Most impressive win in IHSA history?

Kevin JCHS 1981

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
240
174
43
You could make the argument that it wasn't even the most impressive win of the night with MC coming back from down 30.

When i read the thread title I assumed it was going to be about mt carmels win.
If the thread was titled " the Most impressive comeback" Mt Carmel is definitely a top contender, but it was almost equally impressive how they almost managed to dig themselves a whole of "no return" with one of the most talented teams (on paper) ever to grace an IL high school football field (supposedly).

So when Mt Carmel causes their own problems on a Historic Scale and then subsequently keeps the ship from sinking, really all that impressive as a team win. I guess it's how you look at it.

I think we can all agree that Mt Carmel will be a much more dangerous opponent after surviving their attempt at their own demise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FishingandFootball

UIUC 17

Freshman
Sep 20, 2018
82
60
15
One of the most impressive and unexpected. CG and Fenwick beating ESL were also impressive, but this one takes it imo since it was between teams separated by multiple classes. Another game that comes to mind is IC beating St Laurence in a season where St Laurence was a 6A semifinalist
 

DirtySixThirty

Redshirt
Aug 20, 2026
114
45
28
One of the most impressive and unexpected. CG and Fenwick beating ESL were also impressive, but this one takes it imo since it was between teams separated by multiple classes. Another game that comes to mind is IC beating St Laurence in a season where St Laurence was a 6A semifinalist
Are you thinking of the time IC beat them like 63-49?
 
  • Like
Reactions: UIUC 17

Anon430504

Freshman
Jul 13, 2026
132
83
28
1982 Reavis 25 ESL 13. Reavis was coming off back to back state runner ups where the Defense didn’t give up a single point. Reavis lost to Sandburg 28-27 in OT that year. ESL rolled Sandburg 52-10 in round 1. Reavis barely escaped a 6-3 Thornton team 19-12 with a late pass interference. ESL went to Burbank & Reavis got some turnovers & won then won state!!! Nobody thought they could win
 

Wittymoniker1

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2007
5,473
1,869
113
Is this specific team considered one of the top Rochester's teams compared to their rich and impressive history?
 

Colin2299

Junior
Aug 13, 2025
522
352
63
It's still a long way to Week 14.

Having said that, the current Junior and Senior classes are among the strongest in program history. Great balance of skill players and bigger than usual OL/DL.
Watching the highlights their defense is what stood out. Very physical too.

Rochester’s defense doesn’t get the attention they deserve because of how good their offense is but it’s always very good.
 

Colin2299

Junior
Aug 13, 2025
522
352
63
You could make the argument that it wasn't even the most impressive win of the night with MC coming back from down 30.
No you can’t.

What was the messy predictions for both games? MC opponent also didn’t have their HC.
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,101
2,741
113
This is a really good win for Rochester, but it is high school football, and maybe Batavia just isn’t that great.

We can revisit this in November if Batavia makes a deep run
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

PowerI66

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
820
695
93
This is a really good win for Rochester, but it is high school football, and maybe Batavia just isn’t that great.

We can revisit this in November if Batavia makes a deep run
I would say it was a combination of Batavia playing probably as bad as it will and Rochester playing really well.
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,693
9,578
113
1982 Reavis 25 ESL 13. Reavis was coming off back to back state runner ups where the Defense didn’t give up a single point. Reavis lost to Sandburg 28-27 in OT that year. ESL rolled Sandburg 52-10 in round 1. Reavis barely escaped a 6-3 Thornton team 19-12 with a late pass interference. ESL went to Burbank & Reavis got some turnovers & won then won state!!! Nobody thought they could win
I was thinking Granite City in 1986, when East Side had a 40+game streak and was defending national champs. The Hogan Twins took them down! Then Althoff beat GC two weeks later ... mayhem, I tell ya!
 

DR.Eireog

Junior
Nov 26, 2025
143
200
43
I was thinking Granite City in 1986, when East Side had a 40+game streak and was defending national champs. The Hogan Twins took them down! Then Althoff beat GC two weeks later ... mayhem, I tell ya!
I remember meeting a guy from Granite City back in the mid 80’s. I wasn’t the worldly man I am now. I honestly had never heard of the place. When he told me Granite City was in Illinois, I nearly passed out with shock. His twang was something I figured from the Deep South. Oh and he was a white guy.
He told me that GC was a soccer power. I had barely heard of soccer being played in Illinois. Eireog is a much more in touch fella nowadays😂
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,693
9,578
113
He told me that GC was a soccer power. I had barely heard of soccer being played in Illinois. Eireog is a much more in touch fella nowadays😂
STL has always been a hotbed for footie, and even more granularly, Granite City and Collinsville were hot pockets in the market.

Granite City (10 State Titles)
Granite City holds the Illinois state record for the most boys soccer state championships. Most of these were won during the era when the district was split into two schools (Granite City South and Granite City North).
  • 1972–73: Granite City (The inaugural IHSA State Champion)
  • 1976–77: Granite City South
  • 1977–78: Granite City South
  • 1978–79: Granite City South
  • 1979–80: Granite City South
  • 1980–81: Granite City South
  • 1982–83: Granite City South
  • 1987–88: Granite City (Schools consolidated back into one)
  • 1989–90: Granite City
  • 1990–91: Granite City
Collinsville (4 State Titles)
The Kahoks established themselves as a powerhouse, frequently battling their rivals in Granite City during deep postseason runs.
  • 1981–82: Collinsville (Won after knocking out Granite City South in the sectionals)
  • 1986–87: Collinsville
  • 1991–92: Collinsville
  • 1992–93: Collinsville
 

DR.Eireog

Junior
Nov 26, 2025
143
200
43
STL has always been a hotbed for footie, and even more granularly, Granite City and Collinsville were hot pockets in the market.

Granite City (10 State Titles)
Granite City holds the Illinois state record for the most boys soccer state championships. Most of these were won during the era when the district was split into two schools (Granite City South and Granite City North).
  • 1972–73: Granite City (The inaugural IHSA State Champion)
  • 1976–77: Granite City South
  • 1977–78: Granite City South
  • 1978–79: Granite City South
  • 1979–80: Granite City South
  • 1980–81: Granite City South
  • 1982–83: Granite City South
  • 1987–88: Granite City (Schools consolidated back into one)
  • 1989–90: Granite City
  • 1990–91: Granite City
Collinsville (4 State Titles)
The Kahoks established themselves as a powerhouse, frequently battling their rivals in Granite City during deep postseason runs.
  • 1981–82: Collinsville (Won after knocking out Granite City South in the sectionals)
  • 1986–87: Collinsville
  • 1991–92: Collinsville
  • 1992–93: Collinsville
Eireog tells lies but not about this. A few years later ‘88 a guy named Roy Houghton from Ireland scored a goal against England in the European championships tournament to beat those other guys. Eireog was now a casual soccer fan. I remain a very casual soccer fan. I watch the World Cup every 4 years.
 
  • Love
Reactions: crusader_of_90

all4theillini

All-Conference
Jul 23, 2004
43,869
4,287
62
I realize it only took place last night but Rochester running clock W over Batavia has to be in the discussion for most impressive wins in IHSA history..no?

4a vs the #1 team in 7a with what was being talked about as their best team of the Piron era.

Game Highlights
🤣🤣🤣every year is “supposed” to be the greatest Batavia team of the Piron era🤣🤣🤣
 
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Lincoln Way Central
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Bolingbrook Raiders
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football New: The 3rd and Leng Podcast
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Watch: WJOL Pigskin Preview Tonight
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Rivals300 recruits give Nebraska high marks after weekend trip to Lincoln