I'll do it.
Don't like starting off with a run up the middle play.
Come on John you can do better than this:
![]()
Let's hope that Ash is so successful that, in 2020, he moves on to a new HC gig and McNulty stays on to be the new HC.
Turtleneck. Would not hire.Looks really young for all that experience.
![]()
You do not choose your OC based on recruiting..you choose the guy who will have the most productive offensethe Good;
1.Is a veteran,Been threw the NCAA recruiting and Coaching wars.
2.Knows the NJ landscape and Political NJ BS football wise and HS wise..
3. Knows Rutgers Football Culture.
5.Has NFL background ,can relate that to kids trying to make the league.
The Unknown Side(possible downside)
1. Seems to historically run the pro set which right now does NOT fit the Ru talent base.
2.Pro set does not attract speed based athlete types(ACC type recruits).
3. Is NOT a big push upwards as an impact for recruiting.
Ash still needs to improve the staff for Recruiting. If he was smart,still bring in Carty,and replace Jafarr with Acosta.
You do not choose your OC based on recruiting..you choose the guy who will have the most productive offense
I don' t understand those that feel we must have a spread OC. We aren't loaded with spread players. The offense must fit the talent not the other way around.
4) And he has coached the spread: "He also helped Marcus Mariota develop in the spread offense as the quarterbacks coach for the Tennessee Titans in 2014-15."I'll take a stab:
1) it's what HC Chris Ash has wanted from Day 1: not a pure "spread" but a "power spread"...
2) it's what we HAVE recruited for the last 2 classes and continue to recruit for....
3) do you honestly want to attempt a pro-style O in the B1G, especially the B1G east, with the talent we can hopefully recruit?
No I'm looking for an old style pro but the talent on the field the last two years didn't fit a complete spread offense either. You have to fit an offense to who is on the field not who was recruited and is sitting on the bench.I'll take a stab:
1) it's what HC Chris Ash has wanted from Day 1: not a pure "spread" but a "power spread"...
2) it's what we HAVE recruited for the last 2 classes and continue to recruit for....
3) do you honestly want to attempt a pro-style O in the B1G, especially the B1G east, with the talent we can hopefully recruit?
Yeah, I wouldn't put a whole lot of stock in that one year. They went 3-13 and Ken Wisenhut got fired halfway through the season.4) And he has coached the spread: "He also helped Marcus Mariota develop in the spread offense as the quarterbacks coach for the Tennessee Titans in 2014-15."
http://beta.latimes.com/sports/chargers/la-sp-chargers-mcnulty-rutgers-20180111-story.html
Graystork! What's up, my brother!Like it. I liked the way he called a game. And god knows our quarterbacks could use some instruction.
Agree and I think McNulty will be able to run a spread that can incorporates pro set moves in it that takes advantage of the talent Ash has recruited the last two years and Flood's leftovers.I'll take a stab:
1) it's what HC Chris Ash has wanted from Day 1: not a pure "spread" but a "power spread"...
2) it's what we HAVE recruited for the last 2 classes and continue to recruit for....
3) do you honestly want to attempt a pro-style O in the B1G, especially the B1G east, with the talent we can hopefully recruit?
Except:Yeah, I wouldn't put a whole lot of stock in that one year. They went 3-13 and Ken Wisenhut got fired halfway through the season.
No I'm looking for an old style pro but the talent on the field the last two years didn't fit a complete spread offense either. You have to fit an offense to who is on the field not who was recruited and is sitting on the bench.
Great research and great post!Except:
http://thetimes-tribune.com/sports/...itans-mariota-through-rookie-season-1.1985433
"Despite the Titans’ 3-10 record, Mariota has been a bright spot. Even though he missed two games with a knee injury, he has completed 62.4 percent of his passes (227 for 364) for 2,786 yards, 19 touchdowns and just 10 interceptions. He has shattered the franchise’s single-season rookie records for completions, passing yards and touchdowns. Inside the red zone, Mariota has league’s second-best passer rating at 116.1 — he trails Detroit’s Matthew Stafford (118.6) — with 15 touchdowns and no interceptions."
Indeed, the Titans are very young team on offense. Besides Mariota, three other rookies start and up to seven rookies could be on the field at a given time.
Still, four of the Titans’ 10 losses have been by six points or fewer.
Mariota credits McNulty for what he has been able to accomplish thus far in his rookie season.
“He’s helped my growth tremendously and made me a better player,” Mariota said. “I’m thankful to have him as a coach.
“He’s helped me prepare for (different) defenses and coverages week in and week out. Going into every game, I feel very confident knowing that he’s helped put me in position to be ready.”
When the Titans were going through the pre-draft process of whether to select Mariota, McNulty said three things kept coming up: Character, intelligence and poise.
[Backup QB] Mettenberger, in his second season out of LSU, agrees.
“Johnny Mac, he’s the man. He makes it fun to go to work every day,” Mettenberger said. “It’s enjoyable to be in meetings. We have a business-like approach, but at the same time we have fun and laugh. I’m very appreciative what he’s done for me and my career so far. I’m sure Marcus would say the same.”
Agree and I think McNulty will be able to run a spread that can incorporates pro set moves in it that takes advantage of the talent Ash has recruited the last two years and Flood's leftovers.
I look for a better QB production with improved WR play with John's experience coaching both of those positions.
The #free ( name QB) posts might be a thing of the past with the way McNulty handles Gio, Lewis and Sitkowski and helps Williams devolop the WRs better based on John's experience as a WR coach in the pros and his early college coaching years as a WR coach
There is still a lot to fix. We'll see. I am cautiously optimistic. He needs to have free reign on offense. If he wants to go for it on 4 th and 1 or 2 (or 12), it should be his call.Great research and great post!
There is still a lot to fix. We'll see. I am cautiously optimistic. He needs to have free reign on offense. If he wants to go for it on 4 th and 1 or 2 (or 12), it should be his call.
We won't go pro styleAgree but we're going to have an absolute shitload of those kids as frosh, r-frosh, and sophs in 2018. No way should we go full pro-style, again, if that's what we're STILL recruiting for, right?
Who would you have pass for us the past few years? Which QB and which receivers?The best coaching decision that Ash could have done for the RU community is resign. He’s clueless about the pass. Passing is required to win unless you have the option attack like the Service Academy. Ash is incompetent about offense. Two years of the worst offense in America provided everyone with evidence except for Hobbs who keeps making wild, irresponsible decisions about coaching contracts. The ineptness continues. Happy New Year.
The best coaching decision that Ash could have done for the RU community is resign. He’s clueless about the pass. Passing is required to win unless you have the option attack like the Service Academy. Ash is incompetent about offense. Two years of the worst offense in America provided everyone with evidence except for Hobbs who keeps making wild, irresponsible decisions about coaching contracts. The ineptness continues. Happy New Year.
The reason the football program hasn’t been good for years is because in the first place, there was way too much support for Flood throughout his tenure—when he should never should have been considered for the head coaching position. And now there is almost universal support for a head coach who has led the worst (almost the worst) offense in the NATION for 2 years and an AD who has put long-term faith in a coach of a team that unfortunately is at—with the exception of Illinois—the bottom. What has Ash proven thus far for such universal unwavering support? A “five year building plan” to “resurrect RU football” is unacceptable for a big10 program that was playing competitive football not long ago and going to bowl games. Pernetti’s hire of Flood, Prez Bob’s hire of Julie, Hobbs’ hire of Ash, Hobbs’ wild spending on men’s basketball and football coaches who have not been to 1 post season game... how many additional mistakes can we make??? It is laughable. More to come. I guess you prefer enduring the basement and maintaining support vs demanding change because you can’t tolerate seemingly endless ineptitude. End of my comments on this. I’m not going to waste time on Rah Rah defense of everything that is done by RU athletics when our winning percentage on our in-conference games (all-sports) was recently stated publicly to be 19 per cent. I guess we are doing something right by losing 80 per cent of our athletic contests. You and I are die hard fans of RU...but we could never see eye to eye on basically any issue related to Rutgers Athletics. I’ve been involved with RU athletics for over 50 years...seems you have to...but we are polar opposites on everything.
shove your new year straight up your ***. Ash went out and got a solid wr/qb specialist as his OC. Not sure what else you want. Your post was as devoid of fact and full of empty airheaded opinion as anything else on here.The best coaching decision that Ash could have done for the RU community is resign. He’s clueless about the pass. Passing is required to win unless you have the option attack like the Service Academy. Ash is incompetent about offense. Two years of the worst offense in America provided everyone with evidence except for Hobbs who keeps making wild, irresponsible decisions about coaching contracts. The ineptness continues. Happy New Year.
True of whomever was named OC, but how long after McNulty's first play call in the intra-squad game does a poster make a complaint about the call. Vegas has established its even money the post will be made before the play is run.
Don't waste your time.Dear Lord I’ll read this tomorrow lol
The Knight Report
Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
The Knight Report
Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
The Knight Report
Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
The Knight Report
How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
The Knight Report
Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod