Michigan State: Our protected rivals?

lou v

All-Conference
Staff member
Aug 27, 2004
18,208
3,463
98
Why are we playing them every year (for the foreseeable future)? Should we start playing for a trophy?

MSU is in the East division, you know. So NU won't play them every year; it will depend on the crossover games.
 

freewillie07

Junior
Aug 22, 2017
5,367
220
48
My understanding is the Big Ten paired up teams based on their average conference finish over a certain period of time.

That's why Illinois gets Rutgers ever year. :p

Off the top of my head, I believe the others are:

Nebby-OSU
Wisconsin-Michigan
Iowa-PSU
Minnesota-Maryland
Purdue-Indiana
 

lou v

All-Conference
Staff member
Aug 27, 2004
18,208
3,463
98
My understanding is the Big Ten paired up teams based on their average conference finish over a certain period of time.

That's why Illinois gets Rutgers ever year. :p

Off the top of my head, I believe the others are:

Nebby-OSU
Wisconsin-Michigan
Iowa-PSU
Minnesota-Maryland
Purdue-Indiana

Wow, Nebraska drew the short straw there. Good luck with that matchup every year.
 

lou v

All-Conference
Staff member
Aug 27, 2004
18,208
3,463
98
MSU is in the East division, you know. So NU won't play them every year; it will depend on the crossover games.

Weren't each of the teams assigned a team from the other division that they played several years in a row, Lou? Thought I read that somewhere.

You are correct. That slipped my mind...along with a lot of other things.
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,226
453
83
I hope with all my heart that we win convincingly over msu saturday. But then, I want to see msu beat convincingly psu and osu! They already zapped michigan. Of all the teams in the east, I dislike msu the least. At least they aren't primadonna megalomaniacs like they other outfits competing for the top spot. D'Ant runs a humble, blue-collar outfit. Typical for the Detroit area where I was born. So let's go Cats and win Saturday! The rest of the games I watch msu play vs the usual suspects, I will root for msu.
 

lou v

All-Conference
Staff member
Aug 27, 2004
18,208
3,463
98
I hope with all my heart that we win convincingly over msu saturday. But then, I want to see msu beat convincingly psu and osu! They already zapped michigan. Of all the teams in the east, I dislike msu the least. At least they aren't primadonna megalomaniacs like they other outfits competing for the top spot. D'Ant runs a humble, blue-collar outfit. Typical for the Detroit area where I was born. So let's go Cats and win Saturday! The rest of the games I watch msu play vs the usual suspects, I will root for msu.

I was born and raised in Detroit too, mick. I knew there was something I liked about you.

MSU has become my favorite non-NU Big Ten team over the years. As you said, they are a tough, blue collar team. I just like the way they play. I’ve always admired Dantonio and think he’s a helluva coach. He may get more out of the talent he gets than anyone in the country.

However, there have been some bad off-the-field shenanigans going on in East Lansing over the last year or so, and they’ve had far too many arrests. They look to have regained their footing on the gridiron; I hope it extends to other areas too.
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,226
453
83
I was born and raised in Detroit too, mick. I knew there was something I liked about you.

MSU has become my favorite non-NU Big Ten team over the years. As you said, they are a tough, blue collar team. I just like the way they play. I’ve always admired Dantonio and think he’s a helluva coach. He may get more out of the talent he gets than anyone in the country.

However, there has been some bad off-the-field shenanigans going on in East Lansing over the last year or so, and they’ve had far too many arrests. They look to have regained their footing on the gridiron; I hope it extends to other areas too.

Wow! Another Detroit native! Almost all my relatives on both sides of the family work currently for Ford or did while they were alive. I was born in Henry Ford hospital downtown. One of my friends from my NU days went to Wayne State for medical school after graduating from NU. I grew up living with my grandmother about two blocks from Greenfield Village just outside of Detroit in Dearborn. I have been selfishly hoping for NU to go to the Little Ceasars bowl at Ford field (is that what it is called now?). That way, I could stay at the Dearborn Inn with my wife and show her all the hotspots around town. I hear it is getting better in Detroit with the better economy. They are knocking down (or burning them down via "hell's night") abandoned buildings and replacing them with urban farms and trees. I hear they put in a bid for the Amazon hqs too- gosh, wouldn't it be wild if the got it? I know msu had some problems with some of his players too. I hope they can clean up their program too!
 

BattleCat43

Redshirt
Aug 20, 2001
6
0
0
Why are we playing them every year (for the foreseeable future)? Should we start playing for a trophy?

My understanding of how they do the sked with a 14 team league is each team is paired with a cross division 'rival' over a six year span, while going home and away with the other six teams in the other division over the same time frame. Our pair up in this rotation just happens to be MSU. the only one that is protected and plays yearly is Indiana/Purdue, the other 6 pairings switch out at the 6 year mark based on parity and perpection of the programs and/or league preferences (get the big names together most often)
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,928
1,555
113
My understanding is the Big Ten paired up teams based on their average conference finish over a certain period of time.

That's why Illinois gets Rutgers ever year. :p

Off the top of my head, I believe the others are:

Nebby-OSU
Wisconsin-Michigan
Iowa-PSU
Minnesota-Maryland
Purdue-Indiana
And IL can't even beat them
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,226
453
83
Well put, although I think you mean "good teams". Maryland is pretty benign

Maryland most likely would have been a top four team in the east without the qb injuries. Wasn't Kasim Hill our top target for the qb of the future? I dislike Maryland more than msu. Sorry, but it is true. It was very delightful to win the game against MD this year.
 
Last edited:
Sep 10, 2015
763
79
0
My understanding of how they do the sked with a 14 team league is each team is paired with a cross division 'rival' over a six year span, while going home and away with the other six teams in the other division over the same time frame. Our pair up in this rotation just happens to be MSU. the only one that is protected and plays yearly is Indiana/Purdue, the other 6 pairings switch out at the 6 year mark based on parity and perpection of the programs and/or league preferences (get the big names together most often)

It's interesting to consider who will be our next cross-division match-up. In the past 5 years, NU's 37 wins are closest to Michigan (40) and Penn State (40). Michigan State, despite last year's 3 win season, has been better than both of those programs during the same timeframe with 46 wins.

It could work to our advantage if OSU (61 wins) is matched up with Wisconsin (49 wins) for a 6 year period. Here's how the divisions would match up based on the last 5 years of complete seasons. Note: MD & RU records come partially from pre-B1G affiliation.

1. Wisconsin (49) v OSU (61)
2. Nebby (43) v MSU (46)
3. Iowa (39) v Penn State (40)
4. Northwestern (37) v Michigan (40)
5. Minnesota (37) v Rutgers (29)
6. Illinois (20) v Maryland (27)
7. Purdue (15) v Indiana (27)

Does anyone know when the next cross-conference foes will be selected?
 

DkeCat

Senior
Jan 14, 2002
4,041
445
68
Wow! Another Detroit native! Almost all my relatives on both sides of the family work currently for Ford or did while they were alive. I was born in Henry Ford hospital downtown. One of my friends from my NU days went to Wayne State for medical school after graduating from NU. I grew up living with my grandmother about two blocks from Greenfield Village just outside of Detroit in Dearborn. I have been selfishly hoping for NU to go to the Little Ceasars bowl at Ford field (is that what it is called now?). That way, I could stay at the Dearborn Inn with my wife and show her all the hotspots around town. I hear it is getting better in Detroit with the better economy. They are knocking down (or burning them down via "hell's night") abandoned buildings and replacing them with urban farms and trees. I hear they put in a bid for the Amazon hqs too- gosh, wouldn't it be wild if the got it? I know msu had some problems with some of his players too. I hope they can clean up their program too!

What high schools? Was at Country Day for my senior year (they had athletic scholarships in high school believe it or not) and lived in Southfield.
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,226
453
83
What high schools? Was at Country Day for my senior year (they had athletic scholarships in high school believe it or not) and lived in Southfield.

Dearborn High- just off of Telegraph. I finished off at Fremd in Palatine, Illinois. What sport did you play? Did you ever go drinking in Windsor with your buddies? I have some great memories of going with mine!
 
Last edited:

rmndcat

Junior
Sep 4, 2009
2,871
300
83
I hope with all my heart that we win convincingly over msu saturday. But then, I want to see msu beat convincingly psu and osu! They already zapped michigan. Of all the teams in the east, I dislike msu the least. At least they aren't primadonna megalomaniacs like they other outfits competing for the top spot. D'Ant runs a humble, blue-collar outfit. Typical for the Detroit area where I was born. So let's go Cats and win Saturday! The rest of the games I watch msu play vs the usual suspects, I will root for msu.
I agree about MSU being more sympathetic than Mich, OSU or PSU. I don't care about Indy. I used to live in DC, so I kinda like the Terps. Rutgers, I feel sorry for...like I would for the Illini, except the Illini are jerks.
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,226
453
83
I agree about MSU being more sympathetic than Mich, OSU or PSU. I don't care about Indy. I used to live in DC, so I kinda like the Terps. Rutgers, I feel sorry for...like I would for the Illini, except the Illini are jerks.

The biggest game of the season for me is the one against the Illini. My best friend went there and pisses orange all over me when the Illini beat NU. I heard the bs all summer up until now about how Illini beat Nu bball twice last season. I really hope we humble the orange in late Nov this year again for football and then this winter for bball. I weird thing about it is that I actually like their football coach, Lovie. I met him in person at the Lou Malnati's in Elk Grove, Illinois a few years ago. Very nice person. We chit-chatted for about five minutes and then I let him eat his pizza with his entourage. Underwood on the other hand and 98% of the Illini fans I could easily do without though. Let's go Cats!
 

Alaskawildkat

Senior
Dec 28, 2005
20,869
648
113
I was born and raised in Detroit too, mick. I knew there was something I liked about you.

MSU has become my favorite non-NU Big Ten team over the years. As you said, they are a tough, blue collar team. I just like the way they play. I’ve always admired Dantonio and think he’s a helluva coach. He may get more out of the talent he gets than anyone in the country.

However, there have been some bad off-the-field shenanigans going on in East Lansing over the last year or so, and they’ve had far too many arrests. They look to have regained their footing on the gridiron; I hope it extends to other areas too.

Wow! Another Detroit native! Almost all my relatives on both sides of the family work currently for Ford or did while they were alive. I was born in Henry Ford hospital downtown. One of my friends from my NU days went to Wayne State for medical school after graduating from NU. I grew up living with my grandmother about two blocks from Greenfield Village just outside of Detroit in Dearborn. I have been selfishly hoping for NU to go to the Little Ceasars bowl at Ford field (is that what it is called now?). That way, I could stay at the Dearborn Inn with my wife and show her all the hotspots around town. I hear it is getting better in Detroit with the better economy. They are knocking down (or burning them down via "hell's night") abandoned buildings and replacing them with urban farms and trees. I hear they put in a bid for the Amazon hqs too- gosh, wouldn't it be wild if the got it? I know msu had some problems with some of his players too. I hope they can clean up their program too!

Even this far off Alaska kid had some Detroit ties. It was at my uncle and aunt's home there that I first saw TV. That was back in 1953 on our family's road trip to Alaska. On that same trip we visited the Ford Museum which I believe was in or near Greenfield Village. In 1964 when I was headed to the National Boy Scout Jamboree with my fellow Alaskan scouts our train stopped in the area so we could catch a tour of the factory where Mustangs were being manufactured. My cousins living in Detroit ended up going to MSU and I visited them there while a student myself at Northwestern. I came away with a new appreciation for McCulloch Hall as it was a more intimate size than MSU's skyscraper dorms.
 
Last edited:

Deeringfish

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2008
22,360
2,140
63
It's interesting to consider who will be our next cross-division match-up. In the past 5 years, NU's 37 wins are closest to Michigan (40) and Penn State (40). Michigan State, despite last year's 3 win season, has been better than both of those programs during the same timeframe with 46 wins.

It could work to our advantage if OSU (61 wins) is matched up with Wisconsin (49 wins) for a 6 year period. Here's how the divisions would match up based on the last 5 years of complete seasons. Note: MD & RU records come partially from pre-B1G affiliation.

1. Wisconsin (49) v OSU (61)
2. Nebby (43) v MSU (46)
3. Iowa (39) v Penn State (40)
4. Northwestern (37) v Michigan (40)
5. Minnesota (37) v Rutgers (29)
6. Illinois (20) v Maryland (27)
7. Purdue (15) v Indiana (27)

Does anyone know when the next cross-conference foes will be selected?
6 years is too long in college football.
 

ricko6543211

Junior
Nov 15, 2006
4,236
239
47
It's interesting to consider who will be our next cross-division match-up. In the past 5 years, NU's 37 wins are closest to Michigan (40) and Penn State (40). Michigan State, despite last year's 3 win season, has been better than both of those programs during the same timeframe with 46 wins.

It could work to our advantage if OSU (61 wins) is matched up with Wisconsin (49 wins) for a 6 year period. Here's how the divisions would match up based on the last 5 years of complete seasons. Note: MD & RU records come partially from pre-B1G affiliation.

1. Wisconsin (49) v OSU (61)
2. Nebby (43) v MSU (46)
3. Iowa (39) v Penn State (40)
4. Northwestern (37) v Michigan (40)
5. Minnesota (37) v Rutgers (29)
6. Illinois (20) v Maryland (27)
7. Purdue (15) v Indiana (27)

Does anyone know when the next cross-conference foes will be selected?
Probably for whenever they make the schedules for 2022 onward, so like 2019 or 2020, if the conference structure is even the same then...

Yours is a reasonable methodology, though I'd imagine they wouldn't run back the Iowa PSU matchup or repeat any others (with the exception of protecting Indiana Purdue which is part of the reason this whole thing is in place anyways). So using your methodology I think Iowa would get Mich and us PSU.

I do think if divisions stay unchanged (far from certain) they would pair Wisconsin w OSU for the next cycle. Illinois prob gets the next worst on Rutgers / non Indiana team so Maryland is right. That leaves Minny with Rutgers.

Then it's Nebraska Iowa NU with some combo of MSU Mich PSU. I suspect they'd do Nebraska Mich cause of "tradition" and perceived TV matchups, and then Iowa and us trade partners so they'd get Sparty and we get PSU maybe. Mich would be the next most logical partner for us though, perhaps followed by Maryland.

But lots of other factors could change or come into play between now and then. Not the least of which is the quality of our team's performance on field.
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,888
892
73
Maryland most likely would have been a top four team in the east without the qb injuries. Wasn't Kasim Hill our top target for the qb of the future? I dislike Maryland more than msu. Sorry, but it is true. It was very delightful to win the game against MD this year.

I don't know about that. Their defense was pretty awful.
 

iskaboo

Sophomore
Aug 23, 2011
1,817
150
63
It's interesting to consider who will be our next cross-division match-up. In the past 5 years, NU's 37 wins are closest to Michigan (40) and Penn State (40). Michigan State, despite last year's 3 win season, has been better than both of those programs during the same timeframe with 46 wins.

It could work to our advantage if OSU (61 wins) is matched up with Wisconsin (49 wins) for a 6 year period. Here's how the divisions would match up based on the last 5 years of complete seasons. Note: MD & RU records come partially from pre-B1G affiliation.

1. Wisconsin (49) v OSU (61)
2. Nebby (43) v MSU (46)
3. Iowa (39) v Penn State (40)
4. Northwestern (37) v Michigan (40)
5. Minnesota (37) v Rutgers (29)
6. Illinois (20) v Maryland (27)
7. Purdue (15) v Indiana (27)

Does anyone know when the next cross-conference foes will be selected?
Your analysis is good, but wouldn't the Big Ten use conference records rather that overall records to rank the teams?
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
22,020
2,180
113
There is sort of a pile of something at the bottom of the conference
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Northwestern outmatched by Virginia Tech in 87-70 loss
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Fearless Forecast: Northwestern vs. Minnesota
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Behind Enemy Lines: Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Grades Analysis
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota