Wait, how many times have we been to the CWS since Polk was let go? One! Polk took MSU to four CWS just during Templeton’s tenure. And you want crap on a legend like Polk as being a mistake? Come on! Croom years were bad, but that doesn’t define Templeton. Are we the only school to have unsuccessful coaching hires? Plenty of teams have had their moments at the bottom. As a reminder Templeton gave us a Final Four and an SECC game. Appreciate you Templeton!
There's soooooooo much wrong with this post.
I would say that bringing Ron Polk back was possibly the single biggest mistake in MSU baseball history. It set our program back 10 years and allowed Ole Miss AND USM to catch up to us for a little while. Cohen's tenure was vastly superior to Polk's- remind me of that time when Polk took us to the National Finals? Cohen won the SEC and SEC Tournament and essentially rebuilt our program into what it is at the moment and allowed for a seamless transition to one of the best head coaching prospects in all of baseball which also negatively affected LSU at the same time. Cohen also built the interest in baseball back up to where we could build the new baseball stadium.
Bringing Polk back created apathy followed by decline. And while the CWS appearance and SEC Tournament Championship were nice reminders of what we could be and were at that point in time bringing Polk back tarnished Polk's legacy and ultimately led to division amongst our fans that Cohen had to fight and overcome his entire career at MSU. Our recruiting in baseball became a total joke- you had to go to the camp and be deemed not quite good enough to be drafted because we weren't going to deal with that whole draft thing. And this is only after your junior year in high school at a time where baseball recruiting at that point was already moving in a direction where relationships were built by a prospect's sophomore year if not earlier.
All because LT decided to do the easy thing a please some cronies and Ron Polk- when he could have VERY easily hired Paul Manieri from Notre Dame at that time who was literally begging for our job with a phone call.
I still personally don't blame Polk for Polk II as much as I blame LT. Sometimes you have to say "no"- and that's what LT's job as the AD was.
And don't worry about us going back to Omaha- I suspect we're about to become mainstays there based on what I saw Cann do last year without a pitching staff. In fact going there this year wouldn't shock me at all. And once Cann starts bringing in his recruits starting next year it's going to blow Polk's tenure away.