Just gonna leave this here....

AllInBlitz

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2021
2,052
4,591
0
Lia Thomas, a 22-year-old transgender woman who swims for the University of Pennsylvania, is dominating in the pool this season, Axios' Jeff Tracy writes.

Why it matters: Thomas' record-breaking campaign comes amid a debate over transgender inclusion in sport — one that has become increasingly politicized as anti-trans legislation sweeps across the U.S.

Catch up quick: Thomas, assigned male at birth, competed on the men's team at Penn from 2017-20, though in 2018 she realized that she identified as a woman.

  • In May 2019, she began testosterone suppression therapy, and after the Ivy League canceled the 2020-21 season, she joined the women's team last fall as a fifth-year senior.
  • NCAA rules state that a trans woman can compete against women as long as she's undergone one year of testosterone suppression.
By the numbers: At one meet in early December, Thomas won the 200-yard free by seven seconds, the 500 free by 14 seconds and the 1,650 free by 38 seconds, setting two Ivy League records and posting the fastest time of the year among college women in the 200 and 500.

  • Of note: While Thomas' broken records have made news, her times relative to the women's field are generally comparable to what her times relative to the men's field had been.
  • Her best time in the 500 pre-transition (4:18.72) was 12 seconds off the men's record (4:06.32); now, her best time (4:34.06) is 10 seconds off the women's record (4:24.06), having lost 16 seconds post-transition.
Driving the news: Thomas won two races at her final home meet on Saturday. She also lost two to Yale's Iszac Henig, a transgender man who can compete against women because he hasn't begun hormone therapy.

Thomas is congratulated after winning the 200-yard freestyle event. Photo: Hunter Martin/Getty Images
What they're saying: Thomas just wants to "continue to do the sport I love as my authentic self," she told SwimSwam last month.

  • "My mental health was not very good," she said of the 2018-19 season. "It was a lot of unease, basically just feeling trapped in my body."
  • Since transitioning, that's improved: "Being in a swimsuit 20 hours a week has helped me accept my body as it is [and] be comfortable in who I am."
The other side: Some believe Thomas holds an unfair advantage even after two-plus years of testosterone suppression.

  • "At stake here is the integrity of women's sports," a group of Penn swim parents wrote after that December meet. "The precedent being set ... is a direct threat to female athletes."
  • "I think the NCAA policy issued in 2011 was not really based much on scientific knowledge," one parent told WashPost. "So this is all about the rules. It's not really about Lia. She followed the rules."
What's next: Thomas, an Austin native, will be a favorite at next month's Ivy League championships, and she's already qualified for the NCAA championships in March.
 

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
curious if the athletes she competes against seem to have as big a problem with it as the parents who are complaining do
 

cyclotiger

Heisman
Feb 17, 2014
6,933
14,095
113
Stupid this is
This is where I have problems with the LGBT
Ion care what you prefer sexually. That's between you and the Man upstairs. I do have a problem with them using mental health as an excuse to include them in things intended for competition. Mostly it's men trying to compete with women. Don't see many women trying to come compete with men. Gotta draw the line somewhere.
 

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
do you honestly think male athletes are going through M-F transition so that they can more favorably compete in college athletics?
 

AllInBlitz

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2021
2,052
4,591
0
do you honestly think male athletes are going through M-F transition so that they can more favorably compete in college athletics?
Not at all. Honestly I can’t imagine what battles someone is facing in their head that they decide it’s easier to deal with the ridicule from society.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WapPride

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
No but that is irrelevant.

Biological men have no place in women's sports ... period ... full stop
shrug, it's still a work in process - maybe they need to change it to 2 full years of hormone suppression before being allowed to compete. i don't know the answer, but i don't believe just blindly banning transgender athletes from competing is the right choice
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,362
28,922
103
shrug, it's still a work in process - maybe they need to change it to 2 full years of hormone suppression before being allowed to compete. i don't know the answer, but i don't believe just blindly banning transgender athletes from competing is the right choice
no one is for banning athletes ... You compete in the sport which matches your sex. Males compete against males, females against females. Even with hormone suppression, biological males have intrinsic advantages over females

We can certainly debate "gender" and certainly most definitely can debate "gender roles", but sex is not debatable. You cannot change your sex, and if you disagree you are a "activist" whose opinions are not supported by science.

No where in mammalian zoology is "sex" (male vs female) left up for self interpretation. Humans are not special in this regard.

you were born Jack and want to be called Jane? I can do that
you want your pronouns to be her/she when youre clearly a he/him? I can do that
you want to be called "they'? Its grammatically strange, so be patient with me, but I can do that
I can do these things, because Im polite

You want me to agree that biological males can give birth?
... can menstruate?
... that "sex" is fluid?
... that males can be females and females can be males based on their feelings?
... that biological men have any place in woman sports?
That will never happen
 

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
no one is for banning athletes ... You compete in the sport which matches your sex. Males compete against males, females against females. Even with hormone suppression, biological males have intrinsic advantages over females

We can certainly debate "gender" and certainly most definitely can debate "gender roles", but sex is not debatable. You cannot change your sex, and if you disagree you are a "activist" whose opinions are not supported by science.

No where in mammalian zoology is "sex" (male vs female) left up for self interpretation. Humans are not special in this regard.

you were born Jack and want to be called Jane? I can do that
you want your pronouns to be her/she when youre clearly a he/him? I can do that
you want to be called "they'? Its grammatically strange, so be patient with me, but I can do that
I can do these things, because Im polite

You want me to agree that biological males can give birth?
... can menstruate?
... that "sex" is fluid?
... that males can be females and females can be males based on their feelings?
... that biological men have any place in woman sports?
That will never happen
no argument from me here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

nytigerfan

Heisman
Dec 9, 2004
10,651
14,280
102
Lia Thomas, a 22-year-old transgender woman who swims for the University of Pennsylvania, is dominating in the pool this season, Axios' Jeff Tracy writes.

Why it matters: Thomas' record-breaking campaign comes amid a debate over transgender inclusion in sport — one that has become increasingly politicized as anti-trans legislation sweeps across the U.S.

Catch up quick: Thomas, assigned male at birth, competed on the men's team at Penn from 2017-20, though in 2018 she realized that she identified as a woman.

  • In May 2019, she began testosterone suppression therapy, and after the Ivy League canceled the 2020-21 season, she joined the women's team last fall as a fifth-year senior.
  • NCAA rules state that a trans woman can compete against women as long as she's undergone one year of testosterone suppression.
By the numbers: At one meet in early December, Thomas won the 200-yard free by seven seconds, the 500 free by 14 seconds and the 1,650 free by 38 seconds, setting two Ivy League records and posting the fastest time of the year among college women in the 200 and 500.

  • Of note: While Thomas' broken records have made news, her times relative to the women's field are generally comparable to what her times relative to the men's field had been.
  • Her best time in the 500 pre-transition (4:18.72) was 12 seconds off the men's record (4:06.32); now, her best time (4:34.06) is 10 seconds off the women's record (4:24.06), having lost 16 seconds post-transition.
Driving the news: Thomas won two races at her final home meet on Saturday. She also lost two to Yale's Iszac Henig, a transgender man who can compete against women because he hasn't begun hormone therapy.

Thomas is congratulated after winning the 200-yard freestyle event. Photo: Hunter Martin/Getty Images
What they're saying: Thomas just wants to "continue to do the sport I love as my authentic self," she told SwimSwam last month.

  • "My mental health was not very good," she said of the 2018-19 season. "It was a lot of unease, basically just feeling trapped in my body."
  • Since transitioning, that's improved: "Being in a swimsuit 20 hours a week has helped me accept my body as it is [and] be comfortable in who I am."
The other side: Some believe Thomas holds an unfair advantage even after two-plus years of testosterone suppression.

  • "At stake here is the integrity of women's sports," a group of Penn swim parents wrote after that December meet. "The precedent being set ... is a direct threat to female athletes."
  • "I think the NCAA policy issued in 2011 was not really based much on scientific knowledge," one parent told WashPost. "So this is all about the rules. It's not really about Lia. She followed the rules."
What's next: Thomas, an Austin native, will be a favorite at next month's Ivy League championships, and she's already qualified for the NCAA championships in March.

I am pretty liberal, especially on social issues, but I dont think this is right. The only solution I can think of is a third competitive category for trans.

I also wonder, would it be possible for Russia or China to slip some trans athletes into the Olympics to compete with women?
 

Clemson Carl3

Senior
Oct 4, 2011
628
728
70
shrug, it's still a work in process - maybe they need to change it to 2 full years of hormone suppression before being allowed to compete. i don't know the answer, but i don't believe just blindly banning transgender athletes from competing is the right choice
I got an idea. Go join the trans league. Ohh wait there isn’t one? Well with the amount of trans on TV and media you think there would be enough to create their own division of sports. Women’s sports is no place for a once man to compete in, it’s that simple. Idc how many estrogen pills you take.
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,362
28,922
103
I am pretty liberal, especially on social issues, but I dont think this is right. The only solution I can think of is a third competitive category for trans.

I also wonder, would it be possible for Russia or China to slip some trans athletes into the Olympics to compete with women?
fun fact: China and Russia arent exactly Trans/LBGTQ+ friendly countries. I dont think they are "throw you off roof tops" bad like several Middle East countries but .....Russia specifically is known for doping as recently as the last Winter Olympics .... they rather jack their women up on steroids versus letting men complete as women.

...side fun fact: In my single days ... it was my experience that Russian women do not need anything that would increase their aggressiveness.
 
Oct 24, 2012
9,258
13,737
93
Not at all. Honestly I can’t imagine what battles someone is facing in their head that they decide it’s easier to deal with the ridicule from society.
I used to think this until it hit my family. Since then, I've been pretty dialed in to the whole movement and societal ridicule is not nearly as bad as you'd imagine. It feels quite the opposite now where it's practically celebrated and praised.
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,362
28,922
103
soooooooooooo in a surprise to no one ... yesterday the NCAA provided their guidance on Transgender athletes. Their guidance? Oh it was too :

"The new approach to allowing transgender athletes will follow a sport-by-sport model similarly adopted by the U.S. and international Olympic committees, Sports Illustrated reported." ... [bunch a BS woke SJW limp meaningless buzzwords] ... Each particular sport’s national governing body will be responsible for determining transgender athlete participation. If a sport does not have a national governing body, the international federation policy will be enacted, Sports Illustrated reported. "

So ... we have already gone 10 rounds on the topic itself .... no use beating that dead horse anymore ..... BUT ....what I find amazing is that the NCAA ...once again .... does nothing.


quasi-serious question here .... what does the NCAA actually do?
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Dabo Swinney and the scrutiny from within
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football The day after for Clemson Football
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Pearman, Denson lead Clemson past Duke in upset win
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson upends double-digit favorite Duke 20-10
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson - Duke Postgame Notes