Malik Newman to Kansas

BlueDevilish4857

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2016
68
8
0
I give you all of them but that one.

That Arkansas team was easily the best team in the country all year long. Not even close. It would have been an upset if anybody beat them in the tourney, including Duke.

Don't argue about this, it will make you look silly.
Ah ok I"ll take your word for it for 1994. I didn't start watching college basketball till the early 2000s but I thought Duke was the favorite in 1994 but maybe not then.
 

MNantz

Heisman
Dec 20, 2001
9,086
11,921
98
Kansas needs to change its name to Freedom university .'
there motto could be give me your tired give me your poor give me your five star recruits who want to ride the bench for a year and give me the ones with impermissible benefits or is it they will provide the impermissible benefits ?
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,113
88,985
98
By that same token, Duke was robbed of a title in 1994, 1998, 1999, 2002 and 2004 when we were clearly the best team in the country (UConn was debateable in 2004).

We were upset by Arkansas (1994), UK (1998), UConn (1999), Indiana (2002) and UConn (2004) so we got unlucky there.

For blue chip programs, luck cuts both way but in the Cal era UK has been extremely fortunate to do as well as they have in the NCAAT so expect a regression to the mean to be coming.

I hope ya"ll don't unfairly turn on Cal if he only gets you to 1 Final Four in the next 5 years and keep your expectations in check.

I was mocking you, idiot. Of course, luck runs both ways and you can claim luck in just about every game in college basketball.

I don't give a ish what you hope. Screw you, bandwagon loser.
 

Bluemoon725

All-Conference
Feb 18, 2013
2,883
4,175
113
Actually this article says the first black player on a team in the SEC (college basketball) was in 1967.

https://espn.go.com/classic/s/013101_texas_western_fitzpatrick.html
Well then, if you want to pigeonhole the argument, the title count would still be 4-2. UK's overall win record over Kansas is 22-7. Cal is 3-1 vs. Self at UK.

Any Kansas fan can try and change the argument, but the fact is that Kentucky is in the driver's seat of the rivalry, and it doesn't look to be changing anytime soon.
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,113
88,985
98
I give you all of them but that one.

That Arkansas team was easily the best team in the country all year long. Not even close. It would have been an upset if anybody beat them in the tourney, including Duke.

Don't argue about this, it will make you look silly.

I won't. UK in '98 and UConn in '99 were mild upsets. UK was basically the fifth 1-seed coming off B2B championship game appearances and UConn lost two games all year. I don't think UConn '04 was an upset at all. That was the preseason #1 team who was battling injuries all year. Once healthy in March, they were the best team.

I find this all the time with Duke "fans"- it's funny how I know more about their team than they do. That's what happens when 95% of your fanbase is bandwagon.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Well then, if you want to pigeonhole the argument, the title count would still be 4-2. UK's overall win record over Kansas is 22-7. Cal is 3-1 vs. Self at UK.

Any Kansas fan can try and change the argument, but the fact is that Kentucky is in the driver's seat of the rivalry, and it doesn't look to be changing anytime soon.

Not changing up anything, just clarifying your facts. How am I supposed to dispute that Kentucky has more National Titles and a winning record against KU?
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
I won't. UK in '98 and UConn in '99 were mild upsets. UK was basically the fifth 1-seed coming off B2B championship game appearances and UConn lost two games all year. I don't think UConn '04 was an upset at all. That was the preseason #1 team who was battling injuries all year. Once healthy in March, they were the best team.

I find this all the time with Duke "fans"- it's funny how I know more about their team than they do. That's what happens when 95% of your fanbase is bandwagon.

I didn't pay much attention to the rest of his list. His assessment of the 1994 Arkansas team had me focused on it.

Upon further review:

In 1998, Duke was the 1 seed, UK was the 2, so that was an upset. A mild one, but an upset.

IIRC, in 1999 Duke was the favorite to win it all from the beginning of the year. Duke looked unstoppable all year. UConn was right there, but it was a slight upset. I remember that I refused to watch the game because I thought Duke was going to win another, only to be pleasantly surprised when I read later that they had lost.

2004 UConn was the favorite, but by a small margin, pretty much the reverse of 1999. So, I have to agree with you on that one.

So really, I guess I give him UK in '98, UConn in '99, and IU in 2002 as upsets.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Not changing up anything, just clarifying your facts. How am I supposed to dispute that Kentucky has more National Titles and a winning record against KU?

It's understandable.

We are use to people wanting to focus on some timeframe that makes their programs look better.

UofL fans are always telling me, "Well, in 1980 the tourney expanded to blah, blah, blah... so really in that timeframe we have the same amount of titles as you."

Duke fans say, "Well, since Coach K arrived (which is that matters), Duke has 5 titles to your 3, so we are better."

UConn fans will say, "Well, if you start at 1999, then we are better than you because we have won 4 titles to 1 title for you."

UNC fans will say, "Since Roy arrived, we have 2 titles to your one."

UF fans use to talk about how Donovan winning two back to back made them superior to UK.

I'm sure Nova fans are saying, "All that really counts is right now, and we are the best, forget UK, Duke, and UCLA, history is overrated, it's 2016, that's all that counts."

Of course, UK fans say, "Lets count everything that is in the official record books (since 1939)."

I guess all that really matters is what "you" think and want to argue.

I'd rather be the one counting all of NCAA history, than someone cherry picking time spans to make an argument.
 

KneeBurns

Senior
Mar 18, 2006
2,052
516
0
Well then, if you want to pigeonhole the argument, the title count would still be 4-2. UK's overall win record over Kansas is 22-7. .

13-1 vs Ted Owens, in the 70s mostly, when none of the games were televised. We've been thru this many times here. You canceled on us when you hired Billy Clyde. Give Self 14 games vs. Billy Clyde and see what the series is.

Cal is 3-1 vs. Self at UK

Self is 4-3 vs Kentucky.


Any Kansas fan can try and change the argument, but the fact is that Kentucky is in the driver's seat of the rivalry, and it doesn't look to be changing anytime soon.

Not since the early 1980s. I already conceded the WWII era and the 70s. You can have em, I wasn't watching.
 

Bluemoon725

All-Conference
Feb 18, 2013
2,883
4,175
113
13-1 vs Ted Owens, in the 70s mostly, when none of the games were televised. We've been thru this many times here. You canceled on us when you hired Billy Clyde. Give Self 14 games vs. Billy Clyde and see what the series is.



Self is 4-3 vs Kentucky.




Not since the early 1980s. I already conceded the WWII era and the 70s. You can have em, I wasn't watching.
And because you weren't watching, that means it didn't happen right? I can't give Self 14 games vs Billy Clyde because guess what? It didn't happen. And because the games weren't televised, that means no one won the game either. Dude, you're hilarious. Please keep going with your rationale. It's ridiculously entertaining.

Kentucky is 22-7 vs Kansas all time, and has 5 more championships. Soak all up in it, because it's a reality no matter how much you try to wish it away and twist your narrative.

 
  • Like
Reactions: STL_Cat

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
Huh? If Booker wasn't there, then someone else would have taken his shots given the opportunity like Towns or the Harrisons or Lyles. I can't recall any tournament game for UK that year where he the clear "difference maker".
Yeah, others would have taken the shots, but that doesn't mean they would have made up for the points he provided.

So is Tyler Ulis more valuable to UK than Tyus Jones? Ulis stayed 2 years at UK and Jones didn't.
 

BlueDevilish4857

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2016
68
8
0
I won't. UK in '98 and UConn in '99 were mild upsets. UK was basically the fifth 1-seed coming off B2B championship game appearances and UConn lost two games all year. I don't think UConn '04 was an upset at all. That was the preseason #1 team who was battling injuries all year. Once healthy in March, they were the best team.

I find this all the time with Duke "fans"- it's funny how I know more about their team than they do. That's what happens when 95% of your fanbase is bandwagon.
A "mild upset" is still an upset. We can argue all day about UConn '04 but the fact is Vegas had Duke pegged as a favorite before that game tipped off.

I graduated from Duke undergrad a few years back by the way, I'm no bandwagon fan.

JayCatz44 said:
So is Tyler Ulis more valuable to UK than Tyus Jones? Ulis stayed 2 years at UK and Jones didn't.
No, Tyus led Duke to a national championship with his clutch shooting and was named the Final Four MOP. Tyler Ulis led Kentucky to a 2nd round loss at Indiana which even though clearly it wasn't his fault, that's all that people will remember.

In this case, Tyus' 1 year was more important than Ulis' 2 years.
 

BlueDevilish4857

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2016
68
8
0
It's understandable.

We are use to people wanting to focus on some timeframe that makes their programs look better.

UofL fans are always telling me, "Well, in 1980 the tourney expanded to blah, blah, blah... so really in that timeframe we have the same amount of titles as you."

Duke fans say, "Well, since Coach K arrived (which is that matters), Duke has 5 titles to your 3, so we are better."

UConn fans will say, "Well, if you start at 1999, then we are better than you because we have won 4 titles to 1 title for you."

UNC fans will say, "Since Roy arrived, we have 2 titles to your one."

UF fans use to talk about how Donovan winning two back to back made them superior to UK.

I'm sure Nova fans are saying, "All that really counts is right now, and we are the best, forget UK, Duke, and UCLA, history is overrated, it's 2016, that's all that counts."

Of course, UK fans say, "Lets count everything that is in the official record books (since 1939)."

I guess all that really matters is what "you" think and want to argue.

I'd rather be the one counting all of NCAA history, than someone cherry picking time spans to make an argument.
You have to create a reasonable cutoff though. Not too long ago, Yale was the winningest college football program of all time since it dominated the Ivies which were the only schools around in the late 1800s. Should that still count?
 

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
A "mild upset" is still an upset. We can argue all day about UConn '04 but the fact is Vegas had Duke pegged as a favorite before that game tipped off.

I graduated from Duke undergrad a few years back by the way, I'm no bandwagon fan.


No, Tyus led Duke to a national championship with his clutch shooting and was named the Final Four MOP. Tyler Ulis led Kentucky to a 2nd round loss at Indiana which even though clearly it wasn't his fault, that's all that people will remember.

In this case, Tyus' 1 year was more important than Ulis' 2 years.
Yep, I thought you would be selective like that. Booker is more valuable than Graham. He helped UK get to a Final Four (although you won't admit it) and Graham will never reach a Final Four. It's obvious you don't have a Duke education. You have been put in place over and over on this board.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Yep, I thought you would be selective like that. Booker is more valuable than Graham. He helped UK get to a Final Four (although you won't admit it) and Graham will never reach a Final Four. It's obvious you don't have a Duke education. You have been put in place over and over on this board.

How do you know Graham will never reach a Final Four or win a title?
 

JPScott

All-American
Sep 16, 2001
7,694
7,432
62
Actually this article says the first black player on a team in the SEC (college basketball) was in 1967.

https://espn.go.com/classic/s/013101_texas_western_fitzpatrick.html

I hope you realize that the fact that SEC basketball didn't integrate until starting in 1967 means that in the years prior to that time, UK was competing against integrated teams (non-conference and postseason) even though they themselves had no black players on their team.

In other words UK was actually at a competitive disadvantage during that time period. (UK faced black players starting in the late 40s and consistently throughout the 50s and 60s).
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
By that same token, Duke was robbed of a title in 1994, 1998, 1999, 2002 and 2004 when we were clearly the best team in the country (UConn was debateable in 2004).

We were upset by Arkansas (1994), UK (1998), UConn (1999), Indiana (2002) and UConn (2004) so we got unlucky there.

For blue chip programs, luck cuts both way but in the Cal era UK has been extremely fortunate to do as well as they have in the NCAAT so expect a regression to the mean to be coming.

I hope ya"ll don't unfairly turn on Cal if he only gets you to 1 Final Four in the next 5 years and keep your expectations in check.

Kentucky has had plenty of lucky shots on Final Four runs. Duke has had plenty of unlucky shots that have kept them out.
Duke has had plenty of lucky shots on Final Four runs. Kentucky has had plenty of unlucky shots that have kept them out.

You're revealing yourself as an embarrassing homer - by the fact that you try to downplay or ignore the latter two truths,
by the fact that you're trolling around - intentionally trying to rile people up - with predictions like 1 Final Four in 5 years or implying that Cal is incapable of winning a championship without AD,
by the fact that every time Duke is upset by an inferior team above, you chalk it up to "bad luck", and when it happens to Cal, you imply that it's a coaching shortcoming.

You can't sit here and pretend to be the calm, objective visiting fan when you're saying crap like that and implying that Cal can't coach. Again, go tweet Bilas with that latter opinion so that we can all watch you get bent over a barrel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aike

BlueDevilish4857

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2016
68
8
0
Kentucky has had plenty of lucky shots on Final Four runs. Duke has had plenty of unlucky shots that have kept them out.
Duke has had plenty of lucky shots on Final Four runs. Kentucky has had plenty of unlucky shots that have kept them out.

You're revealing yourself as an embarrassing homer - by the fact that you try to downplay or ignore the latter two truths,
by the fact that you're trolling around - intentionally trying to rile people up - with predictions like 1 Final Four in 5 years or implying that Cal is incapable of winning a championship without AD,
by the fact that every time Duke is upset by an inferior team above, you chalk it up to "bad luck", and when it happens to Cal, you imply that it's a coaching shortcoming.

You can't sit here and pretend to be the calm, objective visiting fan when you're saying crap like that and implying that Cal can't coach. Again, go tweet Bilas with that latter opinion so that we can all watch you get bent over a barrel.
Huh? Cal's a great coach, I'm not denying that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hoskins21

BlueDevilish4857

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2016
68
8
0
Yep, I thought you would be selective like that. Booker is more valuable than Graham. He helped UK get to a Final Four (although you won't admit it) and Graham will never reach a Final Four. It's obvious you don't have a Duke education. You have been put in place over and over on this board.
Tyus Jones was Duke's starting PG and our best player in the 2015 Final Four while Devin Booker was just a bench player on a loaded UK team that reached the Final Four that you. Do you not see the difference here?

Graham has already reached the Elite Eight as a Kansas starter and will most likely have 2 more shots to reach the Final Four and win the National Championship with stacked teams. I like his chances here.
 

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
Tyus Jones was Duke's starting PG and our best player in the 2015 Final Four while Devin Booker was just a bench player on a loaded UK team that reached the Final Four that you. Do you not see the difference here?

Graham has already reached the Elite Eight as a Kansas starter and will most likely have 2 more shots to reach the Final Four and win the National Championship with stacked teams. I like his chances here.
Yes, there's a difference between Jones and Booker. That wasn't the point. The point is that UK benefited more from Booker than Kansas has from Graham. That will be the case until Graham takes Kansas to a Final Four. Final Fours and championships are what matter. Considering Kansas has only 3 championships and hasn't been to the Final Four since 2012, I doubt he does anything but flame out of the NCAA tournament.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
You have to create a reasonable cutoff though. Not too long ago, Yale was the winningest college football program of all time since it dominated the Ivies which were the only schools around in the late 1800s. Should that still count?

Football has always been screwed up. No tourney. Most of the champions throughout the years were crowned by newspaper reporters. Most were disputed. You won't hear me crowing about a UK football championship because some writer deemed them "champions" because they had a good record 40 or 50 years ago.

The "reasonable cutoff" in basketball is well defined. 1939 is the first year of the NCAA tournament. It marks the official beginning of an official champion each year.

You want to ignore history, that's fine. Use your own set of criteria all you want. Use some cut off date that makes sense to you, but it is and will always be an opinion. My opinion is based on the "official" record books. That makes it fact not opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hoskins21

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
Football has always been screwed up. No tourney. Most of the champions throughout the years were crowned by newspaper reporters. Most were disputed. You won't hear me crowing about a UK football championship because some writer deemed them "champions" because they had a good record 40 or 50 years ago.

The "reasonable cutoff" in basketball is well defined. 1939 is the first year of the NCAA tournament. It marks the official beginning of an official champion each year.

You want to ignore history, that's fine. Use your own set of criteria all you want. Use some cut off date that makes sense to you, but it is and will always be an opinion. My opinion is based on the "official" record books. That makes it fact not opinion.
When Coach K disappears so will Duke. Many Dukies will have to root for someone else.
 

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Yes, there's a difference between Jones and Booker. That wasn't the point. The point is that UK benefited more from Booker than Kansas has from Graham. That will be the case until Graham takes Kansas to a Final Four. Final Fours and championships are what matter. Considering Kansas has only 3 championships and hasn't been to the Final Four since 2012, I doubt he does anything but flame out of the NCAA tournament.

How many total wins has Booker contributed to Kentucky's all-time record?

How many wins has and will Graham have contributed to KU's all-time record?

How many NCAA tournaments has Booker contributed to Kentucky's chances to win a national title?
How many NCAA tournaments has and will Graham have to add to KU's chances to win a national title?
 

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
How many total wins has Booker contributed to Kentucky's all-time record?

How many wins has and will Graham have contributed to KU's all-time record?

How many NCAA tournaments has Booker contributed to Kentucky's chances to win a national title?
How many NCAA tournaments has and will Graham have to add to KU's chances to win a national title?
Booker contributed to UK's best ever record and a Final Four. Not to mention, he helped put a 32 point whooping on Kansas. Has Graham helped Kansas reach their best ever record? Reach a Final Four? Nope!
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

KnowsAllTellsAll

Sophomore
Nov 9, 2014
811
111
0
Booker contributed to UK's best ever record and a Final Four. Not to mention, he helped put a 32 point whooping on Kansas. Has Graham helped Kansas reach their best ever record? Reach a Final Four? Nope!

"Best record ever?" Is that a meaningful statistic to anyone but a home school's fans? I believe you are conceding my position, by trying to change the value of measure. The questions relate to how many have and will continue to have the opportunity to add to each respective school's W/L record and NCAA title hopes.

ETA: Booker scored 5 points in that 32 point whooping of Kansas. Booker also had zero points in last year's Kentucky loss to Kansas. Graham had 11 points and 5 assists in that KU win.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
How many total wins has Booker contributed to Kentucky's all-time record?

How many wins has and will Graham have contributed to KU's all-time record?

How many NCAA tournaments has Booker contributed to Kentucky's chances to win a national title?
How many NCAA tournaments has and will Graham have to add to KU's chances to win a national title?

I guess the actual results defined by "contributions" has little bearing on Kansas fans since they now have to celebrate the "chance" at making a final four without actually making it.

you don't even know how pathetic you sound.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
You have to create a reasonable cutoff though. Not too long ago, Yale was the winningest college football program of all time since it dominated the Ivies which were the only schools around in the late 1800s. Should that still count?

What the hell are you blabbering about? Reasonable cutoff? A duke fan since 2004? seriously?

Not long ago yale was the winningest football program of all time, AND SO WAS UK in basketball. How about adding some context to that statement. Is Yale STILL dominant in football? Is UK STILL dominant in basketball? I wonder if your logic extends to baseball?

"Because the St. louis Browns are no longer relevant in major league baseball, all accomplishments will now be cutoff for the yankees pre-1985."

Just shut up.
 

hawkin

All-Conference
Jun 16, 2002
3,047
1,434
113
Back to Malik, i think sitting out a year will help the young man grow up a little. With him & a soph. Azubuike it will be a good inside out combo.
 

JayCatz44

Heisman
May 14, 2003
20,699
15,896
113
"Best record ever?" Is that a meaningful statistic to anyone but a home school's fans? I believe you are conceding my position, by trying to change the value of measure. The questions relate to how many have and will continue to have the opportunity to add to each respective school's W/L record and NCAA title hopes.

ETA: Booker scored 5 points in that 32 point whooping of Kansas. Booker also had zero points in last year's Kentucky loss to Kansas. Graham had 11 points and 5 assists in that KU win.
Booker: 1 final four
Graham: 0

End of discussion!
 

UKCAT5FAN

All-Conference
May 9, 2010
5,285
3,822
113
A "mild upset" is still an upset. We can argue all day about UConn '04 but the fact is Vegas had Duke pegged as a favorite before that game tipped off.

I graduated from Duke undergrad a few years back by the way, I'm no bandwagon fan.


No, Tyus led Duke to a national championship with his clutch shooting and was named the Final Four MOP. Tyler Ulis led Kentucky to a 2nd round loss at Indiana which even though clearly it wasn't his fault, that's all that people will remember.

In this case, Tyus' 1 year was more important than Ulis' 2 years.



Well, you can't say you were robbed if it was just a mild upset.



Also, you give Ulis the team that Jones had at Duke and I guarantee he wins the tournament. No doubt about it. You can't say that a player is better than the other or more valuable solely based on a team accomplishment.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Braydon Hawthorne's offensive game is only beginning to reveal itself
  2. 02 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri is Officially the "Who Wants It More?" Bowl
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Basketball It's not all bad: Five things Kentucky has done well this season
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Recruiting 5-star C Cherif Millogo signs with Kentucky