’t have a QB. Ummmm ok
 

GTAT

Redshirt
Jan 23, 2019
399
0
0
2) Any ranking that has us listed with the 8th most returning production in the country has to be questioned. Even if you want to somehow say that the offense is a wash after losing Fitz, we lost a crapload on defense
In hindsight, I'm just glad Mullen left when he did, rather than leaving after 2018. This way, JoMo was able to work hard and secure the 2018 and 2019 classes, which Mullen would not have done. He also signed some key pieces in the trenches, which Mullen had no interest in doing. I think our high would have been better in 2018, but our fall in 2019 and 2020 would have been lower, and Mullen ultimately would have been fired after that season.

I don't know if JoMo will work out long term but I'm just glad that a motivated warm body was in that spot rather than Mullen, who at the time, had an attitude and wanted nothing to do with the program any longer.
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
Excellent points

Wow, I'm gonna have to read through all the details of this when I have more time tonight, but it seems like there are three problems at the surface level

1) His recruiting weighted average gives the most weight to current class which doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Unless you're Bama, the current class isn't going to do much for you this season

2) Any ranking that has us listed with the 8th most returning production in the country has to be questioned. Even if you want to somehow say that the offense is a wash after losing Fitz, we lost a crapload on defense

3) Even though nearly all polls do it, I don't like like any ranking that uses historical performance as a metric. Every year is different for every team

Especially point #1. It should be a weighted where the class your seniors are in should have the most weight going down to the most recent.
 

Old Fart Dawg

Junior
Sep 2, 2012
1,982
273
83
We have a returning letterman who has started 2 games and won both.
Plus 2 more qbs who will challenge him.
Patience young padawan
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,518
3,094
113
That's enough proof to show they don't have a clue. If they turn out to be right I will be more than happy to apologize.
 

Go Budaw

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
7,321
0
36
We have a returning letterman who has started 2 games and won both.
Plus 2 more qbs who will challenge him.
Patience young padawan

And in 1 of those 2 games he outdueled a Heisman Trophy winner and current NFL starter....while under the direction of a career running backs coach.
 

LilSebastian

Redshirt
Sep 13, 2012
175
0
0
I think it’s worth stating that the guy who wrote the algorithm was befuddled by State being so high.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,500
2,503
113
If Key is better than Fitz this year, and he should be, I expect this year's team to be better. Other than the DL, the talent is equally as good and we have some highly rated guys on the DL, they just haven't played yet.

I think we're 9-3 if Key is an above average QB.
 

OliveBranchDAWG

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
643
0
0

Obviously, I don’t expect us to finish #10 this season. Our defense will take a slight step back, but not as big as most believe. But to have a team coming off 8 wins and a few close losses, our fan base 17ing blows right now.

I say 8-4 again. I have my concerns about Moorhead, but bottom line is if he can figure out how to score points this year we’ll be pretty good. Our schedule sets up well for us.

Everyone on this board is so violatile. I don’t think we’ll win 10+ games but let’s relax and hope for a good season, I think 8-9 wins is attainable
 

jdbulldog

Junior
Oct 27, 2007
2,594
368
83
In hindsight, I'm just glad Mullen left when he did, rather than leaving after 2018. This way, JoMo was able to work hard and secure the 2018 and 2019 classes, which Mullen would not have done. He also signed some key pieces in the trenches, which Mullen had no interest in doing. I think our high would have been better in 2018, but our fall in 2019 and 2020 would have been lower, and Mullen ultimately would have been fired after that season.

I don't know if JoMo will work out long term but I'm just glad that a motivated warm body was in that spot rather than Mullen, who at the time, had an attitude and wanted nothing to do with the program any longer.

JoMo wasted one of the best defenses in MSU history. Mullen wins 11 games last year and we are in the hunt for a playoff berth. Probably we fall short but it would have been fun to find out. Mullen was going to leave sooner than later for sure but he was much more dialed into the program than some thought. JoMo has a lot to prove.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  3. 03 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Biggest rankings risers in the updated 2027 Rivals300 rankings