*****Montana St vs Iowa Game Thread*****

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
I think it just looks really bad bc they missed so many 3s.

They either convert even 33% or they take less threes and convert to 2pt field goals and they win by 10-15 more than they did.

Besides that, the steals were the only thing that concerned me. But they were averaging 18 coming into this game.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
Who? Do you mean MSU?
Miguel And Tulio GIF
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wobmam Rulez!

citizenHawk1

All-Conference
Jul 10, 2025
450
1,110
93
A lot to take away from this game. Definitely things going on that need a lot of coaching, and I assume the film might help the coaches as well.

If you can't shoot, and can't get a ball to the post, when you play a fouling team, you have to take the ball to the rim and get to the line. This Montana St. team would have fouled every time. The team needs work going up to the basket without stopping in the lane.

A competitive press can only help the team, so it was great to get that. They can learn a lot there. Every player.

What to make of Dani Carnegie? Idk. She's better than this.
 

SoonerBeAHawk

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2005
577
1,179
93
I am continually amazed at Journey's ability to rebound in a crowd, plus she is pretty good at chasing down loose rebounds. Amari is pretty good at both as well.

But Dani, not sure what she's good at. Her defense is pretty poor too, seems to lack effort. As poorly as Strem is shooting the 3-ball, she still should be playing ahead of Dani at this point, imo.
 

hawkod

All-Conference
Iowa Swarm member
Apr 5, 2007
624
1,939
93
Dani Cargegie....woof. I know she's seen pressure having played in the SEC, but she is so loose with the basketball.
So far this year Amari has been the better pick up in the portal; her defense >>> Dani's.
Montana State is a good team. Good pressure by them the entire game, plus they never got rattled.
The last two games have taught us (I hope) the value of being ready to play from the opening tip.
 
Last edited:

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,740
16,079
113
I am continually amazed at Journey's ability to rebound in a crowd, plus she is pretty good at chasing down loose rebounds. Amari is pretty good at both as well.

But Dani, not sure what she's good at. Her defense is pretty poor too, seems to lack effort. As poorly as Strem is shooting the 3-ball, she still should be playing ahead of Dani at this point, imo.
I agree with all of this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoonerBeAHawk

IowaCityLit

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2025
1,802
2,883
113
Yes my son.
You gotta have and maximize talent at Iowa JJ has to figure this out.

DC was a 1st team all Sec player. Look
At the coach. Look at players excelling without JJ.

TS is a PG. she was 1-5 from the field and missed all her 3s. She was the playmaker tonight with 9
Assists. But Iowa has to figure out how to maximize DC talent. Or they will just flounder.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,740
16,079
113
You gotta have and maximize talent at Iowa JJ has to figure this out.

DC was a 1st team all Sec player. Look
At the coach. Look at players excelling without JJ.

TS is a PG. she was 1-5 from the field and missed all her 3s. She was the playmaker tonight with 9
Assists. But Iowa has to figure out how to maximize DC talent. Or they will just flounder.
And?? DC was 3-10 and 1-7 from 3. She had 7 turnovers in 22 minutes against only 1 assist!! She was a liability on defense. She was the only player on the floor with a negative +/- in a game they won by 16! The offense has looked better pretty much every time she's been off the floor. They dismantled Vanderbilt without her. She needs to get herself right. Maybe coming off the bench can help her get there.
 

KurtWarner

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2025
1,218
3,103
113
I am continually amazed at Journey's ability to rebound in a crowd, plus she is pretty good at chasing down loose rebounds. Amari is pretty good at both as well.

But Dani, not sure what she's good at. Her defense is pretty poor too, seems to lack effort. As poorly as Strem is shooting the 3-ball, she still should be playing ahead of Dani at this point, imo.
I'm with ya, Houston is everywhere, getting rebounds, loose balls and such. Always around the ball and seems to be a step ahead and knowing where it's going. Amari has been great these last couple of games, she has become more assertive and has some game
 

Hawkfan_08*

Heisman
Jul 2, 2025
4,011
10,452
113
Well. That was a horrible game.

Same problems at the ft line and abysmal from 3.

Journey Houston continues to be an incredible asset to this team. Ava ended with 15 rebounds. Taylor sounds like she was everywhere. Whiting, while not hitting the 3, does a lot on both ends. MW is making an immediate impact.

They just have to see the ball go in.
 

SoonerBeAHawk

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2005
577
1,179
93
You gotta have and maximize talent at Iowa JJ has to figure this out.

DC was a 1st team all Sec player. Look
At the coach. Look at players excelling without JJ.

TS is a PG. she was 1-5 from the field and missed all her 3s. She was the playmaker tonight with 9
Assists. But Iowa has to figure out how to maximize DC talent. Or they will just flounder.
I don't think anyone is saying give up on Dani but right now she's stinking the joint up. I hope she can turn it around but presently she's a liability. Would have hoped as a junior the good/very good Stremlow would be more present, but between her and DC one of 'em has gotta figure it out. TS is closer right now to that, imo.
 

MVPFAN

Senior
Mar 10, 2003
3,288
911
113
I think Jan has done a lot of good things so far and I haven't questioned the defensive effort and hustle for her teams but the sloppy play had got to stop. The only one on the team who seems somewhat in control is Amari. The bad passing has been a yearly epidemic. It's ugly basketball and you don't get to the elite level of college basketball with turnovers, bad 3 point shooting and bad FT shooting. Carnegie is terrible with ball security and she shoots too much. Jan either needs to find ways to coach improvement in these areas or get players with better basketball IQ. Playing time needs to be adjusted downward for people turning it over. There needs to be accountability for this bad play in both practices and games. Whatever she has been doing to address this it hasn't worked. Evidently the players think it's acceptable to continue the same sloppy play game after game.
 

citizenHawk1

All-Conference
Jul 10, 2025
450
1,110
93
But she's not right now and hasn't been for much of these first 6 games. The offense looks broken whenever she's in there. How much longer does this go on before you consider bringing her in off the bench to shake things up?
I'm all about the thought that the team plays better with Stremlow on the court---regardless of the other 4. She's the engine and heart.

Even so, with regard to Dani, we are talking All-SEC. Whatever is not right, has to get right if this team hopes to het anywhere in conference play. It could be coaching, could be mental, could be mental on the court. Unheard of for a player that has played at an elite level to transfer and regress to the bench. They need to figure this out.

Didn't Hannah Stuelke have a slow start last season after missing summer practice with USA Basketball? Maybe there really is a problem with this for some reason.) I might be misremembering.

In any case, they need to focus on the ceiling, so best figure it out. --->and practice team free throws while they stumble through it.
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
But she's not right now and hasn't been for much of these first 6 games. The offense looks broken whenever she's in there. How much longer does this go on before you consider bringing her in off the bench to shake things up?
This is why my opinion in the beginning of the thread should be the Vanderbilt starters
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,740
16,079
113
I'm all about the thought that the team plays better with Stremlow on the court---regardless of the other 4. She's the engine and heart.

Even so, with regard to Dani, we are talking All-SEC. Whatever is not right, has to get right if this team hopes to het anywhere in conference play. It could be coaching, could be mental, could be mental on the court. Unheard of for a player that has played at an elite level to transfer and regress to the bench. They need to figure this out.

Didn't Hannah Stuelke have a slow start last season after missing summer practice with USA Basketball? Maybe there really is a problem with this for some reason.) I might be misremembering.

In any case, they need to focus on the ceiling, so best figure it out. --->and practice team free throws while they stumble through it.
I don't know what the answer is, but what if you can't get her right? Do you simply continue getting off to slow starts because the offense operates like shat with her on the floor? This was Montana State, not Ohio State or Michigan St, and she was a negative plus/minus tonight.

I feel like we're having an EmRod moment right now. Here's a player that has more than enough physical talent, but her head seems to be stuck in this place where her primary motivation is how many shots she can launch in an attempt to rack up points vs how can she help the team. In short, she's the complete opposite of Stremlow, CCW, Whiting, and Journey. If that's her mindset then she needs to produce. If she can't, then she's a huge negative and she needs to sit.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,107
8,721
113
I don't know what the answer is, but what if you can't get her right? Do you simply continue getting off to slow starts because the offense operates like shat with her on the floor? This was Montana State, not Ohio State or Michigan St, and she was a negative plus/minus tonight.

I feel like we're having an EmRod moment right now. Here's a player that has more than enough physical talent, but her head seems to be stuck in this place where her primary motivation is how many shots she can launch in an attempt to rack up points vs how can she help the team. In short, she's the complete opposite of Stremlow, CCW, Whiting, and Journey. If that's her mindset then she needs to produce. If she can't, then she's a huge negative and she needs to sit.
I didn't watch her play at Georgia. You do have to wonder if the all SEC thing was a function of her doing her own thing so she put up the numbers. That may not be working out with a team that celebrates the assist as has been Iowas culture. I do know Jans vision of the 4 out offense doesn't look so pretty when were shooting 20-24% for the season from 3 as a team. Even when we drive and get fouled we miss about 40% of our free throws.
 
  • Like
Reactions: citizenHawk1

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,740
16,079
113
I didn't watch her play at Georgia. You do have to wonder if the all SEC thing was a function of her doing her own thing so she put up the numbers. That may not be working out with a team that celebrates the assist as has been Iowas culture. I do know Jans vision of the 4 out offense doesn't look so pretty when were shooting 20-24% for the season from 3 as a team. Even when we drive and get fouled we miss about 40% of our free throws.
Yeah. I don't know. The shooting so far is inexplicable. Dani's 3 point percentage is down over 10 and Stremlow's is down over 20. Dani's FT% is down 20 points as well. What could have possibly happened between last season and now to drive these percentages down like that?
 

Tom Paris

Heisman
Oct 1, 2001
144,885
21,213
113
I'm all about the thought that the team plays better with Stremlow on the court---regardless of the other 4. She's the engine and heart.

Even so, with regard to Dani, we are talking All-SEC. Whatever is not right, has to get right if this team hopes to het anywhere in conference play. It could be coaching, could be mental, could be mental on the court. Unheard of for a player that has played at an elite level to transfer and regress to the bench. They need to figure this out.

Didn't Hannah Stuelke have a slow start last season after missing summer practice with USA Basketball? Maybe there really is a problem with this for some reason.) I might be misremembering.

In any case, they need to focus on the ceiling, so best figure it out. --->and practice team free throws while they stumble through it.
Not starting Carnegie wouldn’t fix the issue. It would probably make it worse. She’s gotta play her way out of it. As far as lack of 3 point shooting, I’m going to keep bringing up the fact that Jan didn’t offer a kid from right down the road, who’s already shooting over 46% from 3 for Arizona State.
 

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,484
18,059
113
Having 7 TOs in 22 minutes for a non point guard is unheard of.
And this is the kind of situation that can spiral quickly.
Outside of the Vandy game, this team hasn't looked prepared.
The staff has three games to figure it out before Nebraska. We'll see if they're up to the task?
 

IowaCityLit

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2025
1,802
2,883
113
Teagan was a bad fit. Averaging 18 pts a game

Addie was a bad fit. Averaging 15 pts a game.

Emily was a bad fit. Averaging 14 pts a game.

Now Dani is a bad fit and should be benched in favor of (name your favorite).

How many more bad fits and underutilization of talent before it’s JJs fault? Because it is.

Id keep an eye on MW.
 

o_Terrykohawk

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2002
712
1,720
93
Teagan was a bad fit. Averaging 18 pts a game

Addie was a bad fit. Averaging 15 pts a game.

Emily was a bad fit. Averaging 14 pts a game.

Now Dani is a bad fit and should be benched in favor of (name your favorite).

How many more bad fits and underutilization of talent before it’s JJs fault? Because it is.

Id keep an eye on MW.
Teagan was not a bad fit. She left for personal reasons that we all sympathize with. Addie could have fit if she would have taken a different approach
Emily was a bad fit but the athleticism made her a reasonable gamble.
Dani is in her own head IMO. Trying to live up to the rep she brought from Georgia. I think she will adjust but we do have other options
 

AFM22

Heisman
Oct 31, 2022
23,917
45,962
113
Teagan was a bad fit. Averaging 18 pts a game

Addie was a bad fit. Averaging 15 pts a game.

Emily was a bad fit. Averaging 14 pts a game.

Now Dani is a bad fit and should be benched in favor of (name your favorite).

How many more bad fits and underutilization of talent before it’s JJs fault? Because it is.

Id keep an eye on MW.
Dani Carnegie has a career 15.2 ppg/41%fg and is currently averaging 14.2ppg/44%

🙄
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball Top takeaways from the Hawkeyes win over Montana State
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball PHOTO GALLERY: Iowa Women's Basketball vs Montana State
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Game Preview: Iowa at Illinois
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Tip Time Preview: Iowa at Xavier
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football The Friday Five