Malik Newman to Kansas

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,660
36,396
113
Ugh. He could be nasty by the time he plays. I'm hoping he tests the waters again after his sit-out year and enters the draft. Wouldn't surprise me at all actually.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ukfan041

brdmn22

Junior
Apr 21, 2004
788
201
0
I really don't get why Newman was ranked so highly. Don't get me wrong, he's a very good player, but not an elite top 10 talent. He's essentially an undersized, one dimensional shooting guard. He's above average from 3, but he's not even elite at that, and that's what he does best.

I've only seen him play a handful of times, but he's never impressed me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cawood86_rivals

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
I really don't get why Newman was ranked so highly. Don't get me wrong, he's a very good player, but not an elite top 10 talent. He's essentially an undersized, one dimensional shooting guard. He's above average from 3, but he's not even elite at that, and that's what he does best.

I've only seen him play a handful of times, but he's never impressed me.

Why did Cal covet him so much then the first time around?
 

BlueRattie_rivals

All-Conference
Feb 6, 2014
1,052
1,943
0
I personally love the whole "they don't trust each other" garbage his dad is shoveling.

Newman wants Howland to "Trust" him to be the absolute focal point of the offense--period. Same old ****. If you don't let me do whatever I want, then you don't "trust me". We dodged a bullet with this kid.
 

cardsfan53

Junior
Apr 15, 2005
5,659
225
0
I think he was just the best of a not so impressive group of guards in last years class. Beside Murray, who was without question the best, the rest of those guys are 4 year guys IMO.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Because it was a mediocre/bad class, and he was after him before Murray became available.

Didn't he commit before Cal went after Murray? Also, it was a down year, but in retrospect, I wouldn't call it terrible. Most of the top 30 had pretty good freshman seasons. Was it a down year in respect to one and done talent? Maybe. I think the number of kids now a days who think they are one and done is inflated anyways in every year.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
I think he was just the best of a not so impressive group of guards in last years class. Beside Murray, who was without question the best, the rest of those guys are 4 year guys IMO.

Looking strictly at WG/PG's in last year's top 30:

Newman
Briscoe
Trier
Thornton
Blakeney
Bacon
Brunson
Jalen Adams
Kennard
Dorsey
Dozier
Juwan Evans
Donovan Mitchell
Justin Simon

That's a pretty good class and those kids had good freshman years.
 

dckala2_rivals16641

All-Conference
Aug 3, 2006
18,541
4,026
0
So he doesn't make grades at msu, but gets into Kansas? Lol, but cal is cheating. Shoo wee they might go for 15 straight conference titles and hang a meaningless banner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ukfan041

MNantz

Heisman
Dec 20, 2001
9,086
11,921
98
Yes ole Bill has already started whining to all who will listen what a great kid he is , and he speaks seven languages and after all the hardship he has been through well it's just a travesty for him to have to sit out a year !! Yep ole honest Bill lol
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Looking strictly at WG/PG's in last year's top 30:

Newman
Briscoe
Trier
Thornton
Blakeney
Bacon
Brunson
Jalen Adams
Kennard
Dorsey
Dozier
Juwan Evans
Donovan Mitchell
Justin Simon

That's a pretty good class and those kids had good freshman years.

Pretty weak group, IMHO.

Not even close to the last group:

Mudiay
Russell
Jones
Ulis
Booker
Allen
Hamilton
Blackmon
Pinson
Berry

And the bigs were nonexistent. Labissiere, Diallo, and Zimmerman were at or near the top of the rankings and how did their seasons and draft night's go?

You see why Murray reclassified and why Maker jumped into this draft.

Weak, weak class. Only the big wings (Simmons, Ingram, Brown) saved it from being a total train wreck.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Pretty weak group, IMHO.

Not even close to the last group:

Mudiay
Russell
Jones
Ulis
Booker
Allen
Hamilton
Blackmon
Pinson
Berry

And the bigs were nonexistent. Labissiere, Diallo, and Zimmerman were at or near the top of the rankings and how did their seasons and draft night's go?

You see why Murray reclassified and why Maker jumped into this draft.

Weak, weak class. Only the big wings (Simmons, Ingram, Brown) saved it from being a total train wreck.

Agree to disagree. Other than Booker, Ulis and Allen, I think the classes are similar. I don't care about NBA potential, I care about college potential.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
So he doesn't make grades at msu, but gets into Kansas? Lol, but cal is cheating. Shoo wee they might go for 15 straight conference titles and hang a meaningless banner.

Is that public record? Maybe he pulled a Simmons thinking he would get into the NBA. He has 4 summer sessions and two full semesters to get eligible before he will suit up for an actual game.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
This solidifies KU's backcourt for 2017-18, IMHO. They have an experienced Senior PG in Graham (I don't think he enters the draft), plus Newman.

They could be very good in 2017-18. I look for them to lose Bragg along with Mason and Lucas graduating, but returning their underclassmen. I think they add Ayton, since they have been on him the most. I could also see them getting a guy like Sexton at guard. They could have a good mix of talent and experience:

Starters

G Graham(6'2 SR)
G Newman(6'3 SO)
G Mykhailiuk(6'8 SR)
F Ayton(7'0 FR)
C Azubuike(7'0 SO)

Key Reserves

G Sexton(6'2 FR)
G Vick(6'5 SO)
F Lightfoot(6'10 SO)

They probably add another big in this class as well. If not they could be pretty thin inside behind Ayton (assuming they get him) and Azubuike. If they miss on Ayton or he is ineligible, then they are in trouble.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Agree to disagree. Other than Booker, Ulis and Allen, I think the classes are similar. I don't care about NBA potential, I care about college potential.

???

I thought we were talking about talent, not college success.

By your reasoning, Graham is better than Booker because at least Graham has started in college, Booker couldn't even get off the bench.

You are entitled to your opinion, it's just hard for me to wrap my brain around your reasoning.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
???

I thought we were talking about talent, not college success.

By your reasoning, Graham is better than Booker because at least Graham has started in college, Booker couldn't even get off the bench.

You are entitled to your opinion, it's just hard for me to wrap my brain around your reasoning.

In his one year at Kentucky, Booker averaged 10 ppg and shot 41% from 3 and 47% from the field. Solid college production. He is now gone and never played another game at Kentucky.

Last year Graham averaged 11.1 ppg and shot 44% from three and 46% from the field and will continue to improve and play for KU.

Booker is clearly more talented, but Kentucky never got to reap the rewards of it. KU will reap the rewards of Graham's talent.
 

TrustinCal

Senior
Feb 7, 2014
1,384
918
0
This solidifies KU's backcourt for 2017-18, IMHO. They have an experienced Senior PG in Graham (I don't think he enters the draft), plus Newman.

They could be very good in 2017-18. I look for them to lose Bragg along with Mason and Lucas graduating, but returning their underclassmen. I think they add Ayton, since they have been on him the most. I could also see them getting a guy like Sexton at guard. They could have a good mix of talent and experience:

Starters

G Graham(6'2 SR)
G Newman(6'3 SO)
G Mykhailiuk(6'8 SR)
F Ayton(7'0 FR)
C Azubuike(7'0 SO)

Key Reserves

G Sexton(6'2 FR)
G Vick(6'5 SO)
F Lightfoot(6'10 SO)

They probably add another big in this class as well. If not they could be pretty thin inside behind Ayton (assuming they get him) and Azubuike. If they miss on Ayton or he is ineligible, then they are in trouble.

No. Haven't you heard Svi went pro last year as a 17 year old.

Also, Ayton ain't going to Kansas.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
In his one year at Kentucky, Booker averaged 10 ppg and shot 41% from 3 and 47% from the field. Solid college production. He is now gone and never played another game at Kentucky.

Last year Graham averaged 11.1 ppg and shot 44% from three and 46% from the field and will continue to improve and play for KU.

Booker is clearly more talented, but Kentucky never got to reap the rewards of it. KU will reap the rewards of Graham's talent.

That's some flawed logic right there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UK till Death

anon1763419335

All-American
Feb 10, 2006
23,231
5,077
113
In his one year at Kentucky, Booker averaged 10 ppg and shot 41% from 3 and 47% from the field. Solid college production. He is now gone and never played another game at Kentucky.

Last year Graham averaged 11.1 ppg and shot 44% from three and 46% from the field and will continue to improve and play for KU.

Booker is clearly more talented, but Kentucky never got to reap the rewards of it. KU will reap the rewards of Graham's talent.

but these are fake rewards right? like kenpom rankings?
 

brdmn22

Junior
Apr 21, 2004
788
201
0
Why did Cal covet him so much then the first time around?
I don't know, I'm not Cal - you should probably ask him that. Maybe he was the best of a bad bunch. Maybe Cal thought he'd be better. Believe it or not, but Cal sometimes misses on evaluating players. It could be a number of reasons, but I'm not the one to answer that.

All I know is that Newman isn't an elite player. Could he be? Sure, I guess it's possible, but I don't see it. Again, I've seen him a number of times and the only reason I even paid any attention to him was because he was ranked so highly - it certainly wasn't because of his performance.
 

anon1763419335

All-American
Feb 10, 2006
23,231
5,077
113
That's some flawed logic right there.

this is what happens when you have disappointing run after disappointing run. you start making no sense and changing the bar in order to justify yourself. ku fans are becoming ul fans in mindset. now its about "college production". wouldnt be hard to find some kid from a mid major that puts up 17 a game and wins his conference. guess that means that guy is the better college player.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
Why did Cal covet him so much then the first time around?

I don't think Cal did. Cal moderately recruited him. But I think Cal saw what some of us saw, that Newman was a me-first player, a volume scorer, just not a good fit for UK. And so I don't think Cal put on the full-court-press on Newman. Glad he didn't.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
I don't think Cal did. Cal moderately recruited him. But I think Cal saw what some of us saw, that Newman was a me-first player, a volume scorer, just not a good fit for UK. And so I don't think Cal put on the full-court-press on Newman. Glad he didn't.

Newman was the best available guard in the class. Cal wanted him because there was no one else. He also wanted him as a wing scorer, not a PG. Newman wanted to be the PG. We had Ulis and Briscoe as better options at PG. Newman did not want to accept being a wing scorer, so he went to MSU, where Howland promised him a shot at the PG spot.

Then we lucked out and Murray became available and was willing to accept the role as wing scorer for us. Newman is now a transfer sitting out next season. Murray is a lottery pick that is going to make a few million this next season while Newman enjoys the college life.

Just another episode of Cal knows best.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Two Former Kentucky Wildcats Selected in UFL Draft
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Recruiting Kentucky signs 'perfect fit' in Ryan Hampton, 'unique build and skillset' in Cherif Millogo
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball The Memorial Memo (EP. 76): Previewing Marshall + Clara Strack's WNBA Draft stock
  4. 04 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Braydon Hawthorne's offensive game is only beginning to reveal itself